Reply With QuoteStephen McPhail
| + Visit Cardiff FC for Latest News, Transfer Gossip, Fixtures and Match Results |
Craig Conway
Paul Brayson
Kevin Evans
Craig Bryson
Jimmy Gardner
Jason Fowler
Stephen McPhail
Aron Gunnarsson
The one and only midfield duo of Willie Boland and mark Bonner
Scott Mc Cormack, was never really slagged off by City fans but i always thought that he was a better player than Chopra, which caused a bit of friction with one or two on here.Originally Posted by jon1959
In fairness, we've not really had many players that have split opinion with the fanbase. If we have then they've usually been creative and had a bit of vision, Whitts, Mc Phail etc... plenty of our lot thrive on effort and work rate and seem to think that a thirty yard defence splitting pass doesn't take plenty of effort and work rate to master......Whittingham just woke up one morning and was able to do some of the most fantastic things i've ever seen while watching the City, the rest of the week he smoked cigars and watched re-runs of Friends..
Gavin Rae
A bit like Paul Brayson. I liked Brayson, he did a very good job for us and in my opinion wasn't given the recognition that he deserved. I'd have him down as one of the fittest players i've ever seen.
Surely Kevin Evans didnt divide opinion.?? 😂😂
Paul Bodin, at the time I thought he was good and every one I spoke to thought he was crap.
Bodin played during my first season watching City, i can't say that i was that astute over the ability of players back then so couldn't really make a judgement, although he did have a good career via Bath City i believe.Paul Bodin, at the time I thought he was good and every one I spoke to thought he was crap
Ethan Ampadu!
Chris Pike. He scored 67 League goals for Cardiff yet fans picked on him because he was a big guy who was not very physical. But the same people seemed to forget that he was excellent on the floor for a big centre forward and could certainly put the ball in the net. His partnership with car Dale was good, and in 92/93 when we went up he was top League goalscorer despite playing in half the games. And we had Dale, Black, Griffiths and Stant too. He was released at the end of the season. I really liked him.
I don't think he's played enough top level football to have an opinion.
I thought he was a class midfield player.
I always found it crazy that Whitts divided opinion. At his best no one could compare and because of that I could forgive any quiet game he had.
There used to be a poster on here “Daehli’s gonna skin you”... or something like that (perhaps he’s still here under a different name) who was vicious with his anti-Whitt’s stuff.
Agreed. He was loyal as well, seemed very happy at the club. He's responsible for some of the best bits of individual skill i've ever witnessed supporting City.
I agree. But others didn't.
Was that the name he gave to the police after his drunken car escapades?
Oh yeah, It was Ross, wasn't it? I'm getting bloody terrible remembering names as i get older, i called my son Peggy the other day which is a bit of a worry as it's the dogs name!Was that the name he gave to the police after his drunken car escapades?
Whittingham was one of the best Cardiff players I have seen in 50 years of supporting City - that season where he scored 20 plus goals playing wide midfield included some incredible efforts. I think he was mostly very appreciated in his time here, it was for 10 years so there were bound to be some dips over that period of time
Chris Pike is a good shout, he seemed to contribute very little to a game but somehow scored a lot of goals!
Andy Keogh, didn’t score a lot but I appreciated his constant running and didn’t think he did too bad here.
Whitts shouldnt divide opinion. Class. His record speaks for itself. Goals assists. Did what a creative attacking was supposed to do with interest.
Yep that for me was the worse , followed by Whitt's and Gunnerson , spot the connection.
We got promoted when Mcphail was axed and Gunner and Whitts put in the middle??
Posting Permissions
