Where I sit on the Ninian Stand, the general consensus is that he appears to have everything - but his decision-making is non-existent. His final product falls down, because he either makes the wrong decision, or fails to make one at all. He shoots when he should pass, and vice versa. Or worse still, he can't make up his mind, and loses the ball. He doesn't appear to lack confidence - he's always willing to take on his man. It's what comes after that, that causes the problem.
However....I can't believe that this has gone un-noticed by his clubs. Don't they work on these things?