This has been a truly dreadful refereeing performance. He should be ashamed.
Printable View
This has been a truly dreadful refereeing performance. He should be ashamed.
Morecambe promoted.
I dislike abuse of the officials but what happens after such a dreadful performance? Usually they get one game at a lower level then straight back to where they were before. This ref should not ever ref a game of such magnitude for the longest time and Morecambe diver should be known as such.
Cheating pays. Newport cheated out of promotion. When people say VAR is killing the game at least there is more chance of a fairer outcome.
Worst game of football ive seen in a long time which is saying something coupled with a shocking refereeing performance and blatant cheating.
And another team in red wins a play off.
Given Morecambe’s finances, Madley could not have been bought, so its just his sheer ineptitude that has ruined Newport’s season.
I feel nearly as robbed as if it was City. Ffing awful refereeing, two huge mistakes should not have such enormous consequences on a club, instead of Sheffield Weds, Sunderland & Portsmouth, it’ll be Sutton, Barrow & Stevenage
As per my thread last week, PL referees are without doubt the absolute worst.Quote:
Originally Posted by Zowhore
Bad luck Cewnty! You were the better team on the day. Can't understand why Maynard wasn't on the pitch from the start? Not a penalty for Morecambe either, foul happened outside the box.Quote:
Originally Posted by tforturton
I don’t know what it is, I haven’t seen any PL games but I’ve seen a lot of European games and the referees seem to have a better understanding, more empathy and more respect, they also seem to have lower profilesQuote:
Originally Posted by A Quiet Monkfish
Newport were the better team but lets face it that doesnt say much. They were poor as well.
Almost incapable of competing at corners and long throws no cutting edge.
Years since we were at that level but our promotion team with Eddie May would have hammered both out of sight.
English refs all seem to come across as arrogantQuote:
Originally Posted by Des Parrot
To play such a long season and have it defined by such a poor refereeing display must be horrible
PL referees have been built up in importance over the years, starting when they gave them different coloured tops as opposed to the rest of the football league/pyramid where all black was the tradition. I also suspect that they're picked for personality and ability to interact with the more temperamental PL player..Quote:
Originally Posted by Des Parrot
Before seeing the replay my impression was that Madley just guessed.
I dont even think he looked at the linesman.
Big respect to Mike Flynn for his post match interview. Gave Morecambe credit before dealing with the two terrible decisions.
Flynn has every right to be aggrieved.
But if I was a Newport fan id be asking why Collins was subbed when he clearly had the beating of his marker.
This, I thought the Newport subs made them worse. I watched Lewis on loan at Cinderford 2 seasons ago, he’s a great lad and the reason I wanted Newport to winQuote:
Originally Posted by Hilts
County should have won that! The ref obviously had a shocker, but if County had more cutting edge they would have won easily. Morecambe were absolutely dire. County only have themselves to blame.
How can Newport 'only' have themselves to blame if the ref had a shocker?Quote:
Originally Posted by Mario Miethig
Wasnt disappointed when Swansea lost, but am disappointed for Newport, after the shit they have gone through over the years. Hope this defeat doesn't set them back.
Awful decisions for the 2 pens but Labadie should have buried that chance.
Sheehan will likely leave on a free now, worth a punt for us on a sensible one or two year deal?
No. Not good enough even as back up We need to improve our midfield and the current lot are miles better than him.Quote:
Originally Posted by FormerlyJohnnyBreadhead
Put Pack in one of those sides today and hed look like Pirlo.
what a poncey cheating dive
Dreadful refereeing
There is something to be said for being a dominant promotion side as we were under Eddie May
The play offs are a nightmare
Newport is easily big enough to sustain a league one side , even perhaps a lower level championship club
The team that won today will soon drop back down
Morecambe will be bottom of League 1 next season, and Newport would have too if they'd gone up.
Newport should have had a penalty in the first half and Morecambe should never have had their penalty. I know there are many criticisms of VAR but had it been available Newport could well have won that match.
nothing wrong with VAR and to me should be used in play off finals
County only have themselves to blame. Between December and March they hardly won a game. In the end, I was surprised they actually got to the play offs.That was an achievement in itself.
Morecambe can be expected to set a League One record for the fewest points gained while finishing 24th.
If the ref wasn't Bobby Madley they would have won. I don't know what your experience of him was like, but he certainly didn't like us. When I saw the decisions today I thought he might be anti Welsh, because he was definitely biased against Newport.Quote:
Originally Posted by Vindec
I don't tend to be one for anti Welsh conspiracy theories when it comes to referees, but, leaving the penalty incidents aside, I thought Madley favoured Morecambe throughout the game, so, in view of what you said, I had a look at his record in matches involving Welsh teams on Soccerbase.Quote:
Originally Posted by ZZ Jack
As he had spent so much of his career in the Premier League before his suspension, he's taken charge of more of your games than any other Welsh side (as far as I can tell, he's never reffed a Wrexham game) and your record in those matches is won four, drawn two and lost eight. However, this rather reflected your form over the period, because early on as you were challenging for promotion and then settling into the Premier League with few alarms, you did well when he was in charge, but as you began to struggle every season, so the losses piled up.
We've won two of the six matches Madley has reffed us in, with the only defeat coming in a game against Wolves in which they had a player sent off, so we've not done bad under him, whereas County have only had him in charge for two games this season since his fall from grace saw him reduced to the lower leagues - they lost 4-2 at home to Oldham in December at a time when they were going really well and then there was yesterday.
So, it looks like cock up wins over conspiracy as far as Madley is concerned and it was just County's bad luck that he had a stinker of a game - for me, he was the main reason why the match finished as it did.
Madleys performance was terrible.
However diving cheating players dont help.
Swansea were the worst ive seen with this and a certain Welsh International and his screaming and rolling around trying to get people cards.
During the game yesterday it flashed up County's top four goal scorers this season but two had been on loan and recalled halfway through the year - they've basically built two sides this season.Quote:
Originally Posted by Ivortheengine
County's pitch was awful for a period of time, eventually they were giving the relief of switching games to Cardiff, which meant the passing football they played for much of yesterday couldn't happen.
There are details behind the stats you're giving there.
About time that sort of behavior was punished with more than a yellow card. Time for the introduction of a sin bin, or something more extreme? There should definitely be no place for it in the game.Quote:
Originally Posted by Hilts
Thanks for the research and the heads up. It may be his over dramatic refusal of a penalty against Stoke which has coloured my perception.Quote:
Originally Posted by the other bob wilson
Has a winning manager been more bitter than Derek Adams.