Alex Scott

[the other bob wilson]

Cant, they stick to proper pundits for Wales and England games and the semi-finals and finals and then have box-ticked pundits just for the rest?

Who would you.call a proper pundit then?

[North Cardiff Blue]

Who would you.call a proper pundit then?

The best ones.

We all have our favorites but considered top are, Neville, Shearer, Hoddle, Gabbidon, and Bellamy for Wales games, Carragher, Souness, Keane, and Richards.

All played at a good level and fully understand the game, some are controversial and add to the entertainment.

We have to bring some new ones through, use them on the other games, and when they are good enough bring them in and retire some of the old boys, just like in football, don't just pick them to tick a box.

[the other bob wilson]

The best ones.

We all have our favorites but considered top are, Neville, Shearer, Hoddle, Gabbidon, and Bellamy for Wales games, Carragher, Souness, and Keane.

All played at a good level and fully understand the game, some are controversial and add to the game.

Isn’t Gabbidon a “box ticked” pundit though?

[North Cardiff Blue]

Isn’t Gabbidon a “box ticked” pundit though?

Maybe lol, I was struggling to think of good Welsh ones.

[the other bob wilson]

Maybe lol, I was struggling to think of good Welsh ones.

I was never a fan of what I think of as positive discrimination, but I can’t believe that there are no women who can get a football pundit job on merit out there, in fact I know there are some because they’re doing the job already.

[Vindec]

The best ones.

We all have our favorites but considered top are, Neville, Shearer, Hoddle, Gabbidon, and Bellamy for Wales games, Carragher, Souness, Keane, and Richards.

All played at a good level and fully understand the game, some are controversial and add to the entertainment.

We have to bring some new ones through, use them on the other games, and when they are good enough bring them in and retire some of the old boys, just like in football, don't just pick them to tick a box.

Carragher? He should come with subtitles.

[North Cardiff Blue]

England's lineup wasn't too bad either, you saw the benefit of Keane when he was saying England underestimated the US and were messing about playing darts.

[North Cardiff Blue]

Who would you.call a proper pundit then?

Today we had a pretty good lineup on paper, Gabby Logan, Ashley Williams, Rush, replace Klinsman for Bellamy and I would have been happy.