View Full Version : Giggs anyone?
Assuming that he could be lured on a temporary basis to get the best out of our current squad would you go for him?
the other bob wilson
04-10-16, 07:43
Assuming that he could be lured on a temporary basis to get the best out of our current squad would you go for him?
Nope - anyone who saw the crowd reaction to his appearance as a sub for Man United three years ago must know that should be a complete non starter, so, with the way the club has been run lately, we can expect Giggs to be in place by Friday :hehe:.
Assuming that he could be lured on a temporary basis to get the best out of our current squad would you go for him?
A few weeks ago I would have said no way but right now I would take virtually anybody on a temporary basis.
We need results and quick!
life on mars
04-10-16, 07:57
Unproven .
Bruce is the boy , one of the phew Utd team successes,decent bloke as well I understand .
The longer it continues the more chance it will be an Warnock moment , love or hate him he does get results
Ring_Peace
04-10-16, 07:58
A Welsh and Manure connection...VT would love it :cheerleader:
Alfonso Perez
04-10-16, 08:01
No thank you. Bellamy would stand more of a chance but that would be a massive gamble & we are not exactly in a great position to roll the dice.
We need a very quick upturn in fortunes so someone like Warnock as a short term solution for this season only would be a good choice in my mind.
EastbourneBlue
04-10-16, 08:18
Assuming that he could be lured on a temporary basis to get the best out of our current squad would you go for him?
While accepting it'd be a risk, I'd take Giggs.
Has managed the biggest club in the world with some success, has played at the very top, surely would command some respect.
Would bring in some great coaches and fitness people - an area I believe we're struggling big time.
Chance of some Man Utd loanees.
He's from Cardiff.
Nice beard.
While accepting it'd be a risk, I'd take Giggs.
Has managed the biggest club in the world with some success, has played at the very top, surely would command some respect.
Would bring in some great coaches and fitness people - an area I believe we're struggling big time.
Chance of some Man Utd loanees.
He's from Cardiff.
Nice beard.
The same could mostly be said of OGS and that was a complete disaster. The only type of person to save us from decline is a manager with a proven track record and the realistic front runner must be Warnock.
EastbourneBlue
04-10-16, 08:24
The same could mostly be said of OGS and that was a complete disaster. The only type of person to save us from decline is a manager with a proven track record and the realistic front runner must be Warnock.
I'd rather Warnock than Giggs.
But the only similarity between OGS and Giggs is that they both played at Utd.
I'd rather Warnock than Giggs.
But the only similarity between OGS and Giggs is that they both played at Utd.
You omitted these two similarities:
Would bring in some great coaches and fitness people - an area I believe we're struggling big time.
Chance of some Man Utd loanees.
Also OGS had mangerial experience unlike Giggs who had a handful of games at the end of a season. The similarities are greater than you think.
While accepting it'd be a risk, I'd take Giggs.
Has managed the biggest club in the world with some success, has played at the very top, surely would command some respect.
Would bring in some great coaches and fitness people - an area I believe we're struggling big time.
Chance of some Man Utd loanees.
He's from Cardiff.
Nice beard.
not sure about the beard, to be honest i like my faces without hair, but hey ho
the rest is about right though
yes i can see people saying " but we tried that with OLE "
I can't see any ex Man U players coming here while Tan's in charge after what happened with Ole.
We need Colin or Bruce but would either come here is the problem
Harry Monk
04-10-16, 10:19
While accepting it'd be a risk, I'd take Giggs.
Has managed the biggest club in the world with some success, has played at the very top, surely would command some respect.
Would bring in some great coaches and fitness people - an area I believe we're struggling big time.
Chance of some Man Utd loanees.
He's from Cardiff.
Nice beard.
Begs the question, Why hasn't he been given the job on a permanent basis?
Llanedeyrnblue
04-10-16, 10:22
In this situation I'd have Warnock any day he's an irritating knob when he's not your manager, he'd be different if he was ours. He'd keep us up for sure:thumbup:
Mr Soul '68
04-10-16, 10:35
Assuming that he could be lured on a temporary basis to get the best out of our current squad would you go for him?
NO! He would be Ole part II, but without the money to spend!
I honestly don't think our beloved Emperor will end up sacking Trollope. I don't think he gives a flying one about where we end up this season
Assuming that he could be lured on a temporary basis to get the best out of our current squad would you go for him?
But based on what - hope and taking a risk?
If we are to have a change, we need better than hope and taking a risk at this time.
valley boy
04-10-16, 11:01
No for me re Giggs we need a manager who knows this league.Ray Wilkins on talk sport said Swansea fans would be hanging off the rafters to get Giggs shows how little he knows on how welsh fans think of a man who never turned up for Wales when we really needed him.
life on mars
04-10-16, 11:20
You omitted these two similarities:
Would bring in some great coaches and fitness people - an area I believe we're struggling big time.
Chance of some Man Utd loanees.
Also OGS had mangerial experience unlike Giggs who had a handful of games at the end of a season. The similarities are greater than you think.
I would say Giggs maybe more respected, he could bring a Fergie approach, he has real fitness experiences to share ,which enabled him to prolong his outfield career ,surpassing most players .
The down side :
The Championship is unforgiving ,very unlike the Premiership
Players he may bring would be at a hefty wage scale
Why was he overlooked at Utd ??
Why has anyone expressed an interest ie Villa , Swansea or Hull
He comes across as not the brightest, might be okay in the dressing room, he''s no Neville, when interviewed, if you know what I mean.
His Cardiff connection is well over blown , he was in Salford with his mum as a very young boy and that's where is heart and soul is.
In conclusion I think he would be a risk and the Welsh job is his best punt.
Let go and get Coleman ?
Let go and get Coleman ?[/QUOTE]
Uh No!!
(Unless hes bringing Ramsey, Bale, Williams and Allen with him)
He's somehow fits into his current job through a series of coincidences that fortunately for us have brought the best out of Wales and long may it continue. Away from the Wales job I extremely doubt his managerial skills as he appears to me to be a bit twp - sorry I know its not fashionable but thats how he appears to me
Not knocking in any shape or form what he's achieved through Wales mind
Wales-Bales
04-10-16, 12:14
As long as I'm given a weeks notice to move my wife and daughter out of Cardiff :thumbup:
NO! He would be Ole part II, but without the money to spend!
I honestly don't think our beloved Emperor will end up sacking Trollope. I don't think he gives a flying one about where we end up this season
Don't buy a lottery ticket this week!
:biggrin:
No for me re Giggs we need a manager who knows this league.Ray Wilkins on talk sport said Swansea fans would be hanging off the rafters to get Giggs shows how little he knows on how welsh fans think of a man who never turned up for Wales when we really needed him.
Looks like they're hanging from the rafters after they got Bob!
:hehe:
:ayatollah:
Dénia Bluebird
04-10-16, 13:29
I see no reason why Giggs would be any different to Ole, he too would stuff us with has been reds on huge contracts with the added negative that Giggs doesnt even have Ole's experience?
Giggs this, Bellers that - c'mon folks, what have they achieved in Management yet?!
Good luck to them, but please - not here , not now.
Somebody with bit of *provable* experience, grit guile and dependability is what we need.
Powered by vBulletin® Version 4.2.3 Copyright © 2024 vBulletin Solutions, Inc. All rights reserved.