Today's player ratings

[Elysium]

Amos 6
Connolly 7
Bamba 7.5
Morrison 7.5
Bennett 7
Ralls 6
Harris 6
Gunnarson 6.5
Whittingham 5.5
Hoilett 7
Gounongbe 4.5

Pilkington 5
Richardson N/A

[WJ99mobile]

Amos 6
Connolly 7
Bamba 7.5
Morrison 7.5
Bennett 7
Ralls 6
Harris 6
Gunnarson 6.5
Whittingham 5.5
Hoilett 7
Gounongbe 4.5

Pilkington 5
Richardson N/A

Thank **** I don't rely on your ratings or reporting

[The Bob Banker Spanker]

Unfair on Fred

[binman]

Amos 6
Connolly 7
Bamba 7.5
Morrison 7.5
Bennett 7
Ralls 6
Harris 6
Gunnarson 6.5
Whittingham 5.5
Hoilett 7
Gounongbe 4.5

Pilkington 5
Richardson N/A

Thought Gunnarson was our best player breaking up a lot of their play - Harris did better than your mark suggests and was our only threat

Fred - dear me - I would say he is the antithesis of a Warnock player - no dog in the boy at all - mind you the nearest offensive player was at least 20 yards from the poor bugger.

[Ainsley Harriott]

Unfair on Fred

Yep. I'd have given him a 2 at most.

[jon1959]

Unfair on Fred

Thought Gunnarson was our best player breaking up a lot of their play - Harris did better than your mark suggests and was our only threat

Fred - dear me - I would say he is the antithesis of a Warnock player - no dog in the boy at all - mind you the nearest offensive player was at least 20 yards from the poor bugger.

Yep. I'd have given him a 2 at most.

Warnock went out of his way in the post-match press conference to praise Fred and Kadeem. Said Fred did a great job for the team in the first hour. Interesting.

[Tandy]

Warnock went out of his way in the post-match press conference to praise Fred and Kadeem. Said Fred did a great job for the team in the first hour. Interesting.

Well Colin is not going to say they were shit is he

[MacAdder]

Warnock went out of his way in the post-match press conference to praise Fred and Kadeem. Said Fred did a great job for the team in the first hour. Interesting.

Jason Perry did the same on Radio Wales, praising his winning of free kicks.
Without watching the game, and although I've watched Fred a number of times this season, your guys' ratings seem harsh considering who we were playing.

Personally i am well happy with nil nil

[Cyclops]

Amos 6
Connolly 6
Bamba 8
Morrison 7
Bennett 6
Ralls 6
Harris 5
Gunnarson 7
Whittingham 5
Hoilett 5
Gounongbe 3

[MacAdder]

Amos 6
Connolly 6
Bamba 8
Morrison 7
Bennett 6
Ralls 6
Harris 5
Gunnarson 7
Whittingham 5
Hoilett 5
Gounongbe 3

Okay.... sounds like maybe Jason Perry was just being kind then

[Tandy]

Amos 5
Connolly 5
Bamba 8
Morrison 7
Bennett 5
Ralls 5
Harris 5
Gunnarson 7
Whittingham 4
Hoilett 5
Gounongbe 5

[jon1959]

Amos 5
Connolly 5
Bamba 8
Morrison 7
Bennett 5
Ralls 5
Harris 5
Gunnarson 7
Whittingham 4
Hoilett 5
Gounongbe 5

Oi. You can't do 'Whittingham 4'. That's copyright!

[City123]

Amos 6
Connolly 4
Bamba 8
Morrison 7
Bennett 5
Ralls 5
Harris 7
Gunnarson 8
Whittingham 5
Hoilett 6
Gounongbe 6

[Elysium]

Oi. You can't do 'Whittingham 4'. That's copyright!

I agree, that's why I gave him 5.5

[Vimana.]

Having seen the highlights, Amos seemed to have been worthy of better than a 5 / 6.
What did he do wrong - in an 0-0 - to lose 40-50% of his potential rating?

[Elysium]

Having seen the highlights, Amos seemed to have been worthy of better than a 5 / 6.
What did he do wrong - in an 0-0 - to lose 40-50% of his potential rating?

Thanks to a very good performance by the back four, reflected in the scores attributed to them, our goalkeeper had a quiet game only having to make a handful of saves with only 4 shots on target all game.

You can't give a 7 or 8 out of 10 if a goalkeeper has little to do. I hope he continues to get 5/6's each game for the same reason.

[life on mars]

Best player's with 7's
Harris
Amos
Bennett
Sol Bamba
Connolly
Gunnerson

[Vimana.]

Thanks to a very good performance by the back four, reflected in the scores attributed to them, our goalkeeper had a quiet game only having to make a handful of saves with only 4 shots on target all game.

You can't give a 7 or 8 out of 10 if a goalkeeper has little to do. I hope he continues to get 5/6's each game for the same reason.

Yeah, ta.
I supposed it was kinda that.
Ratings are tough on 'Keepers ;) Rather inverse compared to outfield players!

[Elysium]

Yeah, ta.
I supposed it was kinda that.
Ratings are tough on 'Keepers ;) Rather inverse compared to outfield players!

Thank you for being civil. It is very much appreciated.

[TH63]

I think Fred deserved a higher mark, but other than that I broadly agree.

[NYCBlue]

Thanks to a very good performance by the back four, reflected in the scores attributed to them, our goalkeeper had a quiet game only having to make a handful of saves with only 4 shots on target all game.

You can't give a 7 or 8 out of 10 if a goalkeeper has little to do. I hope he continues to get 5/6's each game for the same reason.

A clean sheet has to be worth a 7.

[TH63]

A clean sheet has to be worth a 7.

If he had pulled off several great saves then I'd agree, but the reality is he didn't have a lot to do.

[Elysium]

A clean sheet has to be worth a 7.

Not if he had little to do, no.

Two saves of note throughout the whole game. I agree he did absolutely nothing wrong but thanks to the performance of the back four he had a pretty easy, comfortable day. Did nothing wrong at all. Six out of ten a well justified rating.

[life on mars]

If he had pulled off several great saves then I'd agree, but the reality is he didn't have a lot to do.

There's a broader range of a goalkeeper skills that is beyond just great saves :

Communication
Positioning
Distribution
Installing confidence for back passes.
Authority in the air.
Bossing the box.
Able to get down quickly to low difficult shots.
Use of feet.

He delivered again and has been an excellent addition to our club,well worth a 7 today

[TH63]

There's a broader range of a goalkeeper skills that is beyond just great saves :

Communication
Positioning
Distribution
Installing confidence for back passes.
Authority in the air.
Bossing the box.
Able to get down quickly to low difficult shots.
Use of feet.

He delivered again and has been an excellent addition to our club,well worth a 7 today

Good point