Player of (Half) The Year

Printable View

11-12-23, 18:47
Tuerto

Player of (Half) The Year

Ramsey would have been in it, But for obvious reasons....

So my Nomination goes to Goutas, closely followed by NG and McGuiness.

Most Improved a toss up between NG, Mcguiness and Tanner-I'll go Tanner for obvious reasons

A new category for Ugbo-Player with absolutely zero noticeable attributes on a football pitch.
11-12-23, 19:05
WJ99mobile

Re: Player of (Half) The Year

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tuerto

Ramsey would have been in it, But for obvious reasons....

So my Nomination goes to Goutas, closely followed by NG and McGuiness.

Most Improved a toss up between NG, Mcguiness and Tanner-I'll go Tanner for obvious reasons

A new category for Ugbo-Player with absolutely zero noticeable attributes on a football pitch.

Ramsey head and shoulders above anyone so even with the injury still can be considered

Most improved I’ll agree with Tanner because he started from such a low base
11-12-23, 19:06
the other bob wilson

Re: Player of (Half) The Year

Ng for me, Tanner for most improved although he’s in danger of going backwards a bit in recent weeks.
11-12-23, 19:10
Robin Friday's Ghost

Re: Player of (Half) The Year

I'd go for NG too. He's so consistent and consistently good.
11-12-23, 19:13
BLUETIT

Re: Player of (Half) The Year

Ramsey, just for being here
11-12-23, 19:17
2b2bdoo

Re: Player of (Half) The Year

NG and Goutas performance wise.

Although I would say Siopis is our most important player.
11-12-23, 19:40
Blooburd

Re: Player of (Half) The Year

Easy to overlook NG because of his consistent improvement. But if he was a new signing we'd be raving about him :)

other than that similar to the OP, mcguiness followed by goutas..if goutas started how he has played lately he'd be a closer second.

Must be said though.. Ralls seems to be the biggest impact to our ability to attack. But personally ive always thought Ralls was wayyyy under rated on here
11-12-23, 20:19
Pedro de la Rosa

Re: Player of (Half) The Year

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tuerto

Ramsey would have been in it, But for obvious reasons....

So my Nomination goes to Goutas, closely followed by NG and McGuiness.

Most Improved a toss up between NG, Mcguiness and Tanner-I'll go Tanner for obvious reasons

A new category for Ugbo-Player with absolutely zero noticeable attributes on a football pitch.

Any of the back 4 are contender but I'd go Goutas. The back 4 are as good as anyone outside the top 4.

Ugbo is absolutely awful, until he gets a chance and then he's quite good. He's a really weird player.

Ralls has improved loads, too. And his corners are outstanding, he must have a fair few assists.
11-12-23, 20:24
Tuerto

Re: Player of (Half) The Year

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pedro de la Rosa

Any of the back 4 are contender but I'd go Goutas. The back 4 are as good as anyone outside the top 4.

Ugbo is absolutely awful, until he gets a chance and then he's quite good. He's a really weird player.

Ralls has improved loads, too. And his corners are outstanding, he must have a fair few assists.

Ralls is playing with much more quality, As alluded to by Blooburd as well. He seems more relaxed. Ugbo must've been one of those kids who scored 150 goals a season during his junior years and nothing else. I've never seen a player like him. He does **** all.
11-12-23, 20:27
2b2bdoo

Re: Player of (Half) The Year

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tuerto

Ralls is playing with much more quality, As alluded to by Blooburd as well. He seems more relaxed. Ugbo must've been one of those kids who scored 150 goals a season during his junior years and nothing else. I've never seen a player like him. He does **** all.

Doesn’t say much for Isak Davies record, Ugbo scored for fun in that league.
11-12-23, 20:33
olderblue

Re: Player of (Half) The Year

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tuerto

Ralls is playing with much more quality, As alluded to by Blooburd as well. He seems more relaxed. Ugbo must've been one of those kids who scored 150 goals a season during his junior years and nothing else. I've never seen a player like him. He does **** all.

Have to agree, Ugbo closely followed by Robinson for the what the **** does he actually do award🤷*♂️🤷*♂️🤷*♂️
11-12-23, 20:35
City123

Re: Player of (Half) The Year

Quote:

Originally Posted by 2b2bdoo

Doesn’t say much for Isak Davies record, Ugbo scored for fun in that league.

He then scored 3 goals in 18 for a better club in that same league the next season, he also failed badly in League 1 but was part of the good England u17 side that won the Toulon Tournament alongside the likes of Reece James and David Brooks. A really weird player
11-12-23, 20:35
MOZZER2

Re: Player of (Half) The Year

NG for me
11-12-23, 20:36
City123

Re: Player of (Half) The Year

Does Alnwick deserve a shout for most improved?
11-12-23, 20:36
Pedro de la Rosa

Re: Player of (Half) The Year

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tuerto

Ralls is playing with much more quality, As alluded to by Blooburd as well. He seems more relaxed. Ugbo must've been one of those kids who scored 150 goals a season during his junior years and nothing else. I've never seen a player like him. He does **** all.

Yeh, agree with all of that. Ralls is a good player who has been held back by a succession of crap managers. It is great to see him playing so well.

Ugbo is the laziest player I've ever seen. He can't pass, beat a man, hold the ball up and then half a chance and he scores. I think he'll make way in Jan.

Re 2b2bdoo's point on Isaak Davies, he's scoring for a crap side. All Davies has to be is a half decent Champ player, same as Colwill. He shouldn't be judged against Ramsey etc.
11-12-23, 20:44
2b2bdoo

Re: Player of (Half) The Year

Quote:

Originally Posted by City123

He then scored 3 goals in 18 for a better club in that same league the next season, he also failed badly in League 1 but was part of the good England u17 side that won the Toulon Tournament alongside the likes of Reece James and David Brooks. A really weird player

He clearly knows where the goal is, I think he needs a certain team and style, probably someone alongside him.
11-12-23, 21:03
Wash DC Blue

Re: Player of (Half) The Year

Perry Ng.
He has been fantastic most games.
11-12-23, 21:14
jon1959

Re: Player of (Half) The Year

Another vote for Ng.
11-12-23, 21:20
Mr Soul '68

Re: Player of (Half) The Year

NG for me, followed by McGuiness.
11-12-23, 22:00
Pedro de la Rosa

Re: Player of (Half) The Year

Quote:

Originally Posted by City123

Does Alnwick deserve a shout for most improved?

Yes, he flapped at everything last season, he really worried me. I didn't think it was crazy Allsop was number 1, and every manager thought the same. Now, I'm positive we kept the right keeper.
11-12-23, 22:02
Pedro de la Rosa

Re: Player of (Half) The Year

Quote:

Originally Posted by 2b2bdoo

He clearly knows where the goal is, I think he needs a certain team and style, probably someone alongside him.

I think he'd score if he played alongside Moore but I don't think you can carry him in this league, certainly if you want to get into the top 6. He'd probably be worth it for a Huddersfield etc.
11-12-23, 22:11
2b2bdoo

Re: Player of (Half) The Year

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pedro de la Rosa

I think he'd score if he played alongside Moore but I don't think you can carry him in this league, certainly if you want to get into the top 6. He'd probably be worth it for a Huddersfield etc.

Agree, he’s not for me. A useful sub at the moment but little else.
12-12-23, 07:48
North Cardiff Blue

Re: Player of (Half) The Year

Quote:

Originally Posted by the other bob wilson

Ng for me, Tanner for most improved although he’s in danger of going backwards a bit in recent weeks.

Agreed :thumbup:
12-12-23, 07:50
North Cardiff Blue

Re: Player of (Half) The Year

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pedro de la Rosa

Any of the back 4 are contender but I'd go Goutas. The back 4 are as good as anyone outside the top 4.

Ugbo is absolutely awful, until he gets a chance and then he's quite good. He's a really weird player.

Ralls has improved loads, too. And his corners are outstanding, he must have a fair few assists.

We've got some decent players, nice to have so many in contention.
12-12-23, 10:39
Rock_Flock_of_Five

Re: Player of (Half) The Year

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tuerto

Ramsey would have been in it, But for obvious reasons....

So my Nomination goes to Goutas, closely followed by NG and McGuiness.

Most Improved a toss up between NG, Mcguiness and Tanner-I'll go Tanner for obvious reasons

A new category for Ugbo-Player with absolutely zero noticeable attributes on a football pitch.

Perry NG was both the Players' Player of the Year and the Supporters' Player of the Year last season. Based on that, while his game (thankfully) is still improving, I'm not sure he can be considered for the 'Most Improved' category.

Someone like Jack Alnwick would be more suitable for such an accolade.

All times are GMT. The time now is 02:59.