No contest. What a stupid comparison.

Buchanan struck a dead ball well but with no finesse. He just banged it.

At least you identified Whitts as one of the best we’ve ever had.

Just off the top of my head - Kav, Nathan Blake and Dave Bennett were far better than Buchanan at every other aspect of the game other than blasting the ball - and if I thought for more than 10 seconds I could probably give a handful more (I’m actually surprised you didn’t pick an Irish player 🤣)