Reply With QuoteFair ratings, difficult to argue with any of those.
| + Visit Cardiff FC for Latest News, Transfer Gossip, Fixtures and Match Results |
Amos 6
Peltier 7
Bamba 7.5
Morrison 7.5
Bennett 7
Pilkington 6
Ralls 7
Whittingham 7
Gunnarson 6.5
Hoilett 8.5
Lambert 7.5
Fair ratings, difficult to argue with any of those.
wouldn't be the same without his player ratings,
As usual i broadly agree with your ratings but for me i'd promote gunnerson by .5 to 7 and take .5 off lambert taking him to 7 also
Indeed.Originally Posted by Packerman
They certainly stimulate some football debate which I hope will remain civil.
Welcome back Croesy.
I thought Pilkington was very good today and worked his balls off
Totally agree.Not sure Amos did much wrong either.Team performance for me.
Amos didn't really have much to do so it's hard to give him much of a rating.
I don't see Ralls as having deserved more than Gunns & Pilks and the same as Whitts.
Bam a and Morrison were certainly 0.5 of a point better than Bennett.
Didn't think whitts and ralls were any better than gunnarson to be honest..pilks was quiet though. Agree with the rest..
Thought Fred did well when he came on feeding off scraps
Gunnarson deserved more than Ralls. Lambert 6.5 or 7 at most. Hoilet defo MOM and deserves the 8.5.
Spedger
Gunnarsson our best midfielder and our two centre halves were outstanding.
Think whittingham deserves a 7.5 for an assist and a great pass to Hoilet to start the 2nd goal.
Other than that about right, maybe .5 off for Ralls And .5 on for Gunnar.
Posting Permissions