YOUR TOP 5 SPORTSMEN OR WOMEN OF ALL TIME

Printable View

Show 40 post(s) from this thread on one page

06-10-20, 16:52
Jordi Culé

Re: YOUR TOP 5 SPORTSMEN OR WOMEN OF ALL TIME

George Best
Muhammed Ali
John McEnroe
Daley Thompson
Anna Kournikova
06-10-20, 16:55
Hilts

Re: YOUR TOP 5 SPORTSMEN OR WOMEN OF ALL TIME

For cricket if it was best of all time then Don Bradman tops the best batsman and Shane Warne as a bowler. I could never have 2 convicts in my 5 though.
06-10-20, 16:55
the other bob wilson

Re: YOUR TOP 5 SPORTSMEN OR WOMEN OF ALL TIME

Ali.
C B Fry
Daley Thompson
Martina Navratilova
Tiger Woods

It's an impossible question really. I tried to be as dispassionate as possible rather than just go for favourites - I'd only call one of them a favourite of mine and there's one there I don't like much at all.
06-10-20, 16:56
elytillidie

Re: YOUR TOP 5 SPORTSMEN OR WOMEN OF ALL TIME

Muhammed Ali by a country mile. Boxing and his Vietnam stance.
George Best, despite the flaws.
Ian Woosnam, 5' 4", world number one for ages.
Sebastian Coe, despite being a Tory, when he accelerated off the final bend...
Jesse Owens, take that Adolf.
06-10-20, 16:59
SLUDGE FACTORY

Re: YOUR TOP 5 SPORTSMEN OR WOMEN OF ALL TIME

Willie Boland

Kelly Sotherton
06-10-20, 17:00
SLUDGE FACTORY

Re: YOUR TOP 5 SPORTSMEN OR WOMEN OF ALL TIME

Quote:

Originally Posted by elytillidie

Muhammed Ali by a country mile. Boxing and his Vietnam stance.
George Best, despite the flaws.
Ian Woosnam, 5' 4", world number one for ages.
Sebastian Coe, despite being a Tory, when he accelerated off the final bend...
Jesse Owens, take that Adolf.

ali was a great man , up there with the best
06-10-20, 17:03
Moodybluebird

Re: YOUR TOP 5 SPORTSMEN OR WOMEN OF ALL TIME

Quote:

Originally Posted by the other bob wilson

Ali.
C B Fry
Daley Thompson
Martina Navratilova
Tiger Woods

It's an impossible question really. I tried to be as dispassionate as possible rather than just go for favourites - I'd only call one of them a favourite of mine and there's one there I don't like much at all.

Bob as I said earlier, it should be your personal favourites, not the best in any given sport. Even if they were second raters or perennial runners-up it doesn't matter. As long as you had an affinity with them is all that counts.
06-10-20, 17:07
Moodybluebird

Re: YOUR TOP 5 SPORTSMEN OR WOMEN OF ALL TIME

Quote:

Originally Posted by SLUDGE FACTORY

ali was a great man , up there with the best

That is quite amusing Sludge because when I gave an honourable mention to Seb Coe in my original post, I thought I know somebody who's going to kick my a**e for naming a Tory. Never in a million years did I think he would pop up in your list lol
06-10-20, 17:21
splott parker

Re: YOUR TOP 5 SPORTSMEN OR WOMEN OF ALL TIME

Ali
Jesse Owens
CB Fry
Messi
Hughie Ferguson

Fictional... William Wilson by a mile
06-10-20, 17:25
life on mars

Re: YOUR TOP 5 SPORTSMEN OR WOMEN OF ALL TIME

Bugger I forgot Roy of the Rovers
06-10-20, 17:26
Moodybluebird

Re: YOUR TOP 5 SPORTSMEN OR WOMEN OF ALL TIME

Quote:

Originally Posted by Moodybluebird

That is quite amusing Sludge because when I gave an honourable mention to Seb Coe in my original post, I thought I know somebody who's going to kick my a**e for naming a Tory. Never in a million years did I think he would pop up in your list lol

My bad, Coe appeared on Elytillidie's list not Sludge's. Thought that would never happen !
06-10-20, 17:26
tforturton

Re: YOUR TOP 5 SPORTSMEN OR WOMEN OF ALL TIME

I guess a lot of this depends on your age. Muhammed Ali and Pele will be on most older people's lists, but younger folks will choose Messi or Tyson, perhaps. Ali has to be the greatest boxer. Footballer? Well, take your choice from a long list. Gareth Edwards is considered by many (older) people to be the greatest ever rugby player, but young people will close Lomu, or someone similar. It's all subjective. But Chris Pike has got to be in there somewhere.
06-10-20, 17:29
splott parker

Re: YOUR TOP 5 SPORTSMEN OR WOMEN OF ALL TIME

Quote:

Originally Posted by life on mars

Bugger I forgot Roy of the Rovers

Nothing without Blackie Gray and Arnold Tabbs pulling the strings behind him!
06-10-20, 17:32
BLUETIT

Re: YOUR TOP 5 SPORTSMEN OR WOMEN OF ALL TIME

Quote:

Originally Posted by splott parker

Nothing without Blackie Gray and Arnold Tabbs pulling the strings behind him!

Where's Limp Along Leslie ????
06-10-20, 17:47
the other bob wilson

Re: YOUR TOP 5 SPORTSMEN OR WOMEN OF ALL TIME

If we're talking fictional, what about Alf Tupper who won fifty gold medals on a diet of fish and chips? Robert Redford was pretty good in The Natural as well.
06-10-20, 18:16
Pontprennau Bluebird

Re: YOUR TOP 5 SPORTSMEN OR WOMEN OF ALL TIME

George Best
Pele
Les Kellert
Nathan Blake
Ali

Geoff Boycott on the bench.
06-10-20, 18:21
Its been emotional

Re: YOUR TOP 5 SPORTSMEN OR WOMEN OF ALL TIME

Ronnie
Diego
Tyson
Bolt
Lomu
06-10-20, 18:28
The Bloop

Re: YOUR TOP 5 SPORTSMEN OR WOMEN OF ALL TIME

Kim Jong-un x5

Hasn't he gone round St Andrew's in 58, run 100m in 8.9secs, got an 8-darter for 501, won the British F1 driving backwards and was the only boxer to beat Calzaghe?
06-10-20, 18:31
Moodybluebird

Re: YOUR TOP 5 SPORTSMEN OR WOMEN OF ALL TIME

What sticks out like a sore thumb is the scarcity of women on the list. Possibly because to men they don't achieve hero status in a way that Ali, Bolt, Owens etc have. Certainly we admire the achievements of people like Navratilova, Jess Ennis, Serena Williams etc but not enough for us to include them on our all-time favourites list it seems.
06-10-20, 18:35
splott parker

Re: YOUR TOP 5 SPORTSMEN OR WOMEN OF ALL TIME

Quote:

Originally Posted by the other bob wilson

If we're talking fictional, what about Alf Tupper who won fifty gold medals on a diet of fish and chips? Robert Redford was pretty good in The Natural as well.

William Wilson starred in about five different eras, when I was religiously following his exploits in the 60s he was about 120 years old then. Tupper got to meetings on his motorbike and sidebath after a day’s welding, Wilson ran a couple of hundred miles to get to a venue without eating, the man was and still is a marvel, Alf is no doubt long retired.
06-10-20, 18:37
splott parker

Re: YOUR TOP 5 SPORTSMEN OR WOMEN OF ALL TIME

Quote:

Originally Posted by Moodybluebird

What sticks out like a sore thumb is the scarcity of women on the list. Possibly because to men they don't achieve hero status in a way that Ali, Bolt, Owens etc have. Certainly we admire the achievements of people like Navratilova, Jess Ennis, Serena Williams etc but not enough for us to include them on our all-time favourites list it seems.

Linda Lovelace deserves a mention although she blew many an opportunity.
06-10-20, 18:39
SLUDGE FACTORY

Re: YOUR TOP 5 SPORTSMEN OR WOMEN OF ALL TIME

Quote:

Originally Posted by Moodybluebird

My bad, Coe appeared on Elytillidie's list not Sludge's. Thought that would never happen !

Botham was a fantastic cricketer , one of the greatest players of all time up there with sobers , Kapil dev , Hadlee , via Richards etc

But since he's retired he's become a right old little englander , very right wing

Horrible

Coe was world class
06-10-20, 18:40
SLUDGE FACTORY

Re: YOUR TOP 5 SPORTSMEN OR WOMEN OF ALL TIME

Quote:

Originally Posted by splott parker

Linda Lovelace deserves a mention although she blew many an opportunity.

always went down too easily
06-10-20, 18:41
Rjk

Re: YOUR TOP 5 SPORTSMEN OR WOMEN OF ALL TIME

Quote:

Originally Posted by SLUDGE FACTORY

Willie Boland

Kelly Sotherton

ana Ivanovic
06-10-20, 18:51
The Bloop

Re: YOUR TOP 5 SPORTSMEN OR WOMEN OF ALL TIME

Quote:

Originally Posted by SLUDGE FACTORY

Botham was a fantastic cricketer , one of the greatest players of all time up there with sobers , Kapil dev , Hadlee , via Richards etc

But since he's retired he's become a right old little englander , very right wing

Horrible

Coe was world class

Is that ex-Tory MP, Baron, Lord ,KBE, Life Peer Sebastian Newbold Coe?
Didnt think he was your type?

Show 40 post(s) from this thread on one page