take a look at the highlights, crowded 6-yard area but no-one is near being offside :facepalm:
Not sure if the Ifollow highlights will work for you but here goes:
https://www.cardiffcityfc.co.uk/ifollow/
Printable View
take a look at the highlights, crowded 6-yard area but no-one is near being offside :facepalm:
Not sure if the Ifollow highlights will work for you but here goes:
https://www.cardiffcityfc.co.uk/ifollow/
Asks me to buy a pass. :frown:
I think it was the ball back to Hoilett that Monk thinks Junior was offside. I wasn't sure at the time.
Good spot, Penarth - even then not sure he was as camera spoils a decent view
is he also complaining that the ref didnt award us the most blatant penalty you'll see?
We thought it that was offside at first, but the replay shows a Brum player on the goal line as the ball was played.Quote:
Originally Posted by Penarth Blues
Definitely offside. The guy on the line when the ball goes in the goal wasn't there when Paterson mishit his shot back to Hoilett.Quote:
Originally Posted by Harry Monk
A good view of it here. You can count all eleven Birmingham players and see Hoilett's feet as Paterson plays it.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_puPoHjfnEM
That is terrible.Quote:
Originally Posted by Loramski
My sympathies go out to the great up and coming manager Gary Monk . 2 sackings in one season would be awful...just awful..
Looks offside to me, but can't be sure from the camera angle.Quote:
Originally Posted by Jimmy the Jock
Cardiff also had a penalty appeal turned down, was it a penalty?
Yeah, you are right. Hoilett is on the by-line when that shot is made. The ball goes to him, and he is probably in line with the 'keeper, but ahead of all other players. As you say, they can be counted. Warnock was scathing about the officials again this weekend. Being a "qualified ref" means he is automatically correct! Strange, then, that he didn't mention this bit of good fortune amongst his complaints for the referee.Quote:
Originally Posted by Loramski
Have you noticed the way he attempts to look studious? In reality he’s most probably got things fluttering around his brain like Dougal from Father Ted.Quote:
Originally Posted by Jimmy the Jock
:hehe:Quote:
Originally Posted by splott parker
Monk is a bit thick, but he's too thick to realise he is a bit thick.
Are you ‘up the road’ tomorrow Jim? Me & Michael are doing Brentford.Quote:
Originally Posted by splott parker
Why would he or why should he?Quote:
Originally Posted by Badly Ironed Shirt
This would be down to Monk to bring up, which he did.
In any case, it doesn't alter the fact that the referee got it wrong in which case Warnock's (also Monk's) complaints about him are justified.
Are you sure you support Cardiff City?
In fairness to BIS, he is consistent. When Pep was moaning about fouls on his players BIS said 'Why doesn't Pep ever mention the fouls that his own players commit?'.Quote:
Originally Posted by MacAdder
Oh wait, no he didn't.
He just took the anti-cardiff city stance that he takes in every thread, you even entertaining the thought that he supports city?
Hes a silly billy ,if he' s studying performanes his keeper could do with some advise on the first goal, and his defenders were woeful on the other two, bugger all to do with the referee.
It's a bizarre one. A split second earlier and Hoilett wasn't even on the field of play.Quote:
Originally Posted by Loramski
It's odd how the linesman and all but about two of the Birmingham players miss it. I suppose there's usually a man (or two) on the post in that situation so you wouldn't expect an offside but it's not even a close call.Quote:
Originally Posted by Eric the Half a Bee
Agreed. It's definitely offside. Blatantly. It's such an odd situation that virtually everyone missed it :hehe:Quote:
Originally Posted by Loramski
Our 'penalty' was an odd one too. I'm not sure if the contact doesn't come just outside the area but there must be contact because Hoilett wouldn't have kicked the ground otherwise, it's not obvious where it happens though. I guess the ref just doesn't see it and assumes Hoilett has got himself in a tangle.Quote:
Originally Posted by Eric the Half a Bee
Warnock is notorious for whining about referees, and his complaints are backed up by the fact he is a qualified ref. Which, to some people, means he is always right. After a while it gets a bit tedious to see referees blamed for poor results.Quote:
Originally Posted by MacAdder
That was an entirely different conversation, ome where I spoke specifically about Bennetts challenge, and not the straw men that were being proffered as a ridiculous defense of Bennett for nothing other than tribalism.Quote:
Originally Posted by Eric Cartman
I've been looking for the highlights everywhere for that penalty appeal. I was told it was a blatant penalty, and yet another sign that the refs have it in for Cardiff. Your description indicates it wasn't so clean cut, and I haven't heard much about it apart from one particular friend who is incensed.Quote:
Originally Posted by Loramski
Correct, referees are not really affecting results - but if you listen to managers and some fans, they make it sound like every bad result is the sole work of a bent ref!Quote:
Originally Posted by life on mars