Originally Posted by
JamesWales
In defence of Sludge...
And bearing in mind I haven't read everything here.
But it is possible to be critical of some pro-welsh language policies and that not mean you don't support the language. For example, the language needs to 'win around' people if it is to have popular support. Spending money on bilingual signage may not be the best way to do that. Sludge's comments are very common in Cardiff.
Sometimes less is more and 'shoving things down peoples throats' (not my words) isn't always the best thing to do.
Personally I have no issue at all with bilingual general information as it's cheaper than an opt out system and tends to lead to more concise communication (ie, you keep it to one side of paper, so the Welsh/English is reversible).
One thing I would change is the requirement for kids to study Welsh until 16. I think after 14 it should be optional, by which time you have gained an awareness of the cultural and linguistic elements of the language but you are unlikely to become fluent in it compared to kids at Welsh language schools and it does impact upon other subjects given there are only so many hours in the day.
Anecdotally I think that policy does build some resentment towards the language, including amongst young people 'made' to learn it.