Quote Originally Posted by cardiff55 View Post
Contrary to what is stated above Smithies is not the worst 'keeper we've had in years. Only 3 years ago we used 6 goalkeepers on one season - Marshall who was sold, Moore who was sold, Wilson, Amos, Murphy and McGregor. After the first two were sold Wilson wasn't good enough, Amos was not very good , then Murphy who was only ever a back up came in, then McGregor who's was good. We\ve been very fortunate to have signed Etheridge who has only missed one League game up until he got injured recently

I think Smithies is fine, he needs a bit of regular football to get back in to things and he's much better than Day. £4m vs Free.
In my view a fair and accurate summary