Reply With QuoteI know it's all opinions, but how the fuck can you make Noone MOM? He was very poor today.Originally Posted by Croesy Blue wrote on Sat, 18 April 2015 18:44
| + Visit Cardiff FC for Latest News, Transfer Gossip, Fixtures and Match Results |
Marshall 6
Peltier 5
Manga 5
Morrison 5
Malone 5
Noone 6
Gunnarson 4
Whittingham 4
Ralls 5
Mason 4
Doyle 4
Slade 1
Why not give some other players a chance given the season is over. Clueless.
I know it's all opinions, but how the fuck can you make Noone MOM? He was very poor today.
I thought he has possibly his best game of the season so far. Obviously realises he is in the shop window now so starts to put a little effort in.
I'm sorry giving noone 6 undermines your ratings. He was subbed 84 mins too late!!
The tactics are so abysmal that players doing well, like Noone, Ralls, Peltier and possibly Doyle look like poor players
Which is exactly why the manager was marked a 1.
4 for Mason.....really that many?
Mason was rubbish
I thought our full backs today - Peltier, Malone and Fabio were all rubbish, continually playing long aimless balls down the line. Real lower league rubbish
I think your perception of Noone's performance depends, to some extent, on which side of the ground you sit in. Noone appeared to get past his full back a couple of times in the first half when he was playing in front of the Grandstand whereas when he was on the side of the ground I sit in during the second half, he did virtually nothing (apart from regularly lose possession). To me, he merited no more than a five if I were in a generous mood, yet I see Steve Tucker made him man of the match again from his seat in the press box - I take it you sit on the Grandstand side of the ground?
Don't get me wrong. He has been abysmal all season and was only marginally better than that yesterday. Though he was also better than most of the players out on the pitch, who generally were a disgrace and nor fit to wear a Cardiff City shirt of whatever hue.Marshall 6
Give some of the development boys an outing against Blackpool.
Thought Noone had a good game and Harding hacked him down a few times yet didnt get booked. Marshall distribution was awful and was outshone by forde. Our game was slowed down a lot by Morrison lack of ability on the ball and his positioning. Manga brings the ball forward but Morrison stays deep leaving loads of room for a ball over the top, lucky Millwall didnt have a finisher like Bolton did.
Marshall 4 Poor slow distribution
Pettier 5 tried to get forward
Malone 6 Fabio 6 got forward and covered
Morrison 3 out of depth
Manga 6 shaky moments but some class
Gunnerson 6 Better game
Witts 7 Number of corners he cleared stood out
Ralls 5 Out of position but works hard
Noone 7 On the wrong wing again
Doyle 6 lots of good running but not found as slow distribution
Mason 6 same as Doyle
Time for 3.5.2 against blackpool
Marshall
Pettier, Manga, Turner
Kennedy, Gunnerson, Pilkington, Witts, Noone
Doyle, Mason
Four wide midfielders in a midfield five?
pilkington in a free role with gunner and witts sitting in midfield. Would be tempted to bring on adeyami and ralls after 70 mins in a double substition and maybe start them against forest
352
Marshall
Morrison Ajeyi (the arsenal lad however you spell it!!) Manga
Fabio Whitts Adeyemi Ralls Pilkington
Two people from the crowd who can shoot on target and have a decent first touch
Hope one of the two from the crowd doesn't cry off ill - the dog will have to play then I suppose.
If they announce that the two from the crowd will be chosen every ten minutes it may keep us awake cos sure as hell they are sending me to sleep at the mo!!!
Posting Permissions
