All time Cardiff City Championship 11?

[Forgotmyoldaccount]

Who would be your 11 starters of all the players we've had during our championship tenure? Can do a bench too.

------------------Marshall--------------

--Matthews---Bamba----Morrison---Gabbidon----


-----Whittingham--Kavanagh---Koumas----

-----------------Ramsay------------------
----------------- -----Bellamy-------------
---------------Earnshaw--------------------


Bench: O'Neil, Alexander, Bothroyd, Chopra, Ledley, Hudson, Thorne, McCormack

[Armitage Shanks]

would have Hoillett over Ledley on the bench, and maybe Etheridge over Marshall

[NYCBlue]

Chopra has to start. He was a Championship goal machine.

[jon1959]

I can think of half a dozen right backs I'd have in the side before Adam Matthews.

[Lord Worcester]

Kev at right back. Chops has to play. Kav wouldn't be in my starting 11. Shift Ramsay back into that 3 man midfield. Probably roger Johnson over Morrison in back 4, Morrison on bench ahead of Hudson. Mcphail and kav replace Thorne and O'Neill on bench. Great debate!

[The Bob Banker Spanker]

Marshall

McNaughton Hudson Morrison Bennett

Burke Mcphail Koumas Scimeca Hoilett

Bothroyd

Heaton
Bamba
Ralls
McCormack
Chopra
Routledge
Mutch

[Eric the Half a Bee]

Chopra has to start. He was a Championship goal machine.

Earnshaw scored more at that level for us in a single season than Chopra.

[Philbccfc]

whats that, coming over the hill, everytime.

[blue matt]

Chops would have to be in the team, Rambo aswell, Blakey on a good day was a game winner

[Barry Shitpeas]

...............Marshall
Gunter Bamba Gabbidon Kev
McCormack Ramsey Koumas
.............Bellamy
........Earnshaw Chopra

Heaton
Morrison
Johnson
McPhail
Whittingham
Hoilett
Bothroyd

[Croesy Blue]

Etheridge

McNaughton
Johnson
Bamba
Bennett

Routledge
Koumas
Scimeca
Ramsey
Bellamy

Bothroyd

[Forgotmyoldaccount]

Scimeca was a beast

[Forgotmyoldaccount]

Marshall

McNaughton Hudson Morrison Bennett

Burke Mcphail Koumas Scimeca Hoilett

Bothroyd

Heaton
Bamba
Ralls
McCormack
Chopra
Routledge
Mutch

Nice team but missing elite talent like a Rambo or Bellamy

[Sparticus_Mills]

Really was a tough ask, left back was tough, as was central midfield. https://www.buildlineup.com/shared/5afc045f138c092e24ab48b5

[Baker]

Marshall

McNaughton Hudson Morrison Bennett

Burke Mcphail Koumas Scimeca Hoilett

Bothroyd

Heaton
Bamba
Ralls
McCormack
Chopra
Routledge
Mutch

Lol no whittingham

[cardiff55]

I'd have to go for Marshall, McNaughton, Johnson, Gabbidon, Bennett (we have struggled with left backs for years!), Whittingham, Ledley, Hoilett, Koumas, Bothroyd, Chopra. Subs: Etheridge, Morrison, Earnshaw, Ralls, Bellamy, Parry, Connolly.

My alternative squad: Turnbull, Commingues, Tamas, Page, Naylor, Maxwell, Koskela, Boulding, Mulryne, Ferretti, N'Dumbu N'Sungu, Feeney, Flood, Glombard, Fowler, Enckelmann, Taiwo, Parkin, Kiss, Velikonja, Lappin, Maynard, Odemwingie, Eikram, Berget, Cala, Dikgacoi, Revell, Saadi, Macheda, !!! That lot would tear up the National League South......possibly.

[City123]

Marshall

McNaughton Hudson Morrison Bennett

Whittingham Ledley Koumas

Chopra Earnshaw Bothroyd

SUBS: Etheridge, Bamba, Matthews, Hoilett, McPhail, Bellamy, McCormack

[Louth]

A good number of you haven't got Whittingham in the team.

Are you pissed?

[Barry Shitpeas]

A good number of you haven't got Whittingham in the team.

Are you pissed?

To be fair it shows what good players we’ve had. The likes of Loovens, Hasselbaink, Mark Kennedy, Sinclair, Routledge, O’Neil, Rae, Thompson, Turner, Mason etc haven’t been mentioned.

[BLUETIT]

Alright, I know he never played for us in the Championship, but he got us there, so I gotta say Andy Legg at full back.

[delmbox]

Alright, I know he never played for us in the Championship, but he got us there, so I gotta say Andy Legg at full back.

Never played for us in the Championship

[The Bob Banker Spanker]

Lol no whittingham

lol I 4gt bout witnum n ramze

[BLUETIT]

Alright, I KNOW HE NEVER PLAYED FOR US IN THE CHAMPIONSHIP, but he got us there, so I gotta say Andy Legg at full back.


Never played for us in the Championship


Which part of this do you not understand :hehe::hehe:

[delmbox]

Which part of this do you not understand :hehe::hehe:

He never played for us in the Championship though so you can't have him in the team

[Baker]

He never played for us in the Championship though so you can't have him in the team
How can you be so inconsiderate delm

[Croesy Blue]

Which part of this do you not understand :hehe::hehe:

Which part of all time championship 11 do you not understand?

[lardy]

Giggs never played for us in the championship but his quality was there for all to see, so I'd have to put him in.

[Toadstool]

Giggs wouldn’t have turned up

[light up the darkness]

Kev at right back. Chops has to play. Kav wouldn't be in my starting 11. Shift Ramsay back into that 3 man midfield. Probably roger Johnson over Morrison in back 4, Morrison on bench ahead of Hudson. Mcphail and kav replace Thorne and O'Neill on bench. Great debate!


It’s wonderful what’s a misplaced letter can achieve

“...Probably roger Johnson over Morrison in back 4””


It’s not my preferred style but I see where your coming from😬

[Forgotmyoldaccount]

So sad that in 5 years since this thread, not a single player would enter this team.

[Rjk]

Who would be your 11 starters of all the players we've had during our championship tenure? Can do a bench too.

------------------Marshall--------------

--Matthews---Bamba----Morrison---Gabbidon----


-----Whittingham--Kavanagh---Koumas----

-----------------Ramsay------------------
----------------- -----Bellamy-------------
---------------Earnshaw--------------------


Bench: O'Neil, Alexander, Bothroyd, Chopra, Ledley, Hudson, Thorne, McCormack
Matthews?
is there another Matthews I can't remember

[Hilts]

Adam Matthews I presume.

[J R Hartley]

Only read the first post.

No Bothroyd? LOL

[J R Hartley]

Alright, I know he never played for us in the Championship, but he got us there, so I gotta say Andy Legg at full back.

Even Leggy wouldn’t expect to get in a team based on the championship. He knew his level.

[dembethewarrior]

Who would be your 11 starters of all the players we've had during our championship tenure? Can do a bench too.

------------------Marshall--------------

--Matthews---Bamba----Morrison---Gabbidon----


-----Whittingham--Kavanagh---Koumas----

-----------------Ramsay------------------
----------------- -----Bellamy-------------
---------------Earnshaw--------------------


Bench: O'Neil, Alexander, Bothroyd, Chopra, Ledley, Hudson, Thorne, McCormack

I wouldn't have Gabbidon at LB or Whitts at RCM

or play a 43111