+ Visit Cardiff FC for Latest News, Transfer Gossip, Fixtures and Match Results
Results 1 to 10 of 10

Thread: Player ratings

  1. #1

    Player ratings

    Smithies - 7 Did what was required and his distribution was good

    Flint - 6.5 Mitrovic gave him and Morrison nightmares all night

    Morrison - 6.5 would be lower but he didn't do badly pushing forward

    Peltier - 6 Was EXTREMELY lucky not to give away a blatant pen

    Bennett - 6.5 Couple of dodgy moments but not awful

    Whyte - 6.5 Better performance

    Murphy - 6.5 We would have slaughtered him for not passing if he hadn't scored. Appalling goalkeeping though

    Ralls - 7.5 He's good at this level

    Bacuna - 7 Did well, played a few good balls and put himself about in defence

    Tomlin - 6.5 Fairly quiet but tried to spark something

    Glatzel - 6.5 Should have scored a header, certainly adds something to the team and I hope he stays in

  2. #2

    Re: Player ratings

    Regarding Peltier/Mitrovic penalty shout, Mitrovic knew exactly what he was doing, he had two hands on Peltier and pulled Peltier on top of him. Never a penalty

  3. #3

    Re: Player ratings

    I don’t like .5 in ratings, think it’s a cop out

    Just round them all down and I think your ratings are accurate. Ralls was our MoM

  4. #4

    Re: Player ratings

    Quote Originally Posted by delmbox View Post
    Smithies - 7 Did what was required and his distribution was good

    Flint - 6.5 Mitrovic gave him and Morrison nightmares all night

    Morrison - 6.5 would be lower but he didn't do badly pushing forward

    Peltier - 6 Was EXTREMELY lucky not to give away a blatant pen

    Bennett - 6.5 Couple of dodgy moments but not awful

    Whyte - 6.5 Better performance

    Murphy - 6.5 We would have slaughtered him for not passing if he hadn't scored. Appalling goalkeeping though

    Ralls - 7.5 He's good at this level

    Bacuna - 7 Did well, played a few good balls and put himself about in defence

    Tomlin - 6.5 Fairly quiet but tried to spark something

    Glatzel - 6.5 Should have scored a header, certainly adds something to the team and I hope he stays in
    I thought our defence was lucky to concede only one goal.
    Despite being the captain, Morrison is a liability.
    Slow, clumsy on the ball and looks liable to giving a penalty away almost every time he challenges.
    Him and Flint are a mirror image with Peltier and Bennet not far behind.
    After chasing for possession for 5-6 minutes we seemingly cannot hold onto the ball for more than 2 minutes.
    Without the Arter dismissal I am convinced we would have lost.

  5. #5

    Re: Player ratings

    Sorry, when I said 2 minutes it should have been 10 seconds

  6. #6

    Re: Player ratings

    Quote Originally Posted by Don Corleone View Post
    I don’t like .5 in ratings, think it’s a cop out

    Just round them all down and I think your ratings are accurate. Ralls was our MoM
    I was aware of that the entire time I was writing it, I was willing myself to grow a pair but couldn't

  7. #7

    Re: Player ratings

    Quote Originally Posted by delmbox View Post
    Smithies - 7 Did what was required and his distribution was good

    Flint - 6.5 Mitrovic gave him and Morrison nightmares all night

    Morrison - 6.5 would be lower but he didn't do badly pushing forward

    Peltier - 6 Was EXTREMELY lucky not to give away a blatant pen

    Bennett - 6.5 Couple of dodgy moments but not awful

    Whyte - 6.5 Better performance

    Murphy - 6.5 We would have slaughtered him for not passing if he hadn't scored. Appalling goalkeeping though

    Ralls - 7.5 He's good at this level

    Bacuna - 7 Did well, played a few good balls and put himself about in defence

    Tomlin - 6.5 Fairly quiet but tried to spark something

    Glatzel - 6.5 Should have scored a header, certainly adds something to the team and I hope he stays in
    Flint 5, Morrison 5, Whyte 7, Ralls 8, Bacuna 8, Murphy 5. All the others can stay the same.

  8. #8

    Re: Player ratings

    Quote Originally Posted by Mr Shhh View Post
    Flint 5, Morrison 5, Whyte 7, Ralls 8, Bacuna 8, Murphy 5. All the others can stay the same.
    Flint didnt do much wrong win the ball and created the goal. 5 is very harsh.

  9. #9

    Re: Player ratings

    Quote Originally Posted by Hilts View Post
    Flint didnt do much wrong win the ball and created the goal. 5 is very harsh.
    Ok 5.5. 😂 it is harsh because he was better than Morrison. So 6.

  10. #10

    Re: Player ratings

    Ralls was our best player again. At the moment he looks like the only player that a top flight club might come in for in January.

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •