Player ratings thread: Cardiff City v Newcastle United

[Michael Morris]

Etheridge -
Camarasa -
Morrison -
Manga -
Bennett -
Bamba -
Murphy -
Ralls -
Arter -
Hoilett -
Zohore -

NM-L -
Paterson -
Reid -

Quote OP and add your ratings.

[jamieccfc]

Etheridge -10
Camarasa -8
Morrison -6
Manga -7
Bennett -7
Bamba -7
Murphy -9
Ralls -8
Arter -9
Hoilett -5
Zohore -6

NM-L -
Paterson -
Reid -

Quote OP and add your ratings.[/QUOTE]

[Cleve van Leef]

Etheridge - 10
Camarasa - 8
Morrison - 7
Manga - 7
Bennett - 7
Bamba - 8
Murphy - 9
Ralls - 7
Arter - 8
Hoilett - 6
Zohore - 5

NM-L - 6
Paterson - 6
Reid - 6

Quote OP and add your ratings.

Arter would have more but for that tackle.

[Blooburd]

Etheridge -10
Camarasa -6
Morrison -7
Manga -7
Bennett -8
Bamba -7
Murphy -9
Ralls -8
Arter -9
Hoilett -4
Zohore -6

NM-L - 6 almost 7
Paterson - 6 almost 7
Reid - 4

Warnock - 6

Overall the players played well and were unfortunate to only get a draw. However it baffled me that Warnock took off Murphy for NML when hoilett was having a shocker! Murphy at 30% would've been better than hoilett in that match

[Former Labour leader]

Overall the players played well and were unfortunate to only get a draw. However it baffled me that Warnock took off Murphy for NML when hoilett was having a shocker! Murphy at 30% would've been better than hoilett in that match

Hoilett took a heavy knock early on. Doubt he'll be playing next Saturday.

[Former Labour leader]

Etheridge -9
Camarasa -7
Morrison -7
Manga -8
Bennett -7
Bamba -7
Murphy -7
Ralls -6
Arter -8
Hoilett -6
Zohore -5

NM-L -
Paterson -
Reid -

Quote OP and add your ratings.

Manga was my MOM.
I would play Paterson at centre forward. Zohore's job is to score goals which he clearly can't, particularly with his head.

[soulsurfer3]

Etheridge -8
Camarasa -8
Morrison -7
Manga -7
Bennett -6
Bamba -7
Murphy -8
Ralls -7
Arter -8
Hoilett -5
Zohore -5

NM-L -
Paterson -
Reid -

Quote OP and add your ratings.

Ken has got to improve fast, wasting chances in this league is a luxury we can`t afford. I like Ken but he has to show more than he did today.

[severncity]

Etheridge - 10
Camarasa - 9
Morrison - 8
Manga - 8
Bennett - 8
Bamba - 8
Murphy - 8
Ralls - 8
Arter - 9
Hoilett - 6
Zohore - 7

NM-L -
Paterson -
Reid -

Quote OP and add your ratings.

Great performance

[mazadona10]

If these are the ratings we get for drawing 0-0 at home to a midtable or below team imagine we win a game.

[Des Parrot]

Etheridge - 8
Camarasa - 8
Morrison - 6
Manga - 5
Bennett - 6
Bamba - 5
Murphy - 9
Ralls - 7
Arter - 8
Hoilett - 5
Zohore - 7

NM-L - 5
Paterson - na
Reid - na

[Bald Barry Bastad]

Etheridge - 7
Camarasa -8
Morrison -7
Manga -7
Bennett -6
Bamba -7
Murphy -7
Ralls -6
Arter -8
Hoilett -5
Zohore -6

NM-L - 6
Paterson -
Reid -

[BLUEAWAY]

Etheridge - 9
Camarasa - 8
Morrison - 8
Manga - 8
Bennett -8
Bamba - 8
Murphy -8
Ralls - 8
Arter -9
Hoilett -7
Zohore -7

NM-L - 5
Paterson -
Reid -

Quote OP and add your ratings.

Overall, a very encouraging performance

[RichardM]

Overall, a very encouraging performance

Can't say that I was very encouraged. Newcastle were poor but we never really looked like scoring.
Camarasa is getting good ratings but I thought he gave away/lost the ball too often.
Is Etheridge getting such high ratings just for saving an awful penalty? He had little else to do.
I thought Murphy and Arter were good.

[rich munn]

Etheridge - 8
Camarasa - 7
Morrison -8
Manga -6
Bennett -7
Bamba -5
Murphy - 7
Ralls - 7
Arter - 8
Hoilett -6
Zohore -6

NM-L - 6
Paterson - 6
Reid - 5

Quote OP and add your ratings.

OK see above

[jon1959]

Can't say that I was very encouraged. Newcastle were poor but we never really looked like scoring.
Camarasa is getting good ratings but I thought he gave away/lost the ball too often.
Is Etheridge getting such high ratings just for saving an awful penalty? He had little else to do.
I thought Murphy and Arter were good.

Etheridge made two great blocks in the first half - spread himself to stop certain goals. He did well.

[RichardM]

Etheridge made two great blocks in the first half - spread himself to stop certain goals. He did well.

Yes, I thought about those just after I posted, but we are used to him doing that

[Michael Morris]

Sky Sports ratings

Cardiff: Etheridge (8), Morrison (5), Manga (6), Bennett (6), Bamba (6), Camarasa (6), Arter (6), Ralls (6), Murphy (8), Hoilett (5), Zohore (5)

Subs: Reid (5), Mendez-Laing (5), Paterson (5)

Newcastle: Dubravka (6), Dummett (6), Clark (6), Lascelles (6), Manquillo (5), Ritchie (5), Diame (5), Shelvey (5), Kenedy (3), Perez (5), Joselu (5)

Subs: Hayden (4), Murphy (5), Muto (5)

Man of the match: Josh Murphy

[surge]

Etheridge - 7.5
Bennett - 7
Manga - 6.5
Morrison - 7
Bamba - 6.5
Camarasa - 7
Ralls - 7
Arter - 7.5
Murphy - 7
Hoilett - 7
Zohore - 6.5

NM-L - 6
Paterson - 6.5
Reid - 6.5

Quote OP and add your ratings.

10x better than last week but hopefully not as good as next weekend.

[Penarth Blues]

Etheridge - 9
Camarasa - 8
Morrison - 8
Manga - 7
Bennett - 8
Bamba - 7
Murphy - 9
Ralls - 8
Arter - 9
Hoilett - 7
Zohore - 6

NM-L - 6
Paterson - 6
Reid - 6

Quote OP and add your ratings.

Some good performances today

[StraightOuttaCanton]

Etheridge - 9
Camarasa - 8
Morrison - 7
Manga - 7
Bennett - 7
Bamba - 6
Murphy - 8
Ralls - 7
Arter - 9
Hoilett - 7
Zohore - 7

NM-L -
Paterson -
Reid -

Quote OP and add your ratings.

.

[the other bob wilson]

Yes, I thought about those just after I posted, but we are used to him doing that

So that means he should, effectively, be penalised for them? Etheridge was an obvious man of the match for me.

Etheridge - 8
Camarasa - 7
Morrison - 7
Manga - 6
Bennett - 6
Bamba - 6
Murphy - 6
Ralls - 7
Arter - 7
Hoilett - 5
Zohore - 6

NM-L - 5
Paterson - not on long enough
Reid - 5

Lack of precision at dead ball situations and with the final ball means I can't mark our attacking players higher than that.

[The Lone Gunman]

Etheridge - 9
Camarasa - 5
Morrison - 7
Manga - 6
Bennett - 5
Bamba - 6
Murphy - 8
Ralls - 7
Arter - 8
Hoilett - 4
Zohore - 3

I was surprised at how ineffective Hoilett was. Am I right in thinking he's better on the left-hand side of the attack as a rule? Etheridge was excellent. He's improved significantly from this time last year. Arter will no doubt be a very useful addition to the side. Camarasa was OK but seemed to struggle with the pace of the game a little. Murphy looks an exciting talent, but Zohore was really poor throughout.

[LeningradCowboy]

Etheridge made two great blocks in the first half - spread himself to stop certain goals. He did well.

He needs to improve his distribution though. Got us in trouble a few times with misplaced clearances.

[Llanedeyrnblue]

Etheridge -9.....distribution cost him a point
Camarasa - 7
Morrison -8
Manga -6
Bennett -7
Bamba -8
Murphy -8
Ralls -6.......set piece delivery terrible
Arter -8
Hoilett-7
Zohore -6

NM-L - 6
Paterson -7
Reid - 6

Quote OP and add your ratings.

.

[BlueArmy 86]

Etheridge -8
Camarasa - 7
Morrison - 7
Manga - 7
Bennett - 7
Bamba - 6
Murphy - 7
Ralls - 6
Arter - 8
Hoilett - 6
Zohore - 6

..