Based on their personality, not ability. They can be currently playing or retired.

Mine are:

Favourite

1. Sol Bamba (Always comes across as a really nice fella)
2. Gianfranco Zola
3. Robbie Savage (A controversial one, but I've really warmed to him since his podcast with Freddie Flintoff)

Hated

1. John Terry
2. Alan Tate
3. Jack Grealish