-
Re: Official Ashes Thread
Australia lose their top three in the first hour - there’ll be talk of a dodgy ball change if they lose this.
-
Re: Official Ashes Thread
The umpire J Wilson is very poor.
-
Re: Official Ashes Thread
Surely the Stokes catch is legal. Arguably he lost control of the ball but I disagree as the catch was evident.
-
Re: Official Ashes Thread
Thought the Aussies were going to crack at 3 down, but that's a great partnership. Forecast must be crap mind, draw still around 7/4
-
Re: Official Ashes Thread
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Vindec
Surely the Stokes catch is legal. Arguably he lost control of the ball but I disagree as the catch was evident.
Stokes knew it wasn't complete the moment it left his hand.
-
Re: Official Ashes Thread
Ben Stokes what have you done?
-
Re: Official Ashes Thread
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Harry Paget Flashman
Stokes knew it wasn't complete the moment it left his hand.
Lords Rules state (relating to a fair catch):
"33.2.2.1 the ball is held in the hand or hands of a fielder, even if the hand holding the ball is touching the ground, or is hugged to the body, or lodges in the external protective equipment worn by a fielder, or lodges accidentally in a fielder’s clothing."
Surely the ball was firmly in Stokes hand; that was my point.
-
Re: Official Ashes Thread
Smith and Head gone. Game on?
-
Re: Official Ashes Thread
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Vindec
Lords Rules state (relating to a fair catch):
"33.2.2.1 the ball is held in the hand or hands of a fielder, even if the hand holding the ball is touching the ground, or is hugged to the body, or lodges in the external protective equipment worn by a fielder, or lodges accidentally in a fielder’s clothing."
Surely the ball was firmly in Stokes hand; that was my point.
I don't know the law and CBA to look it up but the commentators on the radio were all in agreement that he wasn't in control of his body and therefore it wasn't complete. Bit like the Aussie catch earlier in the series.
EDIT:
33.3 Making a catch
The act of making a catch shall start from the time when the ball first comes into contact with a fielder’s person and shall end when a fielder obtains complete control over both the ball and his/her own movement.
-
Re: Official Ashes Thread
What on earth is happening. Australia were absolutely cruising that game
-
Re: Official Ashes Thread
Whatever happens while we can say Wood was badly missed with his extreme pace Woakes has been brilliant and has shown he should have been in from the start.
-
Re: Official Ashes Thread
Will Stokes take the new ball. ?
If Australia win whatever he does will be questioned.
Though really England should win whatever he chooses.
-
Re: Official Ashes Thread
Quote:
Originally Posted by
chrisp_1927
What on earth is happening. Australia were absolutely cruising that game
Remarkable change of fortunes in such a short time.
Australia now 8 down and still need 90 odd.
Test cricket proving compelling viewing once again.
-
Re: Official Ashes Thread
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Majorblue
Remarkable change of fortunes in such a short time.
Australia now 8 down and still need 90 odd.
Test cricket proving compelling viewing once again.
This series has proved once more how fantastic a game test cricket is. I wouldn’t cross the road to watch that Hundred shite starting this week.
-
Re: Official Ashes Thread
Imagine if England had won the last one and the Ashes were coming down to this.
-
Re: Official Ashes Thread
-
Re: Official Ashes Thread
Quote:
Originally Posted by
bluesp
Had to be didn’t it?
Yeah, but he's not that good really though is he :hehe:
-
Re: Official Ashes Thread
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Hot Shot Hamish.
This series has proved once more how fantastic a game test cricket is. I wouldn’t cross the road to watch that Hundred shite starting this week.
This series has shown Test cricket at its finest 👏 👏
Me neither re the hundred.
The good news is, footy season starts this week!
Woohoo 🙌
-
Re: Official Ashes Thread
Quote:
Originally Posted by
MacAdder
Yeah, but he's not that good really though is he :hehe:
Amazing finale
GOAT 604 Test Wickets Ave 27.68
https://www.espncricinfo.com/series/...ive-match-blog
-
Re: Official Ashes Thread
Fantastic series and what an ending. Pity the 4th Test spoilt things but this series shows why Test Cricket is the best.
Final ball he faced he hits for 6 and wins the match with his final ball.
Broad is an all time great.
-
Re: Official Ashes Thread
Broad finishes his last test innings with the bat with a 6 and his last test n the field with a wicket.
-
Re: Official Ashes Thread
Ah well. Our 3rd xi captain has just asked if I’ll make up numbers on Saturday. How can I say no after watching that series. Right, let’s go and get the linseed oil out!
Well played England.
-
Re: Official Ashes Thread
I couldn’t see England taking ten wickets today, especially with most of the afternoon washed out, but, while everyone talks about the batting with bazball, it also has seen them become far better at taking twenty wickets in the match than they were.
The winning margins of two and three wickets and two of forty odd runs shows how close the series was, but it’s hard to see how it would have been anything other than a very comfortable win for England at Old Trafford if it were not for the rain.
The one negative for me is that a five match test match series in this country should not be finishing in July as it was shoehorned into almost a month to accommodate the bloody Hundred - what an anti climax the next month threatens to be.
-
Re: Official Ashes Thread
Quote:
Originally Posted by
MacAdder
This series has shown Test cricket at its finest
Me neither re the hundred.
The good news is, footy season starts this week!
Woohoo
Test cricket.
The greatest sport.
If not for everybody.
:ayatollah:
-
Re: Official Ashes Thread
Quote:
Originally Posted by
the other bob wilson
I couldn’t see England taking ten wickets today, especially with most of the afternoon washed out, but, while everyone talks about the batting with bazball, it also has seen them become far better at taking twenty wickets in the match than they were.
The winning margins of two and three wickets and two of forty odd runs shows how close the series was, but it’s hard to see how it would have been anything other than a very comfortable win for England at Old Trafford if it were not for the rain.
The one negative for me is that a five match test match series in this country should not be finishing in July as it was shoehorned into almost a month to accommodate the bloody Hundred - what an anti climax the next month threatens to be.
The ODI v New Zealand is in Cardiff in September….. might be worth a visit