+ Visit Cardiff FC for Latest News, Transfer Gossip, Fixtures and Match Results
Results 1 to 24 of 24

Thread: If there was to be a Celtic football side...

  1. #1

    If there was to be a Celtic football side...

    Northern Ireland losing tonight and with me hoping Ireland get absolutely hammered in their Play Off, got me thinking of a hypothetical all Celtic team if none of them made the WC.

    Which of the Wales players would make it other than Bale, Ramsey, Allen, Davies and Williams? Or would only Bale or Ramsey be assured of a starting place in your opinion?

    Would you put Hennessy in there? Or how about the ever present Gunter?

    Then which NI, Scottish or Irish would make it? Snodgrass, Jonny Evans, Leigh Griffiths, Craig Gordon, Harry Arter perhaps?


  2. #2

    Re: If there was to be a Celtic football side...

    The ROI keeper is good

  3. #3

    Re: If there was to be a Celtic football side...

    Don't think many non-Welsh would get in there other than up front tbh.

  4. #4

    Re: If there was to be a Celtic football side...

    Quote Originally Posted by Arfur Europe View Post
    Northern Ireland losing tonight and with me hoping Ireland get absolutely hammered in their Play Off, got me thinking of a hypothetical all Celtic team if none of them made the WC.

    Which of the Wales players would make it other than Bale, Ramsey, Allen, Davies and Williams? Or would only Bale or Ramsey be assured of a starting place in your opinion?

    Would you put Hennessy in there? Or how about the ever present Gunter?

    Then which NI, Scottish or Irish would make it? Snodgrass, Jonny Evans, Leigh Griffiths, Craig Gordon, Harry Arter perhaps?

    I'll leave who plays to the rest of you, what I will guarantee is that Coleman wouldn't be the coach.

  5. #5

    Re: If there was to be a Celtic football side...

    Quote Originally Posted by ccfc_is_my_life View Post
    Don't think many non-Welsh would get in there other than up front tbh.
    I think there would be more non Welsh than Welsh.
    We are weak in defence, goalkeeper and striker

  6. #6

    Re: If there was to be a Celtic football side...

    ramsey allen ben davies bale

    the rest from elsewhere i'd imagine?

    we've got decent players in other positions but I think we overate them

  7. #7

    Re: If there was to be a Celtic football side...

    Quote Originally Posted by Rjk View Post
    I think there would be more non Welsh than Welsh.
    We are weak in defence, goalkeeper and striker
    Actually, I take that back, just tried to work out a team and there is a lot of crap out there in all teams.

    I came up with a 4-2-3-1

    Keeper Hennessy

    RB Gunter

    CB j Evans
    CB a Williams

    Lb Ben Davies

    Cm Allen
    Cm McCarthy

    RaM bale
    AMC Ramsey
    Lam Brady

    CF long

    So I make that 7 Welsh, 3 republic of Ireland and 1 Northern Ireland, and we are still shit up front, at right back and at keeper.

  8. #8

    Re: If there was to be a Celtic football side...

    No Scottish players?

  9. #9

    Re: If there was to be a Celtic football side...

    Quote Originally Posted by Toadstool View Post
    No Scottish players?
    Kieran Tierney should be in there

    he's touted to go to the big boys in the premier league

    and leigh griffiths up top

  10. #10

    Re: If there was to be a Celtic football side...

    Quote Originally Posted by LordKenwyne View Post
    Kieran Tierney should be in there

    he's touted to go to the big boys in the premier league

    and leigh griffiths up top
    Tierney looks a prospect but not ahead of Ben Davies who is already playing for one of the premier league big boys and having an excellent season.

    Griffiths perhaps, if he can do it at a higher level.

  11. #11

    Re: If there was to be a Celtic football side...

    Bale, Ramsey, Allen, Davies, Woodburn, Brooks & Ampadu!

  12. #12

    Re: If there was to be a Celtic football side...

    Quote Originally Posted by Rjk View Post
    Actually, I take that back, just tried to work out a team and there is a lot of crap out there in all teams.

    I came up with a 4-2-3-1

    Keeper Hennessy

    RB Gunter

    CB j Evans
    CB a Williams

    Lb Ben Davies

    Cm Allen
    Cm McCarthy

    RaM bale
    AMC Ramsey
    Lam Brady

    CF long

    So I make that 7 Welsh, 3 republic of Ireland and 1 Northern Ireland, and we are still shit up front, at right back and at keeper.
    Shane Long hasn't scored for about 30 games. You can't play Long. I'd play Davies in a back 5, with Tierney at LWB and drop Brady, and I'd probably play Griffiths up front, or Bale through the middle which I think will happen for Wales in a few years now the emergence of Brooks and Woodburn has happened.

  13. #13

    Re: If there was to be a Celtic football side...

    Disappointingly, none of these teams are that much better than we currently are, and aside from Bale and on a good day Ramsey you could say the same for the other Celtic teams

  14. #14

    Re: If there was to be a Celtic football side...

    Apparently there's a Breton national team to, so do we throw them into the mix?

    Jeremie Menez, Yann Kermogant and indeed one Adam Levine Fondre would be eligible.

  15. #15

    Re: If there was to be a Celtic football side...

    Adam le Fondre FFS autocorrect

  16. #16

    Re: If there was to be a Celtic football side...

    Quote Originally Posted by Rjk View Post
    Apparently there's a Breton national team to, so do we throw them into the mix?

    Jeremie Menez, Yann Kermogant and indeed one Adam Levine Fondre would be eligible.
    Yeah, go on, why the hell not.

    It's just important people don't misunderstand it to mean 'Britain'.

  17. #17

    Re: If there was to be a Celtic football side...

    Quote Originally Posted by Rjk View Post
    Apparently there's a Breton national team to, so do we throw them into the mix?

    Jeremie Menez, Yann Kermogant and indeed one Adam Levine Fondre would be eligible.
    None of the above would get in a Wales side, let alone a British team. Menez would have started 3/4 years ago but he's past his best now.

  18. #18

    Re: If there was to be a Celtic football side...

    Quote Originally Posted by Pedro de la Rosa View Post
    None of the above would get in a Wales side, let alone a British team. Menez would have started 3/4 years ago but he's past his best now.
    Those weren't serious suggestions.
    Not too familiar with many of the names in the Breton national team, there may be some decent players in there.
    When you consider the number of caps that Simon church seems to amass I think we would still be picking Menez

  19. #19

    Re: If there was to be a Celtic football side...

    Quote Originally Posted by Arfur Europe View Post
    Yeah, go on, why the hell not.

    It's just important people don't misunderstand it to mean 'Britain'.
    It does mean Britain really.
    We'd have arguably more right to the name than the interlopers from Germany

  20. #20

    Re: If there was to be a Celtic football side...


  21. #21

    Re: If there was to be a Celtic football side...

    This is based off the current squads, its slim pickings to be honest

    Hennessey (WAL)

    Christie (ROI)
    J.Evans (NIR)
    A.Williams (WAL)
    Davies (WAL)

    Allen (WAL)
    Davies (NIR)

    Bale (WAL)
    Ramsey (WAL)
    Phillips (SCO)

    Vokes (WAL)

    I make it 7 Welshmen, Hennessey is the only debatable Welsh inclusion IMO, only reason he's in is because there is nobody else playing at a higher level

  22. #22

    Re: If there was to be a Celtic football side...

    Quote Originally Posted by City123 View Post
    This is based off the current squads, its slim pickings to be honest

    Hennessey (WAL)

    Christie (ROI)
    J.Evans (NIR)
    A.Williams (WAL)
    Davies (WAL)

    Allen (WAL)
    Davies (NIR)

    Bale (WAL)
    Ramsey (WAL)
    Phillips (SCO)

    Vokes (WAL)

    I make it 7 Welshmen, Hennessey is the only debatable Welsh inclusion IMO, only reason he's in is because there is nobody else playing at a higher level
    I'd debate vokes until I lost all moisture in my mouth from talking.

  23. #23

    Re: If there was to be a Celtic football side...

    There is a Celtic football side.

  24. #24

    Re: If there was to be a Celtic football side...

    So true jack Coleman as not got a clue

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •