Not really pulling up trees at thier respective clubs.
Printable View
Not really pulling up trees at thier respective clubs.
Weren’t exactly lumberjacks here.
Reid playing in a CM role isn’t he?
Zohore’s missed the last three games through injury. Reid has been playing well for Fulham.Quote:
Originally Posted by life on mars
Ive watched both in TV games , I may have to go to specsavers they didnt look that good .Quote:
Originally Posted by The Lone Gunman
One game each then?Quote:
Originally Posted by life on mars
Think i saw them twice and a few highlight games , their performances left me so uninteresting , It left me thinking oh well . I thought after all the comments about them leaving and prospering at better clubs would see them deliver more than they have .Quote:
Originally Posted by dembethewarrior
Has he really ?Quote:
Originally Posted by The Lone Gunman
2 assists no goals in 12. Average rating of 6.5
According to whoscored statistical analysis Pack and Ralls both averaging just under 7.0, hes also scoring lower than all of our other starting midfielders and attacking players.
Flint who according to some fans has been awful is City’s highest ranked player, with Morrison 2nd
Source https://www.whoscored.com/Teams/188/Show/Wales-Cardiff
If we're using WhoScored analysis then Smithies has been one of our worst players. Bennett, Glatzel, Murphy and Madine have been better than Peltier, Hoilett and Whyte. Do you agree with that?Quote:
Originally Posted by Lawnmower
Using WhoScored for a proper analysis is like trusting Garth Brooks' Team of the Week for accuracy.
Some of this stuff is bollocks, isn't it? People seem to use it when it suits their opinion :hehe:Quote:
Originally Posted by Heisenberg
Definitely. Flint is rated the highest as he's got a goal and 3 assists. That would be great if he was a midfielder and had not been at fault for numerous goals this season, which aren't quantified on that site.Quote:
Originally Posted by Tuerto
Some people use statistics like a drunken man uses a lamppost
....for support rather than illumination
Good point. :hehe:Quote:
Originally Posted by Heisenberg
I like a bit of accuracy :biggrin:Quote:
Originally Posted by jon1959
It’s independent though.Quote:
Originally Posted by Tuerto
I just used it as an unbiased opinion as I’ve not taken much interest in Fulham’s game, so no need for you to be so smug.
Not saying I agree with it but I can’t see why anyone would say that Reid has been a success so far.
Not about opinions.Quote:
Originally Posted by Heisenberg
This is statistical analysis.
Just wondering why TLG would consider Reid has been so good when unbiased analysis says otherwise
Until you’ve got a better way of judging players then it’s just your word .Quote:
Originally Posted by Heisenberg
If a player is SO far behind his contemporaries as Reid is its hard to see why he’s perceived by anyone as ‘plying well’
So, your happy to question that , but not able to question why TLG considers that Reid is playing well.Quote:
Originally Posted by Heisenberg
😂😂
As for the rest, you are picking on individuals, there’s a debate on each ,most of whom have still scored better than Reid. The statsdont just have him marginally below our best mid, but below ALL OF THEM, by some distance.
What exactly has he done to deserve the praise ?
How can I when question whether Reid has played well when I've not seen him play this season?Quote:
Originally Posted by Lawnmower
You're showing yourself up here, Lawnmower. I've told you how/why the stats on WhoScored are flawed (as shown by Aden Flint being our best player this season :facepalm:), yet you want to double down on your nonsense and talk about how it's debatable how players have been performing when the stats are questioned. Either WhoScored stats are correct or they're not?
If you need any further evidence that WS is bollocks, Dejan Lovren is statistically Liverpool's best player this season :hehe:
Reid a regular in a side currently 5thQuote:
Originally Posted by Lawnmower
Zohores club top of the league.
Their old club, 14th and pulling up no trees.
That.goes to the heart of it - are we a better team without Zohore? I'd say that's arguable, but the man who we spent around £5 million on to replace him stayed on the bench in our last match. Are we a better team without Decordova-Reid? Definitely not in my view.Quote:
Originally Posted by Do me a Faerber
It must be true, it's on the internet.Quote:
Originally Posted by Lawnmower
Seriously, what a load of bollocks that site is. Complete nonsense. Bennett's playing better than Peltier? Murphy's having a better season than Bacuna? Righto....
I was basing my opinion on his impressive second half showing against Charlton, which I watched live on TV, the clips I saw of Fulham's victory over Luton, in which he appeared prominent, and the fact he's been selected to start the last three games for a team that is fifth in the table and is supposed to have a big, expensive squad. But hey, if whodidwhatandwhen.com says he's having a poor season, then who I am to argue otherwise?Quote:
Originally Posted by Lawnmower
Here's some opinions from a Fulham website following their midweek victory over Luton:
"Bobby Reid, deployed in his familiar capacity as chief instigator, supported both Anthony Knockaert and Ivan Cavaleiro by threading incisive balls into their pathways, luring them to the byline. With Tom Cairney and Reed sweeping up behind the wily Jamaica international, the Whites gutted the visitors like a festive holiday squash."
https://www.fulhamish.co.uk/post/201...am-luton-town/
The guy who wrote that probably hasn't seen whodidwhatandwhen.com and evidently knows nothing.
:thumbup:
However well or badly Bobby is doing- I think we can all agree he would be doing worse if he was still with us- given the type of football we still play.
Reid looks a one season wonder.
Just hope the deal is done and we get our money back.
Have you since taken the time to consider why you're so uninteresting? :shrug: Just asking :hehe:Quote:
Originally Posted by life on mars
Not disputing the original point but using some random Fulham fans blog as concrete evidence to dismiss some random stats site makes no sense either, I would argue neither is a reliable source!Quote:
Originally Posted by The Lone Gunman
League tables don't lie though.Quote:
Originally Posted by Don Corleone
He's playing in a team in the top 5 mate. :hehe:Quote:
Originally Posted by Lawnmower
:hehe: Does ANYONE listen to what that complete idiot says? An untouchable waste of licence payers money and has been for years. :furious:Quote:
Originally Posted by Heisenberg
True. All you ever get from the BBC is country and bloody western. Drives me mad!Quote:
Originally Posted by Bobby Dandruff
I wasn't intending for it to be viewed as concrete evidence. I was merely highlighting a different opinion which indicates the type of role Reid is playing at the moment.Quote:
Originally Posted by Don Corleone
Personally, I wouldn't expect him to get many starts in a side which includes Mitrovic, Knockaert and Cavaleiro, but he's started the last three games, so Parker must believe he's doing alright. I suggested he was based on what I've seen for myself during the last couple of weeks. I didn't, however, say he is having a good season. I simply said he's been playing well, which I believe he has in recent weeks.
Whoscored? Spot on with Flint.Quote:
Originally Posted by Lawnmower
I thought it was Franz Beckenbauer until I checked the name on his back.
Clueless website.