+ Visit Cardiff FC for Latest News, Transfer Gossip, Fixtures and Match Results
Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 25 of 29

Thread: Players to keep if we go up

  1. #1

    Players to keep if we go up

    Certainly not counting chickens but I am sure Warnock and his team are already formulating plans for next year.
    I suspect he would keep the bulk of the first team squad with perhaps 5/6 additions.

    I think these are certs:

    Etheridge
    Manga
    Bamba
    Morrison
    Ralls
    Hoilett
    Madine
    Zohore
    Paterson

    These are possibles

    Richards
    Bennett
    Peltier
    Tomlin

    These will go

    All the loanees plus
    Halford
    Feeney
    Mendez Laing
    Pilks
    Harris
    Bogle
    Connolly
    Gunnar
    any thoughts?????????????????

  2. #2

    Re: Players to keep if we go up

    Quote Originally Posted by jeremy corbyn View Post
    Certainly not counting chickens but I am sure Warnock and his team are already formulating plans for next year.
    I suspect he would keep the bulk of the first team squad with perhaps 5/6 additions.

    I think these are certs:

    Etheridge
    Manga
    Bamba
    Morrison
    Ralls
    Hoilett
    Madine
    Zohore
    Paterson

    These are possibles

    Richards
    Bennett
    Peltier
    Tomlin

    These will go

    All the loanees plus
    Halford
    Feeney
    Mendez Laing
    Pilks
    Harris
    Bogle
    Connolly
    Gunnar
    any thoughts?????????????????

    I think you've called it pretty much spot on. I wouldn't argue with any of that except I don't think Tomlin has a future with us anymore. It's as much about him not willing to relocate here as much as his fitness issues.

    Sad to see NML on the list to go, who would have thought that after the first 10 or so games, eh! However, he's not stepped up to the plate, so yeah, needs to go.

  3. #3
    International jon1959's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2007
    Location
    Sheffield - out of Roath
    Posts
    15,892

    Re: Players to keep if we go up

    Quote Originally Posted by jeremy corbyn View Post
    Certainly not counting chickens but I am sure Warnock and his team are already formulating plans for next year.
    I suspect he would keep the bulk of the first team squad with perhaps 5/6 additions.

    I think these are certs:

    Etheridge
    Manga
    Bamba
    Morrison
    Ralls
    Hoilett
    Madine
    Zohore
    Paterson

    These are possibles

    Richards
    Bennett
    Peltier
    Tomlin

    These will go

    All the loanees plus
    Halford
    Feeney
    Mendez Laing
    Pilks
    Harris
    Bogle
    Connolly
    Gunnar
    any thoughts?????????????????

    Feeney is a loanee.

    I would not be surprised to see Gunnar and Kadeem stay if we go up.

  4. #4

    Re: Players to keep if we go up

    Who do we keep for the Champions League the year after?

  5. #5

    Re: Players to keep if we go up

    Quote Originally Posted by jon1959 View Post
    Feeney is a loanee.

    I would not be surprised to see Gunnar and Kadeem stay if we go up.
    I fear neither would be good enough.

  6. #6

    Re: Players to keep if we go up

    I see creating a squad of players for the Premiership not as a problem, but a fantastic opportunity.
    Here are just a few of the available players without a contract at present - and factor in those with serious injuries and there are hundreds, if not thousands, of potential bargains (I stress these are ALL English and the majority were born north of the Midlands):

    Players 1.jpg
    Players 2.jpg
    Players 3.jpg

  7. #7

    Re: Players to keep if we go up

    Quote Originally Posted by Coch View Post
    I see creating a squad of players for the Premiership not as a problem, but a fantastic opportunity.
    Here are just a few of the available players without a contract at present - and factor in those with serious injuries and there are hundreds, if not thousands, of potential bargains (I stress these are ALL English and the majority were born north of the Midlands):

    Players 1.jpg
    Players 2.jpg
    Players 3.jpg
    Lee Naylor still going?

  8. #8

    Re: Players to keep if we go up

    As long as Malkay has no involvement I'll go with the flow.
    If Gunnerson cant be bothered to sign now, bugger it, we look elsewhere, he's good , but not good enough for the Premier

  9. #9

    Re: Players to keep if we go up

    Quote Originally Posted by jeremy corbyn View Post
    Certainly not counting chickens but I am sure Warnock and his team are already formulating plans for next year.
    I suspect he would keep the bulk of the first team squad with perhaps 5/6 additions.

    I think these are certs:

    Etheridge
    Manga
    Bamba
    Morrison
    Ralls
    Hoilett
    Madine
    Zohore
    Paterson

    These are possibles

    Richards
    Bennett
    Peltier
    Tomlin

    These will go

    All the loanees plus
    Halford
    Feeney
    Mendez Laing
    Pilks
    Harris
    Bogle
    Connolly
    Gunnar
    any thoughts?????????????????
    Near enough the same as you. Though I would include damour. I think he has some more developing to do, could be a great asset with the right coaching.
    Out of the possibles, I would keep all except peltier.
    Spedger

  10. #10

    Re: Players to keep if we go up

    Quote Originally Posted by Coch View Post
    I see creating a squad of players for the Premiership not as a problem, but a fantastic opportunity.
    Here are just a few of the available players without a contract at present - and factor in those with serious injuries and there are hundreds, if not thousands, of potential bargains (I stress these are ALL English and the majority were born north of the Midlands):

    Players 1.jpg
    Players 2.jpg
    Players 3.jpg
    Not sure I'd want any of that lot

  11. #11

    Re: Players to keep if we go up

    Quote Originally Posted by Wales-Bales View Post
    Who do we keep for the Champions League the year after?
    The year after? Wolves will be looking to win the cup for the second time by then

  12. #12

    Re: Players to keep if we go up

    Quote Originally Posted by Rjk View Post
    Not sure I'd want any of that lot
    Come on, you'd fancy Osei Sankofa. He's played for Whitehawk AND Boreham Wood.

  13. #13

    Re: Players to keep if we go up

    Quote Originally Posted by Pedro de la Rosa View Post
    Come on, you'd fancy Osei Sankofa. He's played for Whitehawk AND Boreham Wood.
    Apart from him, obviously

  14. #14

    Re: Players to keep if we go up

    Quote Originally Posted by life on mars View Post
    Lee Naylor still going?
    Let's re-sign him and Chopra!

  15. #15

    Re: Players to keep if we go up

    If IF we go up, think it's really important that we keep the 3 main centre backs.
    We would be having to do a lot of defending if we go up and I think it's really important to have players playing together there who know each others games.
    Last time we went up with Hudson as our best defender, but they obviously were worried he would get exposed by pace in the premier league, so he barely got a game.

  16. #16

    Re: Players to keep if we go up

    Gunners, NML and i think connolly would all stay

    also were we to get there, a season long loan for Grujic might well be an option.

    of the other loan signings i dont see any being good enough.

  17. #17

    Re: Players to keep if we go up

    I think Tan will spend very little as relegation from the Premier League is a near certainty as it is unlikely that the funds needed to stay up will be made available. Tan wants some of his money back and who can blame him.

  18. #18

    Re: Players to keep if we go up

    Harsh on Bennett, he is comfortably good enough to be our LB if we went up imo.

  19. #19

    Re: Players to keep if we go up

    Quote Originally Posted by jeremy corbyn View Post
    Certainly not counting chickens but I am sure Warnock and his team are already formulating plans for next year.
    I suspect he would keep the bulk of the first team squad with perhaps 5/6 additions.

    I think these are certs:

    Etheridge
    Manga
    Bamba
    Morrison
    Ralls
    Hoilett
    Madine
    Zohore
    Paterson

    These are possibles

    Richards
    Bennett
    Peltier
    Tomlin

    These will go

    All the loanees plus
    Halford
    Feeney
    Mendez Laing
    Pilks
    Harris
    Bogle
    Connolly
    Gunnar
    any thoughts?????????????????
    I can see your rational but could you see Warnock making 10-12 new signings.Not sure I can.

  20. #20

    Re: Players to keep if we go up

    Quote Originally Posted by jeremy corbyn View Post
    Certainly not counting chickens but I am sure Warnock and his team are already formulating plans for next year.
    I suspect he would keep the bulk of the first team squad with perhaps 5/6 additions.

    I think these are certs:

    Etheridge
    Manga
    Bamba
    Morrison
    Ralls
    Hoilett
    Madine
    Zohore
    Paterson

    These are possibles

    Richards
    Bennett
    Peltier
    Tomlin

    These will go

    All the loanees plus
    Halford
    Feeney
    Mendez Laing
    Pilks
    Harris
    Bogle
    Connolly
    Gunnar
    any thoughts?????????????????
    Of those I can see Mendez Laing, Bennett and Gunnar definitely staying.

  21. #21

    Re: Players to keep if we go up

    Keep the basic squad together

    Too many poncey players in the premier who won't like to come up against a hard tackling hard working Warnock team that never give up

    If Burnley , Watford and Bournemouth and Huddersfield can stay up without slashing cash then so can we

  22. #22

    Re: Players to keep if we go up

    Quote Originally Posted by Rjk View Post
    Of those I can see Mendez Laing, Bennett and Gunnar definitely staying.
    Gunnar will stay if we go up , if not he's off , he's already told Warnock who has accepted that

  23. #23

    Re: Players to keep if we go up

    Mods should delete this thread as it is just tempting fate.

  24. #24

    Re: Players to keep if we go up

    So we get rid of 7 non-loanees.

    We're not going to make 7 big signings to replace with far better quality.

    We've a good core squad who have fantastic spirit which will be essential in the Prem. Give those players a chance for jettisoning them. Add in quality here and there.

  25. #25

    Re: Players to keep if we go up

    Gunners and Mendez Laing will stay if we go up and Warnock will be given 50m, the same as Malky but I’m not sure if NW can keep us up and a change may be necessary around Christmas if we are struggling. However let’s get there first!

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •