-
Watching the game again now
It's interesting in retrospect , we did pass well, we could have had more on targets shot with more poise, better positioned forwards , better quality final ball
Arters foul in my view was the same as the red card they had.
Zohore cannot head a ball and in some cases looks scared too.
-
Re: Watching the game again now
How did the empty seats look on TV?
-
Re: Watching the game again now
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Auntie Andy
How did the empty seats look on TV?
God knows I just watch the footy
-
Re: Watching the game again now
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Auntie Andy
How did the empty seats look on TV?
Watching MoTD at the moment, the front 4-6 rows of the Bob Bank are probably 40% empty.
Funny seeing Warnock, who was whinging about the PL last season, now whinging about the Championship and not missing it. Linekar said "Not a great game" (is he trolling you Mike?) .
That was my opinion too, I only watched about half an hour live on TV then decided to switch channels. Only just watching MoTD because I have a day off work.
-
Re: Watching the game again now
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Kris
Watching MoTD at the moment, the front 4-6 rows of the Bob Bank are probably 40% empty.
Funny seeing Warnock, who was whinging about the PL last season, now whinging about the Championship and not missing it. Linekar said "Not a great game" (is he trolling you Mike?) .
That was my opinion too, I only watched about half an hour live on TV then decided to switch channels. Only just watching MoTD because I have a day off work.
Thanks for letting us know
-
Re: Watching the game again now
On Sky drinking Guinness in Tenby , it's a better game than MOTD and when I watched live in Saturday amongst a crowd of 75 thousand it went on longer?
-
Re: Watching the game again now
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Kris
Watching MoTD at the moment, the front 4-6 rows of the Bob Bank are probably 40% empty.
Funny seeing Warnock, who was whinging about the PL last season, now whinging about the Championship and not missing it. Linekar said "Not a great game" (is he trolling you Mike?) .
That was my opinion too, I only watched about half an hour live on TV then decided to switch channels. Only just watching MoTD because I have a day off work.
Great update.
-
Re: Watching the game again now
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Baloo
Great update.
Thanks, it is on subject but no doubt some see it as a trolling exercise.
Two very poor teams, I thought Newcastle would be alright this season. Now, I'm not so sure.
-
Re: Watching the game again now
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Kris
Thanks, it is on subject but no doubt some see it as a trolling exercise.
Two very poor teams, I thought Newcastle would be alright this season. Now, I'm not so sure.
Newcastle were terrible, as they were the week before against Spurs... If Rafa cones to his senses and leaves they have no chance.
We looked ok defensively but need more going forward!
-
Re: Watching the game again now
As I watched the game I was wondering what a difference Troy Deeney could have made. And at the end of it, despite the penalty save, it still felt like 2 points dropped.
-
Re: Watching the game again now
Give us a feckin chance mun. We’ve only played 2 games. I really didn’t think the moaning and groaning would start this soon.
-
Re: Watching the game again now
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Kris
Watching MoTD at the moment, the front 4-6 rows of the Bob Bank are probably 40% empty.
Funny seeing Warnock, who was whinging about the PL last season, now whinging about the Championship and not missing it. Linekar said "Not a great game" (is he trolling you Mike?) .
That was my opinion too, I only watched about half an hour live on TV then decided to switch channels. Only just watching MoTD because I have a day off work.
You watched "about half an hour" of the game and made your decision that it wasn't great?
Well done :hehe:
-
Re: Watching the game again now
Arter's foul was not the same. Arter's was a trip, shin to shin contact, not dangerous but a definite yellow. Their player caught Murphy on the back of his calf with his studs, which could have caused serious injury.
-
Re: Watching the game again now
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Auntie Andy
Give us a feckin chance mun. We’ve only played 2 games. I really didn’t think the moaning and groaning would start this soon.
You know every game game counts right? Even the ones in August.
-
Re: Watching the game again now
Quote:
Originally Posted by
NYCBlue
You know every game game counts right? Even the ones in August.
Of course I do. But dear God we’ve a brand new miidfield only played once together. New players who will take time to gel. At least give them a chance instead of giving up after 2 games.
-
Re: Watching the game again now
2 games in and the doom and gloom merchants are out.
New midfield playing in an alien way ie passing !
Ken only passed fit on the morning of the game.
Loads of positives.
-
Re: Watching the game again now
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Kris
Thanks, it is on subject but no doubt some see it as a trolling exercise.
Two very poor teams, I thought Newcastle would be alright this season. Now, I'm not so sure.
It’s fine of course to comment on games. But we’ll clearly need a bit more time to make general assessments.
-
Re: Watching the game again now
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Auntie Andy
Of course I do. But dear God we’ve a brand new miidfield only played once together. New players who will take time to gel. At least give them a chance instead of giving up after 2 games.
Who's giving up?
-
Re: Watching the game again now
Quote:
Originally Posted by
tomm
Arter's foul was not the same. Arter's was a trip, shin to shin contact, not dangerous but a definite yellow. Their player caught Murphy on the back of his calf with his studs, which could have caused serious injury.
Arter’s was similar to Kenedy’s - it was a challenge on somebody with no intention of winning the ball at all. Personally I think both were red cards. The one on Murphy was a red card and a challenge he didn’t need to make but he was trying to play the ball.
-
Re: Watching the game again now
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Kris
Watching MoTD at the moment, the front 4-6 rows of the Bob Bank are probably 40% empty.
Funny seeing Warnock, who was whinging about the PL last season, now whinging about the Championship and not missing it. Linekar said "Not a great game" (is he trolling you Mike?) .
That was my opinion too, I only watched about half an hour live on TV then decided to switch channels. Only just watching MoTD because I have a day off work.
You really are a grade A berk who doesnt deserve the time of day. Bog off and bother someone elses board.
-
Re: Watching the game again now
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Stavross1927
Arter’s was similar to Kenedy’s - it was a challenge on somebody with no intention of winning the ball at all. Personally I think both were red cards. The one on Murphy was a red card and a challenge he didn’t need to make but he was trying to play the ball.
The one on Murphy could have broken his leg. Arters wouldnt have. Kenedys was violent conduct. One was violent/dangerous play and the other was a professional foul. How you can say Hayden was playing the ball is beyond me - he had to go through the man to get it and was nowhere near it.
-
Re: Watching the game again now
Quote:
Originally Posted by
dml1954
The one on Murphy could have broken his leg. Arters wouldnt have. Kenedys was violent conduct. One was violent/dangerous play and the other was a professional foul. How you can say Hayden was playing the ball is beyond me - he had to go through the man to get it and was nowhere near it.
I know it could have broken his leg and as I said it was a challenge he didn’t need to make but I do think he had the intention of playing the ball as bad as the tackle was/looked. Arter’s was not a good challenge, he was frustrated by the player skipping past him and he just booted him around the knee area, when he could have just clipped his ankle. That’s why I think it was a red card.
-
1 Attachment(s)
Re: Watching the game again now
Quote:
Originally Posted by
dml1954
The one on Murphy could have broken his leg. Arters wouldnt have. Kenedys was violent conduct. One was violent/dangerous play and the other was a professional foul. How you can say Hayden was playing the ball is beyond me - he had to go through the man to get it and was nowhere near it.
If Kenedy's is violent conduct then so is Arter's challenge. Arter is nowhere near the ball and kicks Joselu across the knee! Just because it doesn't technically happen "off the ball" (like Kenedy's) it doesn't make it any less of a terrible challenge. The bias is astounding.
Attachment 2648
-
Re: Watching the game again now
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Stavross1927
I know it could have broken his leg and as I said it was a challenge he didn’t need to make but I do think he had the intention of playing the ball as bad as the tackle was/looked. Arter’s was not a good challenge, he was frustrated by the player skipping past him and he just booted him around the knee area, when he could have just clipped his ankle. That’s why I think it was a red card.
'Booted him' :hehe: he's hung his leg out to trip him. Slow motion makes the tiniest tap look like a GBH.
-
Re: Watching the game again now
I enjoyed the game and thought we were a lot better than week before . Still not creating enough in front of goal but hope that will come as new signings settle in.
Newcastle managed the game well once they went down to 10 men , seemed to win majority if not all the free kicks after the sending off , slowed down game at every opportunity . Not sure how much our substitutions helped Newcastle either and/or whether it was Arter having to back off due to his yellow card ?
We need to be more clinical in future , I am sure we will be practicing set pieces this week which on the whole were disappointing.
Big game Saturday (as I know they all are BUT ) this is a chance to go 4 points clear of Huddersfield and maybe 1 or 2 other teams
-
Re: Watching the game again now
Arter's was a professional foul, which unless he's the last man, is usually a booking. Kenedy's was violent conduct off the ball and is a straight red.
-
Re: Watching the game again now
Quote:
Originally Posted by
tomm
Arter's foul was not the same. Arter's was a trip, shin to shin contact, not dangerous but a definite yellow.
I have watched five ex-professionals analyse this incident over the weekend - Danny Gabbidon, Craig Bellamy and Jamie Carragher straight after the match and Gary Lineker and Ian Wright on Match of the Day. All five were certain, without hesitation, that Arter should have been sent off. And there's a reason for that.....
-
Re: Watching the game again now
Quote:
Originally Posted by
The Lone Gunman
I have watched five ex-professionals analyse this incident over the weekend - Danny Gabbidon, Craig Bellamy and Jamie Carragher straight after the match and Gary Lineker and Ian Wright on Match of the Day. All five were certain, without hesitation, that Arter should have been sent off. And there's a reason for that.....
That's nice. I don't agree with them.
-
Re: Watching the game again now
Quote:
Originally Posted by
tomm
That's nice. I don't agree with them.
That's nice. Tomm knows best.
:thumbup:
-
Re: Watching the game again now
Quote:
Originally Posted by
The Lone Gunman
I have watched five ex-professionals analyse this incident over the weekend - Danny Gabbidon, Craig Bellamy and Jamie Carragher straight after the match and Gary Lineker and Ian Wright on Match of the Day. All five were certain, without hesitation, that Arter should have been sent off. And there's a reason for that.....
......all five have a deep-rooted and psychotic hatred of all-things Cardiff City FC - for which they should seek immediate professional help?
-
Re: Watching the game again now
Quote:
Originally Posted by
The Lone Gunman
That's nice. Tomm knows best.
:thumbup:
I'm not saying I know best, I'm just giving my thoughts. People have different opinions.
-
Re: Watching the game again now
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Cyclops
......all five have a deep-rooted and psychotic hatred of all-things Cardiff City FC - for which they should seek immediate professional help?
Danny Gabbidon's famous for that, as is club employee Craig Bellamy.
-
Re: Watching the game again now
Quote:
Originally Posted by
tomm
I'm not saying I know best, I'm just giving my thoughts. People have different opinions.
They do indeed. And those opinions are often severely affected by the club they support.
-
Re: Watching the game again now
Quote:
Originally Posted by
The Lone Gunman
They do indeed. And those opinions are often severely affected by the club they support.
You can think I'm one-eyed if you want, but I'm not, I just have a different opinion on what makes a tackle dangerous. Anyway, this is fast degenerating into the boring one poster whining at another shit that ruins this messageboard so I'll leave it there.
-
Re: Watching the game again now
Quote:
Originally Posted by
The Lone Gunman
Danny Gabbidon's famous for that, as is club employee Craig Bellamy.
I just knew you'd come round to the correct way of thinking
-
Re: Watching the game again now
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Kris
Watching MoTD at the moment, the front 4-6 rows of the Bob Bank are probably 40% empty.
Funny seeing Warnock, who was whinging about the PL last season, now whinging about the Championship and not missing it. Linekar said "Not a great game" (is he trolling you Mike?) .
That was my opinion too, I only watched about half an hour live on TV then decided to switch channels. Only just watching MoTD because I have a day off work.
For a fourth time - I'm going to keep on asking until I get an answer from you;-
"So you are the person we all assume you are then? Tell me, what do you think you would have said to someone who told you in 2008 that in ten years time, you'd be doing what you do now on here when Cardiff City are playing in the Premier League, wearing blue shirts, had an owner who has converted over £70 million worth of club debt into equity over the summer and were going ahead with a new training base?"
-
Re: Watching the game again now
Quote:
Originally Posted by
the other bob wilson
For a fourth time - I'm going to keep on asking until I get an answer from you;-
"So you are the person we all assume you are then? Tell me, what do you think you would have said to someone who told you in 2008 that in ten years time, you'd be doing what you do now on here when Cardiff City are playing in the Premier League, wearing blue shirts, had an owner who has converted over £70 million worth of club debt into equity over the summer and were going ahead with a new training base?"
Amen to that ,TOBW.
-
Re: Watching the game again now
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Heisenberg
You watched "about half an hour" of the game and made your decision that it wasn't great?
Well done :hehe:
In fairness, I saved myself 60 minutes plus half time because most reports say it wasn't a good game. In fact, the only people I see raving about the games are on this board! As someone on the radio said "seeing Warnock celebrating a 0-0 against a 10 man Newcastle suggests a long hard season ahead". The highlights I saw suggest I missed little too - unless the BBC are trying to make Cardiff look poor? Maybe some will believe that.
-
Re: Watching the game again now
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Kris
Thanks, it is on subject but no doubt some see it as a trolling exercise.
Two very poor teams, I thought Newcastle would be alright this season. Now, I'm not so sure.
I thought you might have got over your obsession with a club you no longer support. But now I'm not so sure.
-
Re: Watching the game again now
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Kris
In fairness, I saved myself 60 minutes plus half time because most reports say it wasn't a good game. In fact, the only people I see raving about the games are on this board! As someone on the radio said "seeing Warnock celebrating a 0-0 against a 10 man Newcastle suggests a long hard season ahead". The highlights I saw suggest I missed little too - unless the BBC are trying to make Cardiff look poor? Maybe some will believe that.
You watched match of the day? Why was Warnock celebrating a 0-0, against a 10 man Newcastle?