I love threads like this because you don't have to think. The correct answer is the first one that comes to mind.
1. Man City, 1994, 1-0, FA Cup.
2. 4-1 V brentford in a promotion season, late 1990s. Fowler's chip.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m9fscrz0qWQ
3. 2-1 v Leeds, 2002.
4. Chops late winner v the jacks. God knows why, I'm really not into the rivalry thing too much but that was really memorable
No premier league game comes anywhere near that lot.
on the telly: 4-1 (or 4-2?) v Fulham away, mid 1990s.