Players you rated but seemed to divide opinion?

[Don Corleone]

Whittingham was one of the best Cardiff players I have seen in 50 years of supporting City - that season where he scored 20 plus goals playing wide midfield included some incredible efforts. I think he was mostly very appreciated in his time here, it was for 10 years so there were bound to be some dips over that period of time

Chris Pike is a good shout, he seemed to contribute very little to a game but somehow scored a lot of goals!

[Zowhore]

Andy Keogh, didn’t score a lot but I appreciated his constant running and didn’t think he did too bad here.