Player ratings

[WJ99mobile]

Here’s mine

Ethridge - 5 nothing majorly wrong, nothing worthy of note to bring score up. Not at fault for any of the goals

Manga - 3 categorically the most over rated player in our club

Morrison - 4 poor. Slow. Exposed. Maybe a game too early.

Bamba - 5

Bennett - 4 poor game for him

Bacuna - 4 anonymous - obviously man marking but never really got close enough

After 5 - a few big mistakes but did put in the effort

Ralls 5 - didn’t really dictate the game.

Paterson - 6 played in a wing back position but was never really in game. At least gave 100%

Murphy - 4 just nothing he tried came off

Niasse - 6 tried. Ran the channels no support from the midfield

I think I’m being a bit generous too

[surge]

First half:

Ethridge - 6.5
Manga - 5
Morrison - 4
Bamba - 5
Bennett - 6

Bacuna - 6

After - 5
Ralls - 4.5
Paterson - 5
Murphy - 6

Niasse - 6

Second half:

Ethridge - 5
Manga - 3
Morrison - 3
Bamba - 6.5
Bennett - 6

Bacuna - 5

After - 5
Ralls - 4
Paterson - 6.5
Murphy - 3

Niasse - 4

[Bald Barry Bastad]

Here’s mine

Ethridge - 5 nothing majorly wrong, nothing worthy of note to bring score up. Not at fault for any of the goals

Manga - 3 categorically the most over rated player in our club

Morrison - 4 poor. Slow. Exposed. Maybe a game too early.

Bamba - 5

Bennett - 4 poor game for him

Bacuna - 4 anonymous - obviously man marking but never really got close enough

After 5 - a few big mistakes but did put in the effort

Ralls 5 - didn’t really dictate the game.

Paterson - 6 played in a wing back position but was never really in game. At least gave 100%

Murphy - 4 just nothing he tried came off

Niasse - 6 tried. Ran the channels no support from the midfield

I think I’m being a bit generous too

Agree with these but Morrison was worse than Manga. Would have given him a 2.

[Joe Gillis]

Ralls 3

[jamieccfc]

Ralls 3

What do you think warnock says to him? “Now you Joe play here and run around the centre circle a few times good lad”

[Des Parrot]

First half:

Ethridge - 5
Manga - 5
Morrison - 5
Bamba - 5
Bennett - 6

Bacuna - 6

After - 5
Ralls - 5
Paterson - 5
Murphy - 6

Niasse - 6

Second half:

Ethridge - 3
Manga - 2
Morrison - 3
Bamba - 6
Bennett - 6

Bacuna - 5

After - 5
Ralls - 4
Paterson - 6
Murphy - 4

Niasse - 4

Very similar but a few minor changes.
MoM Bennett, Bamba, Paterson
Ok (just) Bacuna, Ralls
Rest poor