I'm going for the 2012/13 team because of how most of them went on to perform in the Premiership.
I think our present side would struggle bigtime in the bigtime.
If my memory is correct, I was more certain of a good result before a game in 2012/13 too - having greater confidence in the team's ability to perform consistently.
But there's only a fag-paper between the two. So, 2012/13 to win over two legs on penalties.....