Gary Madine - Stop Hating Him

[jamieccfc]

No

He may not have had a fair crack at the whip but most of us can see he's not good enough for the big league Sheffield weds would be a good move for him with bannan coming here

[dml1954]

He may not have had a fair crack at the whip but most of us can see he's not good enough for the big league Sheffield weds would be a good move for him with bannan coming here

I think that you will find that people with your opinion on this matter are in the minority, so less of the 'most' please.

[jamieccfc]

I think that you will find that people with your opinion on this matter are in the minority, so less of the 'most' please.

Why don't you do a poll and see dick head!
By the way I wasn't having a go at him just stating he isn't good enough for the premier league

[life on mars]

I cannot understand anyone not giving a player a chance , just perhaps consider that :

He landed in the worse transfer window recognized as so across football
Victim of a panic buy
Inflated fee fee not his doing
Expected to replace Zohore
Had to quickly fit into a totally difference playing style.
Broke a rib early on .
Never got a chance to establish himself .
Brave enough to take a penalty most of us would have turned away from

Lets be very carefull what we wish for, he may be wanted next year ,will never be prolific but has powerful old fashioned lee fortune type of penalty area chaos / nuisance value ,whcih creates goals, space and opportunities for others , we simply dont know what we have or will need next year if Zohore goes .

Lets be loyal to everyone one or our lads even if they played 5 minutes or every game ,they all played a part



I dont think they hate him , some just like to pick on someone ,some don't get the full picture of what a player brings to the squad ,some have never kicked a ball in anger ,football is not just about silky ,clever skill ,there a need to be brutal ,nasty and a nuisance , it all knits into the fabric of the team .

[Forest Green Bluebird]

I cannot understand anyone not giving a player a chance , just perhaps consider that :

He landed in the worse transfer window recognized as so across football
Victim of a panic buy
Inflated fee fee not his doing
Expected to replace Zohore
Had to quickly fit into a totally difference playing style.
Broke a rib early on .
Never got a chance to establish himself .
Brave enough to take a penalty most of us would have turned away from

Lets be very carefull what we wish for, he may be wanted next year ,will never be prolific but has powerful old fashioned lee fortune type of penalty area chaos / nuisance value ,whcih creates goals, space and opportunities for others , we simply dont know what we have or will need next year if Zohore goes .

Lets be loyal to everyone one or our lads even if they played 5 minutes or every game ,they all played a part



I dont think they hate him , some just like to pick on someone ,some don't get the full picture of what a player brings to the squad ,some have never kicked a ball in anger ,football is not just about silky ,clever skill ,there a need to be brutal ,nasty and a nuisance , it all knits into the fabric of the team .

Wise words again Major Tom.

I hope that Madine will be given the opportunity to prove his worth to Cardiff.

I remember posters having similar opinions of players, some of whom are now club legends.

[dml1954]

Why don't you do a poll and see dick head!
By the way I wasn't having a go at him just stating he isn't good enough for the premier league

Just the kind of abusive reply that I would expect from you to be honest. You have been 'having a go' at Madine ever since City signed him. How do you know he isn't good enough for the Premier League anyway - he's never played in it, nor has Zohore, Reid, Ralls etc but dont see you continually saying they arent going to be good enough.

[jamieccfc]

Just the kind of abusive reply that I would expect from you to be honest. You have been 'having a go' at Madine ever since City signed him. How do you know he isn't good enough for the Premier League anyway - he's never played in it, nor has Zohore, Reid, Ralls etc but dont see you continually saying they arent going to be good enough.

No I haven't, see another thread where I've asked how many of our players can actually be classed as premier quality imo not many and imo madine is an average championship striker you keep mentioning his goal ratio but wasn't most of them at league 1?