+ Visit Cardiff FC for Latest News, Transfer Gossip, Fixtures and Match Results
Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 25 of 33

Thread: 25 worst City signings. Agree, Disagree?

  1. #1

    25 worst City signings. Agree, Disagree?

    Wales Online think along with Etien Velikonja and Filip Kiss the following players are the worst in City's history.

    They seem to have forgotten we signed shit before 1997 as well. Do you agree? Or who else would you include. There are some stinkers in the list below but we signed some dross in the past as well.

    Peter Zois (1997/98)
    The goalkeeper was only brought in as cover, he had just one job to do, keep out Rotherham. He failed and was gone the next day. Legend indeed.

    Jörn Schwinkendorf (1999-00)
    He stood at 6ft 5ins, but when he jumped to head the ball that somehow decreased to 3ft 2ins. Put it this way, when the highlight of your time at a club is once hitting the post, you know things are bad.

    Zhiyi Fan (2002/03)
    Signed from Shanghai International for free in 2002, he became the first ever Chinese player to wear the Cardiff shirt and after witnessing him in action Bluebirds fans were left hoping he might be the last.

    Guylain Ndumbu-Nsungu (2006)
    His name is one of the highest scores you can get in Scrabble. The striker failed to find the net for the Bluebirds although after just 11 appearances he did find the exit.

    Andrea Ferretti (2005/06)
    Italy has produced some amazing strikers down the years, but this guy was not one of them. He came on the recommendation of Sir Alex Ferguson, but so did David Moyes.

    Toni Koskela (2005-06)
    The well-built midfielder spent a year with the Bluebirds, but not much of that actually on the pitch. He made three appearances, all from the bench, although one of those was at Arsenal in the FA Cup. Cardiff still lost.

    Iwan Redan (2006/7)
    Legend has it Cardiff intercepted the striker at the airport to bring him in on loan, many surmise they got the wrong man and it was actually just some innocent bloke heading off on holidays. Redan was coming off the back of controversy after allegedly head-butting a teammate at his Dutch club Willem II.

    Thankfully, nothing like that happened at Cardiff, well, to be honest, very little happened at all. He made two substitute appearances in February 2007 at Coventry and West Brom and then he was gone, back to Willem II.

    Luigi Glombard (2006/7)
    Glombard was part of the France side which won the U-17s World Cup. But he failed to hit those heights at Cardiff. You can never forget it, Glombard’s brilliant ball through to Robert Earnshaw at Carrow Road. Brilliant apart from the fact ‘Earnie’ was playing for Norwich at the time.

    Dimitrios Konstantopoulius (2008-9)
    You had to love this guy, but only if your side was playing against Cardiff. The man known as ‘Agent Dimi’ managed to throw the ball into his own net at Wolves. Twice!

    Quincy Owusu-Abeyie (2008/09)
    The winger was a Ghanian international, but during his five appearances for Cardiff he really looked as if he had just come in following a spell at Roath Park Rangers.

    Eddie Johnson (2008/09)
    Two goals in 30 games said its own sad story for the extremely likeable striker. He scored the last ever goal under the floodlights at Ninian Park which made a change because his shots usually hit the floodlights.

    Miguel Comminges (2008/09)
    The guy was a Guadeloupe international, but, hey, who amongst us hasn’t been one of those? He started ten games for the Bluebirds during his time at the club, but no one ever got too excited.

    Martin John (2010-11)
    Martin John didn't make a league appearance for Cardiff City. If ever there was an international man of mystery then this full-back was it. Born in London to a Gambian father and a mother he described as Colombian, Bolivian and Swiss, John was the ultimate enigma.

    At the age of five, John moved to Italy, then three years later to Canada. Look, there basically was hardly a national side in the world John did not qualify to play for which was just as well really as he barely featured for Cardiff.

    His route to the Bluebirds was tortuous, but Dave Jones signed him in July 2010. He made his debut in a 4-1 League Cup win over Burton and then...zilch, zero, nada. He never played for Cardiff again. Sent out on loan to Newport, the last anyone heard of John he was on trial at Plymouth.

    Solomon Taiwo (2009-12)
    You only get an ooh with Taiwo! Except you don’t. Midfielder Taiwo played well against Cardiff for Dagenham & Redbridge in a League Cup tie in August, 2009, and then the Bluebirds signed him.

    It was a move, with the advantage of hindsight, that really did not involve nearly enough research at all. Taiwo was at the club for three years, yep, you read that right, and in that time he made just two league starts.

    Simon Lappin (2013-14)
    The omens weren't great when Lappin was sent off in his first appearance for City while on loan in 2012. When he became a permanent signing the following year he never actually played at all before Sheffield United took him on loan. Lappin was never seen in a Cardiff shirt again.

    Andreas Cornelius (2013-14)
    Andreas Cornelius lasted just a few months as a Cardiff City player
    When we are old and grey we will be able to sit our little grandson on our knee and say: “I saw Cornelius play for Cardiff my boy. And yes, he did cost £8m and, yes, he was rubbish.”
    A disastrous signing who moved back to Copenhagen after one anonymous season.

    Javi Guerra (2014/15)
    Aged 31 he was given a three year contract by the Bluebirds having proved himself in Spain's La Liga. He ended up making three appearances off the bench before being sent to Malaga.

    Magnus Wolff Eikrem (2014)
    Once named in a Manchester United Champions League squad this fellow was more poodle than Wolff while at the Bluebirds. One of Solskjaer's Norwegian brigade he lasted from January to December making only six league appearances before Russell Slade terminated his contract.

    Jo Inge Berget (2014-15)
    Another attacking Norwegian midfielder thought by Solskjaer to be the answer. Guess what? He wasn't.

    He got one start in the FA Cup in the defeat at Wigan in February, 2014 and came off the bench for ten minutes in his only taste of Premier League action during a humiliating 4-0 home defeat at the hands of Hull a week later. Berget made more of a success on a loan spell at Celtic, but is now almost back in Norway, at Malmo in Sweden.

    Wilfried Zaha (2014)
    Now here was the guy whose left wing trickery would rescue the Bluebirds from Premier League relegation when he joined in the 2014 January transfer window. Er, not quite. In 10 appearances he simply ran up blind alleys.
    He has shown he wasn't a complete flash in the pan, though, after rediscovering his dynamism since returning to Crystal Palace from Manchester United.

    Guido Burgstaller (2014-15)
    Burgstaller really looked the part for Cardiff - on his debut at Carmarthen Town that is. After that he played 20 minutes in the Championship and a Capital One Cup game. Gone by the January...

    Adam Le Fondre (2014-15)
    Adam Le Fondre is one of a number of Cardiff City players who look devoid of confidenceAdam Le Fondre
    He ran around, he gave his all but Le Fondre was missing one important ingredient for a striker - goals. He hit three in 21 appearances before Russell Slade set him to Bolton.
    Spent the entirety of 2015/16 with Wolves where three goals in 26 appearances didn't convince them to take up the option of a permanent deal. He is now back with the Bluebirds though it remains to be seen whether he will be part of new boss Paul Trollope's plans.

    Maxi Amondarain (2013-15)
    When Malky Mackay brought Amondarain to the club in August 2013 not a lot was expected of him which proved to be just as well in retrospect.
    The defender, who at least looked the part, never came closer to troubling the first team. Admittedly a youngster, he barely featured for the development side either. You could hardly call him a gamble as he was never really given any opportunity at all at the club.

    http://www.walesonline.co.uk/sport/f...diff-11373830?

  2. #2

    Re: 25 worst City signings. Agree, Disagree?

    Some of those player aren't shite though.
    If they want to go with modern players then why on Earth isn't Simon Walton in there?

  3. #3

    Re: 25 worst City signings. Agree, Disagree?

    What about the two signed from MK Dons, Malvin Kamara and Nick McKoy? Surely worse than Commingues ever was.

    Leyton Maxwell, Phil Mulryne, Jermaine Darlington, Steven McLean, Matty Green all spring to mind, too.

  4. #4
    International jon1959's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2007
    Location
    Sheffield - out of Roath
    Posts
    16,085

    Re: 25 worst City signings. Agree, Disagree?

    A few of them were good signings badly used (eg Burgstaller)

    Some were OK players in a mid Championship side (eg Commingues)

    Some were good players who didn't want to be here (eg Guerra)

    Others were stupid signings, maybe just to give fans something to talk about in the pub (Dave or Redan)

    And as the Spanker has pointed out, Simon Walton is missing, so the whole list is invalid.

  5. #5
    International jon1959's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2007
    Location
    Sheffield - out of Roath
    Posts
    16,085

    Re: 25 worst City signings. Agree, Disagree?

    Quote Originally Posted by Eric the Half a Bee View Post
    What about the two signed from MK Dons, Malvin Kamara and Nick McKoy? Surely worse than Commingues ever was.

    Leyton Maxwell, Phil Mulryne, Jermaine Darlington, Steven McLean, Matty Green all spring to mind, too.

    Steve McLean who never missed a penalty - until he came to us on a free.

    However the Riddler moved him on to Plymouth for £500k, so a brilliant signing!

  6. #6

    Re: 25 worst City signings. Agree, Disagree?

    Quote Originally Posted by The Bob Banker Spanker View Post
    Some of those player aren't shite though.
    If they want to go with modern players then why on Earth isn't Simon Walton in there?
    Simon Walton is still only 28. He has had 13 clubs in his career so far. The night he made his debut for City, Feb 2007, I was a guest of the match sponsor. He was voted man of the match because it was his debut.

    He was involved in five more games for us after that getting booked twice and sent off twice.

  7. #7

    Re: 25 worst City signings. Agree, Disagree?

    Paul Parry

    just for his display against Ipswich

  8. #8

    Re: 25 worst City signings. Agree, Disagree?

    A lot of those players were when we were in the lower leagues and not expected to do well, except for Schwinkendorf who cost £100,000 when we were in division 4. Some of those only played a few games or were on short term loans.

    So I give you Cornelius, £10m and ridiculous wages! Also anyone signed by OGS. Eikram, Berget, Kenwynne Jones, Fabio, Burgstaller, Manga, etc given the transfer fees paid and the wages they were in. And how they performed when they were here. I left out Daehli because he showed promise and we got £2m when we sold him. Also Le Fondre, Doyle, Dikgacoi for the same reasons.

  9. #9

    Re: 25 worst City signings. Agree, Disagree?

    That article's rubbish for all sorts of reasons. Why not just say the worst signings of the last twenty years if you are unable to remember beyond that? There's factual errors aplenty - Dimi didn't chuck the ball into his own net twice against Wolves, he did it once against them and once against Norwich, Javi Guerra started two games for us, the FA Cup match with Wigan Berget started was a home game, not an away one, I'm still trying to work out what this sentence about Maxi Amondarain means "The defender, who at least looked the part, never came closer (closer than what?) to troubling the first team." and, worst of all, they've forgotten, or just weren't aware, that Eddie Johnson scored the last ever opposition goal at Ninian Park under floodlights as well as the last one for City under the lights!

    Seriously, that article is living proof that you should keep quiet if you've not got anything worthwhile to say.

  10. #10

    Re: 25 worst City signings. Agree, Disagree?

    Quote Originally Posted by Michael Morris View Post
    Wales Online think along with Etien Velikonja and Filip Kiss the following players are the worst in City's history.

    They seem to have forgotten we signed shit before 1997 as well. Do you agree? Or who else would you include. There are some stinkers in the list below but we signed some dross in the past as well.

    Peter Zois (1997/98)
    The goalkeeper was only brought in as cover, he had just one job to do, keep out Rotherham. He failed and was gone the next day. Legend indeed.

    Jörn Schwinkendorf (1999-00)
    He stood at 6ft 5ins, but when he jumped to head the ball that somehow decreased to 3ft 2ins. Put it this way, when the highlight of your time at a club is once hitting the post, you know things are bad.

    Zhiyi Fan (2002/03)
    Signed from Shanghai International for free in 2002, he became the first ever Chinese player to wear the Cardiff shirt and after witnessing him in action Bluebirds fans were left hoping he might be the last.

    Guylain Ndumbu-Nsungu (2006)
    His name is one of the highest scores you can get in Scrabble. The striker failed to find the net for the Bluebirds although after just 11 appearances he did find the exit.

    Andrea Ferretti (2005/06)
    Italy has produced some amazing strikers down the years, but this guy was not one of them. He came on the recommendation of Sir Alex Ferguson, but so did David Moyes.

    Toni Koskela (2005-06)
    The well-built midfielder spent a year with the Bluebirds, but not much of that actually on the pitch. He made three appearances, all from the bench, although one of those was at Arsenal in the FA Cup. Cardiff still lost.

    Iwan Redan (2006/7)
    Legend has it Cardiff intercepted the striker at the airport to bring him in on loan, many surmise they got the wrong man and it was actually just some innocent bloke heading off on holidays. Redan was coming off the back of controversy after allegedly head-butting a teammate at his Dutch club Willem II.

    Thankfully, nothing like that happened at Cardiff, well, to be honest, very little happened at all. He made two substitute appearances in February 2007 at Coventry and West Brom and then he was gone, back to Willem II.

    Luigi Glombard (2006/7)
    Glombard was part of the France side which won the U-17s World Cup. But he failed to hit those heights at Cardiff. You can never forget it, Glombard’s brilliant ball through to Robert Earnshaw at Carrow Road. Brilliant apart from the fact ‘Earnie’ was playing for Norwich at the time.

    Dimitrios Konstantopoulius (2008-9)
    You had to love this guy, but only if your side was playing against Cardiff. The man known as ‘Agent Dimi’ managed to throw the ball into his own net at Wolves. Twice!

    Quincy Owusu-Abeyie (2008/09)
    The winger was a Ghanian international, but during his five appearances for Cardiff he really looked as if he had just come in following a spell at Roath Park Rangers.

    Eddie Johnson (2008/09)
    Two goals in 30 games said its own sad story for the extremely likeable striker. He scored the last ever goal under the floodlights at Ninian Park which made a change because his shots usually hit the floodlights.

    Miguel Comminges (2008/09)
    The guy was a Guadeloupe international, but, hey, who amongst us hasn’t been one of those? He started ten games for the Bluebirds during his time at the club, but no one ever got too excited.

    Martin John (2010-11)
    Martin John didn't make a league appearance for Cardiff City. If ever there was an international man of mystery then this full-back was it. Born in London to a Gambian father and a mother he described as Colombian, Bolivian and Swiss, John was the ultimate enigma.

    At the age of five, John moved to Italy, then three years later to Canada. Look, there basically was hardly a national side in the world John did not qualify to play for which was just as well really as he barely featured for Cardiff.

    His route to the Bluebirds was tortuous, but Dave Jones signed him in July 2010. He made his debut in a 4-1 League Cup win over Burton and then...zilch, zero, nada. He never played for Cardiff again. Sent out on loan to Newport, the last anyone heard of John he was on trial at Plymouth.

    Solomon Taiwo (2009-12)
    You only get an ooh with Taiwo! Except you don’t. Midfielder Taiwo played well against Cardiff for Dagenham & Redbridge in a League Cup tie in August, 2009, and then the Bluebirds signed him.

    It was a move, with the advantage of hindsight, that really did not involve nearly enough research at all. Taiwo was at the club for three years, yep, you read that right, and in that time he made just two league starts.

    Simon Lappin (2013-14)
    The omens weren't great when Lappin was sent off in his first appearance for City while on loan in 2012. When he became a permanent signing the following year he never actually played at all before Sheffield United took him on loan. Lappin was never seen in a Cardiff shirt again.

    Andreas Cornelius (2013-14)
    Andreas Cornelius lasted just a few months as a Cardiff City player
    When we are old and grey we will be able to sit our little grandson on our knee and say: “I saw Cornelius play for Cardiff my boy. And yes, he did cost £8m and, yes, he was rubbish.”
    A disastrous signing who moved back to Copenhagen after one anonymous season.

    Javi Guerra (2014/15)
    Aged 31 he was given a three year contract by the Bluebirds having proved himself in Spain's La Liga. He ended up making three appearances off the bench before being sent to Malaga.

    Magnus Wolff Eikrem (2014)
    Once named in a Manchester United Champions League squad this fellow was more poodle than Wolff while at the Bluebirds. One of Solskjaer's Norwegian brigade he lasted from January to December making only six league appearances before Russell Slade terminated his contract.

    Jo Inge Berget (2014-15)
    Another attacking Norwegian midfielder thought by Solskjaer to be the answer. Guess what? He wasn't.

    He got one start in the FA Cup in the defeat at Wigan in February, 2014 and came off the bench for ten minutes in his only taste of Premier League action during a humiliating 4-0 home defeat at the hands of Hull a week later. Berget made more of a success on a loan spell at Celtic, but is now almost back in Norway, at Malmo in Sweden.

    Wilfried Zaha (2014)
    Now here was the guy whose left wing trickery would rescue the Bluebirds from Premier League relegation when he joined in the 2014 January transfer window. Er, not quite. In 10 appearances he simply ran up blind alleys.
    He has shown he wasn't a complete flash in the pan, though, after rediscovering his dynamism since returning to Crystal Palace from Manchester United.

    Guido Burgstaller (2014-15)
    Burgstaller really looked the part for Cardiff - on his debut at Carmarthen Town that is. After that he played 20 minutes in the Championship and a Capital One Cup game. Gone by the January...

    Adam Le Fondre (2014-15)
    Adam Le Fondre is one of a number of Cardiff City players who look devoid of confidenceAdam Le Fondre
    He ran around, he gave his all but Le Fondre was missing one important ingredient for a striker - goals. He hit three in 21 appearances before Russell Slade set him to Bolton.
    Spent the entirety of 2015/16 with Wolves where three goals in 26 appearances didn't convince them to take up the option of a permanent deal. He is now back with the Bluebirds though it remains to be seen whether he will be part of new boss Paul Trollope's plans.

    Maxi Amondarain (2013-15)
    When Malky Mackay brought Amondarain to the club in August 2013 not a lot was expected of him which proved to be just as well in retrospect.
    The defender, who at least looked the part, never came closer to troubling the first team. Admittedly a youngster, he barely featured for the development side either. You could hardly call him a gamble as he was never really given any opportunity at all at the club.

    http://www.walesonline.co.uk/sport/f...diff-11373830?
    Bit harsh on Kiss I'd say. At the age of 21 he played a big part in the team that got us to the Championship playoffs.

    Also played a part in one of only 4 major cup finals the club has ever been in.

    No way Eddie Johnson should be on the list either.

  11. #11

    Re: 25 worst City signings. Agree, Disagree?

    25 worst articles in City's history...

  12. #12

    Re: 25 worst City signings. Agree, Disagree?

    Andreas Cornelius....when you factor the price tag in, has to be the worst signing in the last 20 years.

  13. #13

    Re: 25 worst City signings. Agree, Disagree?

    Quote Originally Posted by EastbourneBlue View Post
    No way Eddie Johnson should be on the list either.

  14. #14

    Re: 25 worst City signings. Agree, Disagree?

    Quote Originally Posted by jon1959 View Post
    A few of them were good signings badly used (eg Burgstaller)

    Some were OK players in a mid Championship side (eg Commingues)

    Some were good players who didn't want to be here (eg Guerra)

    Others were stupid signings, maybe just to give fans something to talk about in the pub (Dave or Redan)

    And as the Spanker has pointed out, Simon Walton is missing, so the whole list is invalid.
    Have to agree with all of that.

  15. #15

    Re: 25 worst City signings. Agree, Disagree?

    Quote Originally Posted by EastbourneBlue View Post
    Bit harsh on Kiss I'd say. At the age of 21 he played a big part in the team that got us to the Championship playoffs.

    Also played a part in one of only 4 major cup finals the club has ever been in.

    No way Eddie Johnson should be on the list either.
    I thought that about Kiss.

    (Not sure about Eddie though.....!)

  16. #16

    Re: 25 worst City signings. Agree, Disagree?

    Quote Originally Posted by jon1959 View Post
    Steve McLean who never missed a penalty - until he came to us on a free.

    However the Riddler moved him on to Plymouth for £500k, so a brilliant signing!
    Surely the best signing that we ever made? £500k profit for no apparent reason.

    Oh wait a sec. What about Joe Mason?! :-o

  17. #17

    Re: 25 worst City signings. Agree, Disagree?

    Quote Originally Posted by Bobby Dandruff View Post
    I thought that about Kiss.

    (Not sure about Eddie though.....!)
    Eddie improved massively while he was with us, he went from someone who looked like they had never played Soccer before to someone who you might pick if you were a manager of a lower leagues team

    the question must be, how did he go from being a fairly big player in the MLS to looking like he had never kicked a round ball in his life ? ? ? confidence i guess

  18. #18

    Re: 25 worst City signings. Agree, Disagree?

    What about that Scottish t**t (soz james, but he was) Andy Jordan.

  19. #19

    Re: 25 worst City signings. Agree, Disagree?

    Alan Fogan , Tony Philliskirk , Godfrey Ingrams.

  20. #20

    Re: 25 worst City signings. Agree, Disagree?

    Quote Originally Posted by blue matt View Post
    Eddie improved massively while he was with us, he went from someone who looked like they had never played Soccer before to someone who you might pick if you were a manager of a lower leagues team

    the question must be, how did he go from being a fairly big player in the MLS to looking like he had never kicked a round ball in his life ? ? ? confidence i guess
    Eddie did improve massively while with us right up the day he left when I'd class him as shite.

    He prospered in the MLS because it too was garbage. It's no mystery!

  21. #21

    Re: 25 worst City signings. Agree, Disagree?

    Quote Originally Posted by Michael Morris View Post
    Simon Walton is still only 28. He has had 13 clubs in his career so far. The night he made his debut for City, Feb 2007, I was a guest of the match sponsor. He was voted man of the match because it was his debut.

    He was involved in five more games for us after that getting booked twice and sent off twice.
    Eddie Johnson had a man of the match award too, perhaps the Doncaster game in which he scored his first goal.
    Absolutely scuffed that shot and it travelled in at a blistering 1mph.

  22. #22

    Re: 25 worst City signings. Agree, Disagree?

    I remember that Taiwo debut against QPR far too well...

  23. #23

    Re: 25 worst City signings. Agree, Disagree?

    What a pile of utter shit. Did we never sign Pat Heard, Jeff Chandler, Richard Sendall, Paul Shaw, Paul Milsom and Tony Philliskirk then?

    And that’s just off the top of my head, I bet other long termers can think of dozens more.

  24. #24

    Re: 25 worst City signings. Agree, Disagree?

    Gavin Gordon - like a shit Leo Fortune West.

    And all for the bargain price of 300 grand I believe.

    Pace, heading, movement, strength, determination and an eye for goal - this guy was not very good at them all.

  25. #25

    Re: 25 worst City signings. Agree, Disagree?

    Quote Originally Posted by the other bob wilson View Post
    That article's rubbish for all sorts of reasons. Why not just say the worst signings of the last twenty years if you are unable to remember beyond that? There's factual errors aplenty - Dimi didn't chuck the ball into his own net twice against Wolves, he did it once against them and once against Norwich, Javi Guerra started two games for us, the FA Cup match with Wigan Berget started was a home game, not an away one, I'm still trying to work out what this sentence about Maxi Amondarain means "The defender, who at least looked the part, never came closer (closer than what?) to troubling the first team." and, worst of all, they've forgotten, or just weren't aware, that Eddie Johnson scored the last ever opposition goal at Ninian Park under floodlights as well as the last one for City under the lights!

    Seriously, that article is living proof that you should keep quiet if you've not got anything worthwhile to say.

    The writer must also work for Sky Sports cos they too deny any existence of football pre 1993

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •