Click here for Cardiff City personalised gift shop
Results 1 to 26 of 26

Thread: Your starting line up

  1. #1

    Your starting line up

    Interested to see how many different players we would have if say 10 people all put their starting line up together. My issue with Warnock is that we didnt strengthen we just bulked up the squad. Saying thay i do think the squad is under achieving and should be capable of reaching the play offs.
    (To confirm if all players are available the game is v another championship team at random)
    Gk smithies
    Rb peltier
    Lb Bennett
    Cb bamba
    Cb morrison
    Cm ralls
    Cm bacuna
    Cm tomlin
    Rf mendez laing
    Cf paterson
    Lf hoilett

  2. #2

    Re: Your starting line up

    Today's team with NML for Whyte and Ralls for Bacuna.

    I'd like it to look something like this however at the end of the window. We can't buy a new squad but 3 new faces would be lovely.
    New Striker
    Hoilett Tomlin New Winger
    Ralls New CM
    Bennett Nelson Morrison Pelts
    Smithies

  3. #3

    Re: Your starting line up

    Gk smithies
    Rb Richards
    Lb Bennett
    Cb bamba
    Cb morrison
    Cm ralls
    Cm Pack
    Cm tomlin
    Rf Whyte
    Cf Glatzel
    Lf Murphy

  4. #4

    Re: Your starting line up

    Smithies

    Peltier
    Nelson
    Morrison
    Bennett

    Pack
    Ralls
    Tomlin

    Hoilett
    Paterson
    Whyte

  5. #5

    Re: Your starting line up

    Smithies

    Peltier
    Nelson
    Morrison
    Bennett

    Bacuna
    Ralls
    Tomlin

    Hoilett
    Glatzel
    Whyte

  6. #6

    Re: Your starting line up

    I'm struggling with the wide players. Mendez-Laing and Murphy have pace but no end product, Whyte runs around a lot but does little else and Hoilett seems to have lost interest since Warnock left. I'd be tempted to stick Paterson out wide on the right.

  7. #7

    Re: Your starting line up

    Smithies

    Peltier
    Morrison
    Nelson
    Bennett

    Pack
    Ralls

    Mendez-Laing
    Tomlin
    Murphy

    Glatzel

  8. #8

    Re: Your starting line up

    Smithies

    Richards
    Morrison
    Nelson
    Bennett

    Bacuna
    Ralls

    Murphy
    Tomlin
    Hoilett

    Paterson

  9. #9
    International jon1959's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2007
    Location
    Sheffield - out of Roath
    Posts
    9,244

    Re: Your starting line up

    Etheridge

    Richards
    Morrison
    Nelson
    Bennett

    Ralls
    Bacuna

    Mendez-Laing
    Tomlin
    Hoilett

    Glatzel

  10. #10

    Re: Your starting line up

    Etheridge
    Peltier
    Morrison
    Nelson
    Bennett
    Hoillett
    Ralls
    Pack
    Tomlin
    Murphy
    Patterson

  11. #11

    Re: Your starting line up

    Smithies

    Coxe
    Morrison
    Nelson
    Bennett

    Bacuna
    Pack
    Tomlin
    Ralls

    Whyte
    Glatzel

  12. #12

    Re: Your starting line up

    Quote Originally Posted by Seabird View Post
    Smithies

    Coxe
    Morrison
    Nelson
    Bennett

    Bacuna
    Pack
    Tomlin
    Ralls

    Whyte
    Glatzel
    relegation

  13. #13

    Re: Your starting line up

    Why?

  14. #14

    Re: Your starting line up

    Quote Originally Posted by Seabird View Post
    Why?
    Whyte up front, Coxe at right back, Ralls and Bacuna on the wing

  15. #15

    Re: Your starting line up

    I thought that was the defence we have been crying out for for a long time and good to see that defence keep a clean sheet. The worrying part is that it took Harris so long to see it. Hopefully we have seen the last of Aiden Flint as a starter in this side.

  16. #16

    Re: Your starting line up

    Smithies

    Peltier
    Morrisson
    Nelson
    Bennett

    Pack
    Ralls
    Tomlin

    Whyte
    Hoilett (Murphy if he could be arsed)

    Patersson

  17. #17

    Re: Your starting line up

    Quote Originally Posted by SunderlandBluebird View Post
    I thought that was the defence we have been crying out for for a long time and good to see that defence keep a clean sheet. The worrying part is that it took Harris so long to see it. Hopefully we have seen the last of Aiden Flint as a starter in this side.
    I am sure Harris could see the problem in defence from day 1. His problem was that he came to us with a less than impressive CV so had to bide his time before he got the team he wanted, with the existing players. The 6-1 hammering at QPR gave him all the ammunition he needed. I think we are in for a few shock comings and goings I the next 2 windows.

  18. #18

    Re: Your starting line up

    Quote Originally Posted by Croesy Blue View Post
    Smithies

    Peltier
    Morrisson
    Nelson
    Bennett

    Pack
    Ralls
    Tomlin

    Whyte
    Hoilett (Murphy if he could be arsed)

    Patersson
    The defence, after Sunday picks itself. We need pace in midfield and I just dont think we can have both Pack and Tomlin in there. Up front Whyte runs around like a headless chicken. I would pick Murphy over him.
    Smithies
    Pelts
    Morrie
    Nelson
    Bennett
    Ralls
    Bacuna
    Tomlin
    Paterson
    Glazo
    Hoilett

  19. #19

    Re: Your starting line up

    I like whyte, Murphy is a better player when he can be arsed which he never is.

  20. #20

    Re: Your starting line up

    Answer to Llandaff Blue: Don't think wingers, think diamond. I thought Coxe and Whyte combined well against Carlisle and as both are relatively young (for us that is) the combination could improve. Bye the way I haven't seen your line-up yet.

  21. #21

    Re: Your starting line up

    I don't really care about what happens for the rest of this season. I'd like to see a team where Paterson, Flint, Medez-Laing, Peltier, and Bennett are no longer factors.

  22. #22

    Re: Your starting line up

    Quote Originally Posted by NYCBlue View Post
    I don't really care about what happens for the rest of this season. I'd like to see a team where Paterson, Flint, Medez-Laing, Peltier, and Bennett are no longer factors.
    Peltied played quite well at the weekend I thought. Mendez-Liang can be brilliant one day and then shite for the next 10.

  23. #23

    Re: Your starting line up

    After watching yesterday's game it does seem that now Smithies will be first choice 'keeper, unless of course we don't sell Etheridge and sell Smithies instead! The back four from yesterday are obviously now first choice. Bamba seems well out of favour. NML and Ralls are injured but when they are fit I'd have-

    Smithies, Peltier, Morrison , Nelson, Bennett, NML, Tomlin, Bacuna, Ralls, Hoilett, Paterson. Any new players to come in and take over some of those spots.

    I wish we could unload Flint and Pack and get our money back and invest in some new players.

  24. #24

    Re: Your starting line up

    Quote Originally Posted by Croesy Blue View Post
    Peltied played quite well at the weekend I thought. Mendez-Liang can be brilliant one day and then shite for the next 10.
    Peltier has been a great servant to the club. He's far from perfect but he's the least of our concerns.

  25. #25

    Re: Your starting line up

    Quote Originally Posted by Seabird View Post
    Answer to Llandaff Blue: Don't think wingers, think diamond. I thought Coxe and Whyte combined well against Carlisle and as both are relatively young (for us that is) the combination could improve. Bye the way I haven't seen your line-up yet.
    Smithies

    Peltier Morrison Nelson Bennett

    Ralls Bacuna

    Hoilett Tomlin Murphy/Whyte
    Glatzell

    Best we've got unless any new players come in. I don't think right back is an issue right now which is why I'd rather Coxe go out on loan for the season and we keep Peltier starting, he doesn't do anything attack wise but he rarely puts a foot wrong defensively. If Peltier has a stinker then Jazz is better placed to play instead of Coxe.

    I think our midfield is too slow for a diamond, which is why I'd stick with our frustrating wingers. On his day Hoilett can be our best attacking player and Murphy showed yesterday when he's up for it he's a problem for any fullback.

  26. #26

    Re: Your starting line up

    Smithies

    Jazz
    Morrison
    Nelson
    Bennett

    Ralls
    Bacuna

    Murphy/Hoilett
    Tomlin
    Whyte

    Glatzel

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •