Madine or Bogle

[Dorcus]

I'm still down in the dumps after a long trip to Wigan and watching a mediocre performance on our part. We obviously need to sort out the defence and midfield pdq because yesterday we were under the weather in both areas of play.

However, with the debut of Glatzel coming soon I wonder who will be given the second berth as striker. Judging by yesterday's performance it surely has to be Bogle. Madine was ok when he was on but in truth never looked the part. Bogle on the other hand grabbed his chance with both hands. He appears to link well with our other forward players, gets into good positions and always looks capable of scoring. I for one would love to see Madine sent packing and that would be a further vote of confidence in Bogle.

[ToTaL ITK]

for me Bogle...seems to had an ok pre-season

[The Bob Banker Spanker]

Bogle is the only natural finisher at the club and has done well here in my opinion given that nigh on all his appearances have come from the bench.

[The Bob Banker Spanker]

As an aside I think Bogle would’ve flourished in a Dave Jones team.
Warnock has said he doesn’t have much success with strikers but after 40 years of management he must realise it’s his style of football that’s the problem, not every striker he’s had.

[jon1959]

Bogle.

[life on mars]

Bogle liked his finish and pre season goals I think he has ability, just needs to work on a cool head and touch, all of which comes with game time .

He's only just turned 25.

Since 2017 he's played 60 odd games at 4 clubs.

[Chris Pontprennau Blues]

Has to be Bogle - the one hes scored yesterday is more than Madine since he been here

[RonnieBird]

If it was Madine or Charlie Chuck I'd go for Chuck every time.
I'm sorry that it hasn't worked out for Gary Madine, but it's never going to work for him here.
Bogle's not really good enough either to be honest , but if that's all we've got so be it.

[dicey1966]

Like Tomlin, I feel Bogle is making up the numbers until Warnock wants shot of him. Hope the lad is given another opportunity

[Eric the Half a Bee]

I'm still down in the dumps after a long trip to Wigan and watching a mediocre performance on our part. We obviously need to sort out the defence and midfield pdq because yesterday we were under the weather in both areas of play.

However, with the debut of Glatzel coming soon I wonder who will be given the second berth as striker. Judging by yesterday's performance it surely has to be Bogle. Madine was ok when he was on but in truth never looked the part. Bogle on the other hand grabbed his chance with both hands. He appears to link well with our other forward players, gets into good positions and always looks capable of scoring. I for one would love to see Madine sent packing and that would be a further vote of confidence in Bogle.

Bogle showed enough desire in 10 minutes to deserve the shirt next time around. That's more desire than Zohore has shown in 2 years.

[Ianto13]

I'm still down in the dumps after a long trip to Wigan and watching a mediocre performance on our part. We obviously need to sort out the defence and midfield pdq because yesterday we were under the weather in both areas of play.

However, with the debut of Glatzel coming soon I wonder who will be given the second berth as striker. Judging by yesterday's performance it surely has to be Bogle. Madine was ok when he was on but in truth never looked the part. Bogle on the other hand grabbed his chance with both hands. He appears to link well with our other forward players, gets into good positions and always looks capable of scoring. I for one would love to see Madine sent packing and that would be a further vote of confidence in Bogle.

Madine has scored a lot of goals in the Championship but unfortunately not for us as yet! However he’s been involved with two promotions to the Premier League in the last two years whereas Bogle hasn’t yet proved himself at this level. However he has the raw talent and could succeed if he concentrates on his on field activities rather than off field diversions!

[Bobby Dandruff]

Madine has scored a lot of goals in the Championship but unfortunately not for us as yet! However he’s been involved with two promotions to the Premier League in the last two years whereas Bogle hasn’t yet proved himself at this level. However he has the raw talent and could succeed if he concentrates on his on field activities rather than off field diversions!

I think that is being very generous to Madine! It is like saying that Ross Turnbull helped Chelsea win the Champions League....

Madine just isn’t up to it at this level and amazingly keeps being handed chances to prove himself, none of which he is capable of capitalising on.

I have only seen Bogle in fits and starts but even in that time he has looked more menacing than anything that I have ever seen Madine do.

[Taunton Blue Genie]

Is Madine the most expensive striker that City has ever signed but who has never scored for us?

[Pedro de la Rosa]

Is Madine the most expensive striker that City has ever signed but who has never scored for us?

A certain Danish striker holds that record!

Re Madine, he's not suited to our style of play at all. He's a decent player but he's so isolated most of the time and we don't get any bodies around him. Bogle is a much better player for us and he really impressed me on Saturday. I'd much rather we kept Bogle as back up to Glatzel and signed a centre mid and a centre half.

[Pug]

The fact that supporters are asking themselves to choose between Bogle and and Madine, tell me its going to be a long arse season.

[BLUETIT]

Patterson

[Former Labour leader]

Patterson

You say that but we are a better team with Patterson in it. Whether he plays full back midfield or striker.

[BLUETIT]

S

You say that but we are a better team with Patterson in it. Whether he plays full back midfield or striker.

I totally agree with you, I bet the fella would be a great keeper as well

It’s my sense of humour, the same as when people use the LFW option

[Taunton Blue Genie]

A certain Danish striker holds that record!

Re Madine, he's not suited to our style of play at all. He's a decent player but he's so isolated most of the time and we don't get any bodies around him. Bogle is a much better player for us and he really impressed me on Saturday. I'd much rather we kept Bogle as back up to Glatzel and signed a centre mid and a centre half.

I had forgotten that he hadn't scored - and having just looked up his stats it seems that he only played 8 times for City. Shocking considering the price.

[Taunton Blue Genie]

The fact that supporters are asking themselves to choose between Bogle and and Madine, tell me its going to be a long arse season.

An easier question then: would you prefer to have an arm or a leg amputated?

[DubaiDai]

The fact that supporters are asking themselves to choose between Bogle and and Madine, tell me its going to be a long arse season.

[NYCBlue]

Madine is a waste of space. Bogle scored during pre-season and on Saturday. So Bogle.

[Pedro de la Rosa]

The fact that supporters are asking themselves to choose between Bogle and and Madine, tell me its going to be a long arse season.

Good job we signed Robert Glatzel then.