What would you prefer?

[Eric the Half a Bee]

We've been to cup finals, playoff finals and won promotion in recent years. Thinking ahead to a certain cup tie, while comfortably challenging for promotion, which would you prefer if it could happen? This is more a hypothetical question I guess.

[J R Hartley]

We've been to cup finals, playoff finals and won promotion in recent years. Thinking ahead to a certain cup tie, while comfortably challenging for promotion, which would you prefer if it could happen?

Wouldn’t say we were comfortably challenging for promotion at the moment tbh.

In answer to the question then winning a major trophy over playing for 17th on the premier league any day of the week.

[J R Hartley]

How can you answer a poll on mobile version?

[Joe Gillis]

FA Cup Final

[Eric the Half a Bee]

How can you answer a poll on mobile version?

Not sure. I presume it's not visible in mobile mode then?

[J R Hartley]

Not sure. I presume it's not visible in mobile mode then?

No. Unless I’m being blind.

[Louth]

Winning the FA cup all day long.

[Badly Ironed Shirt]

Promotion seasons are hard to beat, but a good and unexpected cup run is magic, especially if you're in the lower leagues.

[Arfur Europe]

That's a tough one. It really is.

We've done the FA Cup Final, so that has lost it's magic for me now. I also hate the Play Offs, and simply making a final means nothing, as we all know too well.

I've therefore decided to abstain on this one.

[Llanedeyrnblue]

Cup final

[jamieccfc]

That's a tough one. It really is.

We've done the FA Cup Final, so that has lost it's magic for me now. I also hate the Play Offs, and simply making a final means nothing, as we all know too well.

I've therefore decided to abstain on this one.

This.

I don't think I can take any more heartbreak. Cardiff city the club that almost gives but then slaps you in the face

[Zenith]

FA Cup win guarantees Europe and that would be a great experience.

We can still get promoted automatically so it's a no brainer at this moment.

[dembethewarrior]

No. Unless I’m being blind.

Have to switch to full mode for a poll, I change back then.

[Pedro de la Rosa]

Nobody will remember our 3/4 years in the Prem in 50 years. If we won the cup, Christ, we still talk about 1927!

[Des Parrot]

Where's the Anthony Gerrard option?

[Harry Monk]

Poll only asks which final we'd like to reach, not whether we'd want promotion over a cup win. I would prefer the 3rd option of automatic promotion rather than reaching either of the finals.