David Marshall

[Hilts]

Should we bring him back?

We need a 2nd keeper. Surely he cant have gone downhill all that much.

[light up the darkness]

No. Past his best
Don’t go back

[BlueToujours]

Will be No. 1 at Hull following McGregor's departure.

[life on mars]

Not for me stays on his line too much and this awareness in the air was suspect.

This lad Paul Woolston who we have on trial may be a better,cheaper
option, played for England at U17/18 and part of the Newcastle first team squad .

[Father Dougal]

No way. His distribution is awful and that’s important for us.

Can’t believe the fuss about him before. I’d take Etheridge over him no question at all.

[Father Dougal]

Plus he doesn’t score enough goals

[The Bob Banker Spanker]

Etheridge got so much better as the season went on. I'd say he was the best keeper in the league at the end of the season.

[WJ99mobile]

Never go back for a former player

[Armitage Shanks]

Never go back for a former player

unless its Gareth Bale

[life on mars]

Never go back for a former player

Aaron?

[Welshcake.]

What a gem we found in Etheridge. I would opt for some promising younger players to learn with/from him.

[theclaw]

Be a great back up

[Spooky Tree]

He's a great shot stopper but that's goalkeeping basics. He's shit at everything else.

[Blue in the Face]

Why does Marshy have to be shit all of a sudden? We wouldn't have gotten a sniff of promotion without him. Former player of the season. Loyal player. I'm not saying we should try and sign him, but why the need to criticise? He's a club legend for me.

[Blue blood]

Why does Marshy have to be shit all of a sudden? We wouldn't have gotten a sniff of promotion without him. Former player of the season. Loyal player. I'm not saying we should try and sign him, but why the need to criticise? He's a club legend for me.

Agree with this and he was excellent in our PL season.

However, I also agree with the general consensus that we shouldn't get him back, aside from which can't see him coming to be a back up keeper.

[The Bloop]

He stood out in our premier league season because he was a great shot stopper. One huge reason for that was the vast number of shots against us. Does he command the box as well as Etheridge? No where near as good.
Etheridge for me every time.

[Taffy Blue in Berkshire]

Plus he doesn’t score enough goals

Nor does b1oody Madine!

[life on mars]

What a gem we found in Etheridge. I would opt for some promising younger players to learn with/from him.

got him

Paul Woolston who we have on trial may be a better,cheaper
option, played for England at U17/18 and part of the Newcastle first team squad .

[life on mars]

Nor does b1oody Madine!

bookmark this , for when he's leading the line for ingerland next year

[William Treseder]

We would have ended up with less premiership points than Derby if it wasn’t for Marshall that season.
Wouldn’t re sign him now, but come on guys, a bit of respect.

[jamieccfc]

I'd stick with Murphy tbh

[Sloop_Jon_Bee]

No way. His distribution is awful and that’s important for us.

Can’t believe the fuss about him before. I’d take Etheridge over him no question at all.

Agree. :thumbup: