disallowed

[Rhiwbina Blues]

Why was Zohore and Hoilett goals disallowed?

[WJ99mobile]

Why was Zohore and Hoilett goals disallowed?

First one a push but second I have no idea

[the other bob wilson]

First one an alleged push, second one an alleged push - looking at the video though, the ref got it hopelessly wrong on both occasions.

[Seabird]

First one I thought mayhem goes on in the box and the ref could have given it either way but I was mystified by the Hoillett 'goal".

[IanD]

First one an alleged push, second one an alleged push - looking at the video though, the ref got it hopelessly wrong on both occasions.

Didn't have a good view of the first disallowed goal but agree that the goal should have stood having seen it on the video. Had a brilliant view of the second disallowed goal and was totally confused as to why it was disallowed. No offside, no foul. It should have stood. A good argument for video review?

[jon1959]

Both should have stood. Two very poor decisions.

[Heathblue]

Both should have stood. Two very poor decisions.

Having won the game, its water of a ducks back but, and I hear that Warnock praised the ref, I thought he was bloody awful as was the Lino in the 2nd half (City attacking end) the wrestling of big Ken was going unpunished for the full 90 mins, right in the eyes of the ref and the Lino's, not the sneaky stuff from the over the hill professional but blatant wrestling belonging in a ring, perhaps the best example just before the 2nd disallowed goal, right in front of the lino, he couldn't have been any closer, we could have been undone by sheer incompetence and IMO, due to the furore that followed the Wolves game perpetuated by social media which the ref would have been well aware of.

[IanD]

Let's hope goal difference doesn't come into it at the end of the season and yesterday's decisions don't come back to bite us.

[AfricanBluebird]

Both should have stood. Two very poor decisions.

Both should have stood, yeah.

If the ref gave fouls for those kind of incidents consistently then game would still be in added time now with 20 or 30 goals a piece.

Mystifying.

[AfricanBluebird]

Having won the game, its water of a ducks back but, and I hear that Warnock praised the ref, I thought he was bloody awful as was the Lino in the 2nd half (City attacking end) the wrestling of big Ken was going unpunished for the full 90 mins, right in the eyes of the ref and the Lino's, not the sneaky stuff from the over the hill professional but blatant wrestling belonging in a ring, perhaps the best example just before the 2nd disallowed goal, right in front of the lino, he couldn't have been any closer, we could have been undone by sheer incompetence and IMO, due to the furore that followed the Wolves game perpetuated by social media which the ref would have been well aware of.

Agree with that.

At least we are not babies and 'twinging' about it constantly on twitter like Wolves fans... although maybe if we hadn't won some fans would have. Saying that Wolves didn't have two perfectly good goals disallowed.

[Nobody's Rep]

Having won the game, its water of a ducks back but, and I hear that Warnock praised the ref, I thought he was bloody awful as was the Lino in the 2nd half (City attacking end) the wrestling of big Ken was going unpunished for the full 90 mins, right in the eyes of the ref and the Lino's, not the sneaky stuff from the over the hill professional but blatant wrestling belonging in a ring, perhaps the best example just before the 2nd disallowed goal, right in front of the lino, he couldn't have been any closer, we could have been undone by sheer incompetence and IMO, due to the furore that followed the Wolves game perpetuated by social media which the ref would have been well aware of.

The post match interview I heard Warnock was critical of the ref for all the holding and shirt pulling but Nathan Blake felt the ref had a great game and let it flow?

Me I thought he was the latest in a long line of shite at the city.

[jamieccfc]

The lino on the ninian side may as well not been there gives offside when long was on then let's him carry on when he must've been at least 5 yards off he was useless

[Baloo]

Agree with that.

At least we are not babies and 'twinging' about it constantly on twitter like Wolves fans... although maybe if we hadn't won some fans would have. Saying that Wolves didn't have two perfectly good goals disallowed.

Shouldn't that be 'twhinging'?

The shirt pulling on Zahore was so clear and close to him I can only assume the Lino felt that it doesn't contravene the rules of the game.

[MacAdder]

For "Leighton James" read "referees"

https://youtu.be/Of0Ci6HLJu0

[Eric the Half a Bee]

Let's hope goal difference doesn't come into it at the end of the season and yesterday's decisions don't come back to bite us.

It would have been worse if that last minute scramble in front of our goal had gone in.

[IanD]

It would have been worse if that last minute scramble in front of our goal had gone in.

And how many times has that happened in the past? Thankfully it didn't and we are still top of the league. I've watched the highlights again and still can't spot any fouls for the two disallowed goals.
Moan over. Bring on Fulham and let's have some of this
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hsqpN8bvAPo

[bluethrough]

It would be nice if incidents like these were clarified after games, just to help fans understand the thinking. In fact its probably a good idea for a 2 hour show on Sunday morning.

[bobh]

It would be nice if incidents like these were clarified after games, just to help fans understand the thinking. In fact its probably a good idea for a 2 hour show on Sunday morning.

If onle of the TV channels did something like that.

[IanD]

If onle of the TV channels did something like that.

"We Thought We'd Scored" with Gabby presenting��

[I.8.POLITICAL.CORRECTNESS]

Why was Zohore and Hoilett goals disallowed?

the first one I cant comment as I was being asked am I going to wales game on Saturday by the guy who sits (stands) lol
in front of me in the canton have done since day one at new Ninian Park natters on like he is at the salon lol
the 2nd one is baffling as there was no compliant from any of the QPR players about the goal
I couldn't (even with my blue tinted specs) couldn't see why the goal was disallowed there wasn't an offside or a foul or a foul I could see
ref did have a bit of a shocker there just as well it din cost us points

as a side note
well done City and well done everyone of you

[LordKenwyne]

The handball was the funniest. One of the most blatant I have ever seen. On the grandstand side in the second half towards their goal.