Anyone going to watch Villa tonight ? I know:-----

[tomm]

Why the hell should Villas first goal not been allowed?

The player who kicked the ball as the keeper spilled it was offside when the shot went in.

[Llanedeyrnblue]

1-2 FT

[BLUETIT]

The player who kicked the ball as the keeper spilled it was offside when the shot went in.

He would be classed as not interfering with play, as he did not attempt to touch the ball.

Why the hell should Villas first goal not been allowed?

The reason I think it should not be allowed, is:--- When the ball is played forward to the player who plays the ball into the keepers arms, the player who eventually scores is way offside, so when the keeper fumbles it, he has gained an unfair advantage, with being stood offside originally.

I don't care if you agree or disagree, I THINK he has gained an unfair advantage

[J R Hartley]

He would be classed as not interfering with play, as he did not attempt to touch the ball.





The reason I think it should not be allowed, is:--- When the ball is played forward to the player who plays the ball into the keepers arms, the player who eventually scores is way offside, so when the keeper fumbles it, he has gained an unfair advantage, with being stood offside originally.

I don't care if you agree or disagree, I THINK he has gained an unfair advantage

I don't care what you THINK, that is not the rules, and you can't make your own up.

[jamieccfc]

I don't care what you THINK, that is not the rules, and you can't make your own up.

[GRUMPYS DEN]

Spot on Bluetit!!!!

[jamieccfc]

He would be classed as not interfering with play, as he did not attempt to touch the ball.





The reason I think it should not be allowed, is:--- When the ball is played forward to the player who plays the ball into the keepers arms, the player who eventually scores is way offside, so when the keeper fumbles it, he has gained an unfair advantage, with being stood offside originally.

I don't care if you agree or disagree, I THINK he has gained an unfair advantage

But when that player challenges the keeper it becomes a new phase thus the player is not offside the keeper ****ed up and played the ball to him