-
Re: CARDIFF CITY v Q.P.R. Match thread
Quote:
Originally Posted by
2b2bdoo
I think it’s the right line up.
Could make a case for Harris but when I see him he seems to do best off the bench.
I hope the back 5 can do well , I think on form they are the best options
Flint is the best defender we have probably
Nelson is a liability. If it wasn't for the fact we had Morrison and Flint also, we would be looking for a replacement
-
Re: CARDIFF CITY v Q.P.R. Match thread
I still think five at the back at home is too cautious.
-
Re: CARDIFF CITY v Q.P.R. Match thread
I think its 3 at the back, same as Saturday
-
Re: CARDIFF CITY v Q.P.R. Match thread
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Parti Mellow
I still think five at the back at home is too cautious.
It's a back 3
-
Re: CARDIFF CITY v Q.P.R. Match thread
Three centre backs then, still too cautious.
-
Re: CARDIFF CITY v Q.P.R. Match thread
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Parti Mellow
I still think five at the back at home is too cautious.
Doesn't that depend on whether the wing backs attack and provide the width and crosses.
If they sit back like a pair of centre backs playing out of position it is definitely too cautious. Ng and Giles should do OK.
I'm less confident about central defence and central midfield. Mozzer, Nelson and Vaulks need big games.
Great to see Zimba on the bench, and Ralls back.
-
Re: CARDIFF CITY v Q.P.R. Match thread
Would have started Flint and Harris, but that's ok.
-
Re: CARDIFF CITY v Q.P.R. Match thread
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Parti Mellow
Three centre backs then, still too cautious.
Not really. It allows Giles and NG to get high and wide whilst having Colwil and Evans provide support to Moore.
The way Mick set us up in this formation was criminal, but there's a reason back 3s are becoming more and more common in modern football.
-
Re: CARDIFF CITY v Q.P.R. Match thread
We always concede a few so I’m going 4-3 city
-
Re: CARDIFF CITY v Q.P.R. Match thread
Quote:
Originally Posted by
WJ99mobile
Flint is the best defender we have probably
Nelson is a liability. If it wasn't for the fact we had Morrison and Flint also, we would be looking for a replacement
Yeah I think you can make a case for Flint but personally think Morrison is a better defender and I wouldn’t play the together especially with Giles bombing forward at fullback.
If that defence can get some form I think they are the better 3 personally. Getting form is the issue but then Flint hasn’t been great either minus the goals
-
Re: CARDIFF CITY v Q.P.R. Match thread
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Llandaff Blue
Not really. It allows Giles and NG to get high and wide whilst having Colwil and Evans provide support to Moore.
The way Mick set us up in this formation was criminal, but there's a reason back 3s are becoming more and more common in modern football.
Agree this team couldn’t be further from a MM team
-
Re: CARDIFF CITY v Q.P.R. Match thread
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Parti Mellow
Three centre backs then, still too cautious.
it doesn't have to be, if you get the wing backs pushed on it can be a really aggressive tactic. think Holland at the euros
-
Re: CARDIFF CITY v Q.P.R. Match thread
LIVE from CCFS. I have a signal!
-
Re: CARDIFF CITY v Q.P.R. Match thread
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Citizen's Nephew
LIVE from CCFS. I have a signal!
Because there's no bugger here
-
Re: CARDIFF CITY v Q.P.R. Match thread
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Armitage Shanks
Because there's no bugger here
🤙😮
-
Re: CARDIFF CITY v Q.P.R. Match thread
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Armitage Shanks
Because there's no bugger here
I only ever miss home games if I’m away on holiday but, unfortunately, I’m missing tonight because I’m going on holiday on Friday. Had a ‘fit to fly’ test this morning, results tomorrow and another test at Cardiff Airport on Friday morning, two negatives allow you to check in, a positive means no holiday. Just didn’t want to chance it, not happy about the situation....C’mon The City!!!
-
Re: CARDIFF CITY v Q.P.R. Match thread
Been a minute gone and already a noticeable difference in tempo to Mickball
-
Re: CARDIFF CITY v Q.P.R. Match thread
-
Re: CARDIFF CITY v Q.P.R. Match thread
Irrespective of score, isn’t it nice just seeing us try and pass it a little.
-
Re: CARDIFF CITY v Q.P.R. Match thread
So much better to watch, having to watch on tv as I’m away unfortunately. Vaulks wasn’t wrong about the change in midfield play, he along with Pack look so much better.
-
Re: CARDIFF CITY v Q.P.R. Match thread
well impressed so far.
When someone is in possession someone dropping into space just incase.
Always trying to get that second ball
Quicker
Positive forward balls into space
Just looks like we have a plan rather than waiting for the oppo to open up
EDIT not sure about the huge gaps in the defence mind
-
Re: CARDIFF CITY v Q.P.R. Match thread
Did I just hear the commentator suggest that MM was trying to change our style to a more possession based game lol
-
Re: CARDIFF CITY v Q.P.R. Match thread
Collwill and Evans are a joy to watch.
They are playing with confidence!
-
Re: CARDIFF CITY v Q.P.R. Match thread
No BBC reporters down the CCS tonight? Our game hasn’t been mentioned at all in the live updates so far. Have they not been made aware of Mick’s departure?
-
Re: CARDIFF CITY v Q.P.R. Match thread
Refreshing to see the players passing the ball to each other. Much better to watch.
(Smithies looks to have missed that particular team meeting though.)