-
Re: Playing out from the back
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Eric the Half a Bee
No, but keep doing that and you keep offering the opposition the chance to start attacks. On MNF yesterday the two pundits were saying that the recent errors were due to mistakes by defenders.
If your defenders aren't capable of playing the ball out from the back, they don't do it. If they are, surely it's better to have possession than whack it long and enter the lottery.
Any professional footballer, especially in the premier League should be capable of playing a simple pass, and there's always the hoof option if nothing else is on.
Of course, they need to train to do it effectively
-
Re: Playing out from the back
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Rjk
Any professional footballer, especially in the premier League should be capable of playing a simple pass, and there's always the hoof option if nothing else is on.
Of course, they need to train to do it effectively
It's more than a simple pass, these kind of transitions require the entire team to function as a single unit. They spend months doing drills and learning rotations on the training pitch.
-
Re: Playing out from the back
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Pedro de la Rosa
His opinions just don’t interest me, and they are every other post under different names.
Playing out from the back is the way to go because otherwise you needlessly give away possession almost every goal kick.
Yes there will be the odd error but I’d bet more goals are conceded by needlessly giving away possession by hitting it long.
There is zero excuse for a professional not to be able to play a pass in these situations.
-
Re: Playing out from the back
There's no rule where you have to do one thing or the other. Mix it up a bit.
-
Re: Playing out from the back
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Eric the Half a Bee
No, but keep doing that and you keep offering the opposition the chance to start attacks. On MNF yesterday the two pundits were saying that the recent errors were due to mistakes by defenders.
If your defenders aren't capable of playing the ball out from the back, they don't do it. If they are, surely it's better to have possession than whack it long and enter the lottery.
Oh yeah. If they can do it PROPERLY of course you do that , but very very few are, and there's not much prospect of us getting any in the foreseeable future. You've also got to have the right coaching staff to pull that off successfully
-
Re: Playing out from the back
https://youtu.be/3_DW2m0QygA
Here's footage of the boys being trained by the other Bob Wilson and Pedro at Porthcawl to pass it round their penalty area when they take over from Neil Warnock
-
Re: Playing out from the back
Here is a good example of playing out from the back from last night's CL game at Benfica. The move starts with a throw-in near the left corner flag at 82:50, then the ball is played across the box and out to the right touchline. The right fullback then starts an attack which results in a clinical move that ends in a goal.
https://www.footballorgin.com/benfic...tember-2019/2/
-
Re: Playing out from the back
Quote:
Originally Posted by
RonnieBird
Oh yeah. If they can do it PROPERLY of course you do that , but very very few are
What nonsense.
-
Re: Playing out from the back
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Wales-Bales
Here is a good example of playing out from the back from last night's CL game at Benfica. The move starts with a throw-in near the left corner flag at 82:50, then the ball is played across the box and out to the right touchline. The right fullback then starts an attack which results in a clinical move that ends in a goal.
https://www.footballorgin.com/benfic...tember-2019/2/
Here is a better link. I counted 13 touches before it was in the opposition net.
https://www.footballorgin.com/benfic...tember-2019/4/
-
Re: Playing out from the back
Quote:
Originally Posted by
RonnieBird
https://youtu.be/3_DW2m0QygA
Here's footage of the boys being trained by the other Bob Wilson and Pedro at Porthcawl to pass it round their penalty area when they take over from Neil Warnock
Funnily enough, the warnock boys would keep the ball in the air for about 6 touches. And these are not league one players. They are beach bums having fun on a Tuesday..
-
Re: Playing out from the back
The blog has been updated since yesterday actually, and the full system for goalkeeping, playing it out from the back and holding the ball in your own penalty area has been combined with a live kit change into mauve during games.
https://youtu.be/eNrk5_T0d40
-
Re: Playing out from the back
Quote:
Originally Posted by
RonnieBird
What is the logical point in risking losing possession in front of your own goal if you don't have to ?
It's as simple as that really
There is no logical reason to pumping the ball up to players with their back to goal and effectively making the chances of possession 50-50 all of the time. Nobody can control the ball on their head, all we are relying on is anticipating second balls. That's just shit.
-
Re: Playing out from the back
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Tuerto
There is no logical reason to pumping the ball up to players with their back to goal and effectively making the chances of possession 50-50 all of the time. Nobody can control the ball on their head, all we are relying on is anticipating second balls. That's just shit.
Don't bother mate. He hasn't got a clue
-
Re: Playing out from the back
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Tuerto
There is no logical reason to pumping the ball up to players with their back to goal and effectively making the chances of possession 50-50 all of the time. Nobody can control the ball on their head, all we are relying on is anticipating second balls. That's just shit.
It's the only option if Sam Vokes is playing up front!
-
Re: Playing out from the back
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Tuerto
There is no logical reason to pumping the ball up to players with their back to goal and effectively making the chances of possession 50-50 all of the time. Nobody can control the ball on their head, all we are relying on is anticipating second balls. That's just shit.
Well first of all it needn't be 50/50 if you've got a good target man and wingers , but here's the logic - if you lose a long ball that's unfortunate but not immediately dangerous. On the other hand, if you lose it whilst buggering about with the ball in your own half or in front of your own goal , you've got no time to react and it can be in your net a few seconds later.
It's a matter of reducing risks where that's possible and if you're trying to win matches you've got to do that. It depends where your priority is though, and if you think it's worth taking risks you could avoid for the sake of artistic content then so be it.
Someone there said I "haven't got a clue", but that's not so. It's certainly not so for various coaches such as our manager , Sam Allerdyce or Ron Atkinson in recent times or many many others who got the best out of limited players by loading the dice in this and other ways.
-
Re: Playing out from the back
Quote:
Originally Posted by
RonnieBird
Well first of all it needn't be 50/50 if you've got a good target man and wingers , but here's the logic - if you lose a long ball that's unfortunate but not immediately dangerous. On the other hand, if you lose it whilst buggering about with the ball in your own half or in front of your own goal , you've got no time to react and it can be in your net a few seconds later.
It's a matter of reducing risks where that's possible and if you're trying to win matches you've got to do that. It depends where your priority is though, and if you think it's worth taking risks you could avoid for the sake of artistic content then so be it.
Someone there said I "haven't got a clue", but that's not so. It's certainly not so for various coaches such as our manager , Sam Allerdyce or Ron Atkinson in recent times or many many others who got the best out of limited players by loading the dice in this and other ways.
Recent times ? Atkinson?
Atkinson is also shit and a racist.
Jesus wept.
-
Re: Playing out from the back
Everyone was wanking over Rochdale a couple of weeks ago. And now it's out of fashion already?
-
Re: Playing out from the back
Quote:
Originally Posted by
RonnieBird
Well first of all it needn't be 50/50 if you've got a good target man and wingers , but here's the logic - if you lose a long ball that's unfortunate but not immediately dangerous. On the other hand, if you lose it whilst buggering about with the ball in your own half or in front of your own goal , you've got no time to react and it can be in your net a few seconds later.
It's a matter of reducing risks where that's possible and if you're trying to win matches you've got to do that. It depends where your priority is though, and if you think it's worth taking risks you could avoid for the sake of artistic content then so be it.
Someone there said I "haven't got a clue", but that's not so. It's certainly not so for various coaches such as our manager , Sam Allerdyce or Ron Atkinson in recent times or many many others who got the best out of limited players by loading the dice in this and other ways.
I remember watching Atkinson's Villa a number of times in the 90s and to even consider the football that side played as similar as Warnockball shows you don't know what you're talking about.
Also, your comment, which I have highlighted, shows that your lack of understanding of the game has attained new heights. If you really think that passing the ball about the back is merely for show, I'd consider following something simpler, like the card game, Snap.
-
Re: Playing out from the back
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Eric the Half a Bee
I remember watching Atkinson's Villa a number of times in the 90s and to even consider the football that side played as similar as Warnockball shows you don't know what you're talking about.
Also, your comment, which I have highlighted, shows that your lack of understanding of the game has attained new heights. If you really think that passing the ball about the back is merely for show, I'd consider following something simpler, like the card game, Snap.
:hehe:
-
Re: Playing out from the back
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Eric the Half a Bee
I remember watching Atkinson's Villa a number of times in the 90s and to even consider the football that side played as similar as Warnockball shows you don't know what you're talking about.
Also, your comment, which I have highlighted, shows that your lack of understanding of the game has attained new heights. If you really think that passing the ball about the back is merely for show, I'd consider following something simpler, like the card game, Snap.
I may be many things Eric, but simple isn't one of them. Your comment is interesting , since football is - on the face of it -one of the simplest games on earth. That's why some of the people here think they understand it. Compared to lots of other stuff it actually is fairly simple of course , but like anything else it's capable of improvement by intelligent thought.
I have admiration for those who can apply such intelligent thought to improve the performance of a football team, and it's possible to understand to some extent how they're achieving that . Observing the performance of a more expensive and to be fair more skilful team them concluding that we should do that isn't a very intelligent view.
You mention one of the many teams Ron Atkinson has managed as if he's always done it that way, but of course he's done it many ways and always played to the strengths of the players he has available, whilst avoiding the stuff they can't do. I might mention the extreme route one football he used at Peterborough.
Tell you what's definitely NOT intelligent.... Calling people names and acting like a spoilt child whilst discussing alternative tactics. In the real world of big boys activities where we have to make important decisions, people who act like that don't get to take part. It's not going to help anything and it's childishly rude.
-
Re: Playing out from the back
Looking forward to hearing all about what Ron Atkinson did at Peterborough.
Let's play "guess what Ronnie is talking about". My guess is John Beck at Cambridge.
-
Re: Playing out from the back
Ron Atkinson is like the Jim Davidson of football managers. Sam Allardyce is Bernard Manning.
Davidson and Manning. Ronnie Bird's favourite comics ???
-
Re: Playing out from the back
That's all quite childish isn't it ?
There's not much point being logical if people either can't grasp it or just want to call people names from behind their keyboards.
If that's what you like doing, why wait until someone's posted something - just post away with the schoolyard crap and enjoy the fact that you can get away with it .
-
Re: Playing out from the back
Quote:
Originally Posted by
RonnieBird
I may be many things Eric, but simple isn't one of them. Your comment is interesting , since football is - on the face of it -one of the simplest games on earth. That's why some of the people here think they understand it. Compared to lots of other stuff it actually is fairly simple of course , but like anything else it's capable of improvement by intelligent thought.
I have admiration for those who can apply such intelligent thought to improve the performance of a football team, and it's possible to understand to some extent how they're achieving that . Observing the performance of a more expensive and to be fair more skilful team them concluding that we should do that isn't a very intelligent view.
You mention one of the many teams Ron Atkinson has managed as if he's always done it that way, but of course he's done it many ways and always played to the strengths of the players he has available, whilst avoiding the stuff they can't do. I might mention the extreme route one football he used at Peterborough.
Tell you what's definitely NOT intelligent.... Calling people names and acting like a spoilt child whilst discussing alternative tactics. In the real world of big boys activities where we have to make important decisions, people who act like that don't get to take part. It's not going to help anything and it's childishly rude.
Hilarious, trying to gain some sort of moral highground. Spoilt child? Pot, kettle etc. You're the tosser that rubs people up the wrong way then cries when you get it back. :hehe: Only one of us gets it reguarly in the neck from other posters on here, which says something.
Try growing up and being the supposedly intellectual and intelligent mature adult you claim to be. You're not impressing anyone. Quite the opposite.
-
Re: Playing out from the back
Anyone remember when Brian Clough was managing Celtic?
-
Re: Playing out from the back
Quote:
Originally Posted by
lardy
Anyone remember when Brian Clough was managing Celtic?
:hehe:
An interesting article not just for the balloon ball comment.
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/football...areer-to-this/
-
Re: Playing out from the back
What is Ronnie's hard on over Ron Atkinson about?
The guy hasn't been talked about for about 20 years ffs.
I reckon if you typed Ron Atkinson into google the first 10 links from the search engine would open up threads form ccmb from the last month!
-
Re: Playing out from the back
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Eric the Half a Bee
Hilarious, trying to gain some sort of moral highground. Spoilt child? Pot, kettle etc. You're the tosser that rubs people up the wrong way then cries when you get it back. :hehe: Only one of us gets it reguarly in the neck from other posters on here, which says something.
Try growing up and being the supposedly intellectual and intelligent mature adult you claim to be. You're not impressing anyone. Quite the opposite.
I don't want to impress anyone here , I can assure you. Your comment is rubbish though, because I don't call people names, especially in response to a post they've made.
It's heartbreaking to see some of the stuff written here, but not for me, for the sake of those who will self inflict failure upon themselves with their lack of manners and insistence upon opinions which don't stand examination.
-
Re: Playing out from the back
Quote:
Originally Posted by
RonnieBird
It's heartbreaking to see some of the stuff written here, but not for me, for the sake of those who will self inflict failure upon themselves with their lack of manners and insistence upon opinions which don't stand examination.
Is that Hamlet? Wales Bales?
-
Re: Playing out from the back
It's not Hamlet or WB.
I can do a bit of Shakespeare if you like, but I didn't think it would go down well here.
' Lord what fools these mortals be !'
-
Re: Playing out from the back
Quote:
Originally Posted by
RonnieBird
' Lord what fools these mortals be !'
There you go 👌👏 And I think Tuerto was generous. Kicking out from the back is more 65/35 than 50/50.
-
Re: Playing out from the back
ronnie ruining another thread with his tedious posts.
-
Re: Playing out from the back
a great example of the modern game
<blockquote class="twitter-tweet"><p lang="en" dir="ltr">Great example from Bournemouth on drawing the press and then beating it. Superb understanding of how their positioning and ball movement manipulate the opposition, combined with the ability and composure to play off of 1 or 2 touches under pressure <a href="https://t.co/h1XlYgPQ9s">pic.twitter.com/h1XlYgPQ9s</a></p>— Lee Hurrell (@LHfutebol) <a href="https://twitter.com/LHfutebol/status/1174382327142780930?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">September 18, 2019</a></blockquote> <script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>
-
Re: Playing out from the back
Quote:
Originally Posted by
MOZZER2
a great example of the modern game
<blockquote class="twitter-tweet"><p lang="en" dir="ltr">Great example from Bournemouth on drawing the press and then beating it. Superb understanding of how their positioning and ball movement manipulate the opposition, combined with the ability and composure to play off of 1 or 2 touches under pressure ���� <a href="https://t.co/h1XlYgPQ9s">pic.twitter.com/h1XlYgPQ9s</a></p>— Lee Hurrell (@LHfutebol) <a href="https://twitter.com/LHfutebol/status/1174382327142780930?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">September 18, 2019</a></blockquote> <script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>
What a load of bollocks. Where's the 50-50 challenges, the misplaced passes and the last gasp tackles to win the ball back for the keeper to launch forward, taking out half a dozen seagulls as it gets close to exiting the earth's atmosphere?
This isn't football. I'd rather watch a schoolyard game of kick and rush.
-
Re: Playing out from the back
Quote:
Originally Posted by
MOZZER2
a great example of the modern game
<blockquote class="twitter-tweet"><p lang="en" dir="ltr">Great example from Bournemouth on drawing the press and then beating it. Superb understanding of how their positioning and ball movement manipulate the opposition, combined with the ability and composure to play off of 1 or 2 touches under pressure ���� <a href="https://t.co/h1XlYgPQ9s">pic.twitter.com/h1XlYgPQ9s</a></p>— Lee Hurrell (@LHfutebol) <a href="https://twitter.com/LHfutebol/status/1174382327142780930?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">September 18, 2019</a></blockquote> <script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>
Love that football is heading in this direction. How can anyone hate watching this
-
Re: Playing out from the back
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Llandaff Blue
Love that football is heading in this direction. How can anyone hate watching this
Apparently, in the 1870s, Scotland bamboozled the English by passing the ball. Before that, football was largely a game where one player would run as far as he could with the ball until he lost it.
-
Re: Playing out from the back
I think playing out from the back, can look clever and controlled, and I do like to see it, but to me it can only work with a settled defence.
-
Re: Playing out from the back
That was a thing of beauty. Extremely well executed but not without risk. It's also not a great example. It doesn't have to be like that. When the goalie has the opportunity and the outfield player is well placed pass the ball. If not, do something else.
It just seems obvious to me that in the game of football when you can, pass to one of your own players. Hoofing upfield and hoping for the best should be a last resort. That's not to say you can't go long to someone running into space, but booting into the pack when you can actually use your feet and hand to control the ball just seems a waste.
-
Re: Playing out from the back
Quote:
Originally Posted by
lardy
Looking forward to hearing all about what Ron Atkinson did at Peterborough.
Let's play "guess what Ronnie is talking about". My guess is John Beck at Cambridge.
Come on ronniebird, what did you want to say about Ron Atkinson's stint in charge of Peterborough?
-
Re: Playing out from the back