Reply With QuoteFrom my view in the canton, it looked like a penalty for Huddersfield.Originally Posted by Lawnmower wrote on Sat, 12 September 2015 18:17
| + Visit Cardiff FC for Latest News, Transfer Gossip, Fixtures and Match Results |
Surely they should have had a pen before our 1st goal and the 2 nd one was offside?
From my view in the canton, it looked like a penalty for Huddersfield.
It was a clear penalty for them just before we got the first - Ameobi was onside to set up the first goal though
The second goal was shocking - he was yards offside how the linesman missed that I have no idea
Just seen the 2nd goal on sky sports. The lino got the decision right - just! Mason was just behind Ameobi when he played the ball.
Mason clearly ONSIDE
Thought Morrison was lucky; he's got to be dropped hasn't he?
2nd goal looked offside but fair play if the Lino got it right.
That ref was a tit. Should have Hogg got a red?
What I didn't get was how the linesman who is two yards away didn't flag for anything, yet the ref who is at least 20 yards away gives a foul?
he was clearly onside to those who know the rules
Chris Powell in his post-match interview was complaining about their penalty shout but was very clear that there was no offside for the second goal.
I'm no Morrison fan but I thought he got a bit of the ball. I felt the ref got the big decisions right didn't think the challenge was a red.
Only thing wasn't sure of is the goal Pilkington got in 1st half
Hindsight indeed - he did look clearly offside (I now know he wasn't)It was a clear penalty for them just before we got the first - Ameobi was onside to set up the first goal though
Well he wasn't, anyone who knows the rules of the game would know that.
Oh bog offHindsight indeed - he did look clearly offside
Think he needs to be dropped for Manga as some of his defending is sloppy and he's awful with ball at feet.
Posting Permissions