-
Yet another Cardiff boy snapped up by Swansea
For the love of god, a Llandaff North boy should be a Bluebird.
https://www.walesonline.co.uk/sport/...ented-17245471
-
Re: Yet another Cardiff boy snapped up by Swansea
It is a pisstake isn't it. How crap is our academy system. No players bought through is bad enough but missing good players on our doorstep. FFS useless.
-
Re: Yet another Cardiff boy snapped up by Swansea
The more things like this happen, along with what must surely be a growing perception that Cardiff is not a place where young players are given a chance at senior level, the more likely it becomes that there will be plenty more to follow.
-
Re: Yet another Cardiff boy snapped up by Swansea
Quote:
Originally Posted by
the other bob wilson
The more things like this happen, along with what must surely be a growing perception that Cardiff is not a place where young players are given a chance at senior level, the more likely it becomes that there will be plenty more to follow.
Very true. I know a promising player in the under 17's who has every chance of making it. His dad was keen to move him out of the club because he didn't see the point of him being there. Warnock going may have changed his mind.
-
Re: Yet another Cardiff boy snapped up by Swansea
Quote:
Originally Posted by
simonp_ccfc
Very true. I know a promising player in the under 17's who has every chance of making it. His dad was keen to move him out of the club because he didn't see the point of him being there. Warnock going may have changed his mind.
How much does our board and owner value having an academy and bringing young players through?
-
Re: Yet another Cardiff boy snapped up by Swansea
Quote:
Originally Posted by
the other bob wilson
The more things like this happen, along with what must surely be a growing perception that Cardiff is not a place where young players are given a chance at senior level, the more likely it becomes that there will be plenty more to follow.
True, Paul. Moreover, until Tan opens the purse strings and he invests in a Category 1 Academy we'll always be up against it.
StT.
<><
-
Re: Yet another Cardiff boy snapped up by Swansea
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Steve the Tea
True, Paul. Moreover, until Tan opens the purse strings and he invests in a Category 1 Academy we'll always be up against it.
StT.
<><
“Category One status is extremely hard to achieve and takes real commitment from the club. Any football academies that have this status is a show of the quality of the coaching, equipment, facilities and strategic development that you can expect to find.Category One football academies also invest a lot to maintain their status. There are also some clubs that choose not to publicise their status in order to avoid being over approached by players and parents“
That’s us out.
-
Re: Yet another Cardiff boy snapped up by Swansea
Quote:
Originally Posted by
The Hooded Claw
A Cat 1 Academy costs a lot to set up and maintain, but then so do transfers that don't work out not to mention the cost of losing young local talent to rivals. It's gotta be worth it.
-
Re: Yet another Cardiff boy snapped up by Swansea
-
Re: Yet another Cardiff boy snapped up by Swansea
Quote:
Originally Posted by
simonp_ccfc
Are Swansea academy one?
Yep, which makes it all the more shocking that we aren’t.
-
Re: Yet another Cardiff boy snapped up by Swansea
Quote:
Originally Posted by
The Hooded Claw
Despite the Chair of Swansea City being an insolvency practitioner (recently appointed to help them with their financial position) he , and the club`s owners, still considers it to be a good investment and of financial benefit to continue to fund their Academy system. Maybe because of Trevor`s football background he is clear why it is so important.
-
Re: Yet another Cardiff boy snapped up by Swansea
It's no surprise. Young players don't get a sniff, Slade and Warnock weren't interested and then there was the bullying investigation, add to that the way we play. If there was a choice between us and the jacks i'd say that there was no contest. Even if a young player doesn't make the grade at Swansea i'd say that he's coming out of it a better player.
-
Re: Yet another Cardiff boy snapped up by Swansea
Quote:
Originally Posted by
dembethewarrior
“Category One status is extremely hard to achieve and takes real commitment from the club. Any football academies that have this status is a show of the quality of the coaching, equipment, facilities and strategic development that you can expect to find.Category One football academies also invest a lot to maintain their status. There are also some clubs that choose not to publicise their status in order to avoid being over approached by players and parents“
That’s us out.
Exactly. That my point, 'demb.' You can't run a club on the cheap these days. You must have long, mid and short term plans and a Cat 1 Academy must be part of that. We've had about 4 or 5 parachute payments by now. Where has it gone?
StT.
<><
-
Re: Yet another Cardiff boy snapped up by Swansea
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Tuerto
It's no surprise. Young players don't get a sniff, Slade and Warnock weren't interested and then there was the bullying investigation, add to that the way we play. If there was a choice between us and the jacks i'd say that there was no contest. Even if a young player doesn't make the grade at Swansea i'd say that he's coming out of it a better player.
The bullying investigation was a year ago wasn’t it? And it’s been sorted?
-
Re: Yet another Cardiff boy snapped up by Swansea
Quote:
Originally Posted by
dembethewarrior
The bullying investigation was a year ago wasn’t it? And it’s been sorted?
I don't know, my point is that it wouldn't really go in our favour i suppose when young players and parents are weighing up the options.
-
Re: Yet another Cardiff boy snapped up by Swansea
Strange how they don’t produce any home grown talent of their own, do they always just pinch them from other clubs academies like they did with Dan James?
-
Re: Yet another Cardiff boy snapped up by Swansea
Quote:
Originally Posted by
goats
Strange how they don’t produce any home grown talent of their own, do they always just pinch them from other clubs academies like they did with Dan James?
Ben Davies, Joe Allen, There fullback (i forget his name) They developed Mc Burnie. I'd say that Davies, Allen and McBurnie has netted them the best part of 30 million, James went for 15 million? Their youth development has saved them. Lets just say that they have an eye for a young player.
-
Re: Yet another Cardiff boy snapped up by Swansea
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Tuerto
Ben Davies, Joe Allen, There fullback (i forget his name) They developed Mc Burnie. I'd say that Davies, Allen and McBurnie has netted them the best part of 30 million, James went for 15 million? Their youth development has saved them. Lets just say that they have an eye for a young player.
McBurnie was bought from Bradford and had played 1st team football for them.
-
Re: Yet another Cardiff boy snapped up by Swansea
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Hilts
McBurnie was bought from Bradford and had played 1st team football for them.
Fair enough, although they brought in an 18 year old from a league 2 club and turned him into a 15 million pound player. Good scouting.
-
Re: Yet another Cardiff boy snapped up by Swansea
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Tuerto
Fair enough, although they brought in an 18 year old from a league 2 club and turned him into a 15 million pound player. Good scouting.
So just joe Allen really, just cause his dad played for them.....not many Swansea boys playing or making it though
-
Re: Yet another Cardiff boy snapped up by Swansea
Quote:
Originally Posted by
goats
So just joe Allen really, just cause his dad played for them.....not many Swansea boys playing or making it though
Ben Davies, Connor Roberts, Joe Rodon... They're all from that area, aren't they?
-
Re: Yet another Cardiff boy snapped up by Swansea
Quote:
Originally Posted by
goats
So just joe Allen really, just cause his dad played for them.....not many Swansea boys playing or making it though
His dad never played for Swansea.
-
Re: Yet another Cardiff boy snapped up by Swansea
Interesting comments, but I don’t see us bringing in young players from the lower leagues and turning them into multi million pound players and/or internationals.
-
Re: Yet another Cardiff boy snapped up by Swansea
From what I can see this lad joined the Jacks about 10 years ago so don't know what it's got to do with Slade, Warnock or Tan for that matter as he'd only just arrived. But the City Critics Message Board never misses an opportunity for a dig at the club these days 😞
-
Re: Yet another Cardiff boy snapped up by Swansea
From a Wales point of view, I’m kind of glad that these young footballers go to Swansea as they seem to bring them through and educate in a way that ensures longevity whilst maximising potential. A player in the Cardiff City academy is either so talented that a larger club comes in to take them on to better things or they just fade away.
At CCFC, you don’t get solid professionals that are nurtured with a view to becoming a first team regulars. This probably has something to do with the fact that there is no continuity in football philosophy through the age groups to the reserves and onto the first team.