-
Re: The bookies have us finishing 20th ?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
J R Hartley
Injuries are part and parcel of the game. Thats why clubs have 20+ man squads plus younger pros.
Not ideal getting 3 injuries of 2-4 months each before a ball is even kicked this season, but apart from Collins they were not likely to be in Buluts starting XI. Collins, maybe, but after a good start here the jury is out on him and O Dowda may have been preffered at LB anyway.
Championship clubs cant afford to carry massive squads, so its an opportunity for some youngsters to fill the bench and maybe get an opportunity earlier in the season they wouldnt have otherwise got. Could be the making of one or two of them, who knows.
I agree Conte and Ashford looked very good at the end of the season, maybe with plenty of good players around them to help them have their breakthrough season.
-
Re: The bookies have us finishing 20th ?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
The Lone Gunman
The Racing Post's verdict is in:
17th - Cardiff City - Twelfth place last season was a significant step forward for Cardiff, who had narrowly staved off relegation in 2022/23, but some of the underlying statistics were not great with 70 goals conceded and a goal difference of minus 17. The Bluebirds have been fairly quiet in the transfer market and may regress.
The Post's predictions for the top 8:
1st - Burnley
2nd - Leeds Utd
3rd - Middlesbrough
4th - Norwich City
5th - Coventry City
6th - West Brom
7th - Luton Town
8th - Bristol City
The bottom six:
19th - Sunderland
20th - Derby County
21st - Portsmouth
22nd - Blackburn Rovers
23rd - Oxford United
24th - Plymouth Argyle
Their best bet recommendations:
Burnley to win the title @ 8/1
Middlesbrough to be promoted @ 7/2
Plymouth to be relegated @ 9/4
Blackburn to be relegated @ 4/1
Bristol City to finish ahead of Cardiff, Plymouth and Swansea @ 9/4
Not sure where their confidence in Bristol is coming from ?
-
Re: The bookies have us finishing 20th ?
I think the Championship 11th-18th is much of a muchness so not sure why city fans are getting annoyed by people predicting a lower finish. Unless we get a proven striker we will always struggle to improve on that. Signings from abroad have a rare hit rate so I think we will struggle to come by goals again this season which will be our undoing
Ramsey staying fit and starting 25+ games or Kanga being a gem are the only things I can see that would take us into the top 8
-
Re: The bookies have us finishing 20th ?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Eric the Half a Bee
Yes, absolutely correct. In fact, only 5 top half teams have had a worse goal difference in the history of the football league. Colchester hold the record with a GD of -21 despite a 10th place finish in 1951/52 and hold the worst ever record for a third tier side.
We hold the record in the second tier.
Any guesses which team holds the record in the top division?
Derby?
-
Re: The bookies have us finishing 20th ?
Szmodics was the top scorer in the Championship with 27. I for one would not have wanted to swap places with Blackburn last season.
There are only a couple of ways of finishing mid table. One is lose as many as you win, the other is win less but have a few more draws. We “took” the former option. Teams that do this have a tendency to finish with large negative goal differences. Our final “on the beach” game with Rotherham obviously took us into the stratosphere in some people’s eyes wrt gd but have a look, plenty have finished up with similar numbers. Btw a team could go through a season unbeaten and be relegated. I.e. gd = 0. We almost did this in league 2.
-
Re: The bookies have us finishing 20th ?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
PaulWent76
There are only a couple of ways of finishing mid table. One is lose as many as you win, the other is win less but have a few more draws. We “took” the former option. Teams that do this have a tendency to finish with large negative goal differences. Our final “on the beach” game with Rotherham obviously took us into the stratosphere in some people’s eyes wrt gd but have a look, plenty have finished up with similar numbers.
Who and when?
-
Re: The bookies have us finishing 20th ?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
PaulWent76
Szmodics was the top scorer in the Championship with 27. I for one would not have wanted to swap places with Blackburn last season.
I would. In a heartbeat. Seeing a player score 27 league goals would have been brilliant and it's the sort of thing that happens very rarely.
-
Re: The bookies have us finishing 20th ?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
TheBirchgrovePub
Not sure where their confidence in Bristol is coming from ?
Their write-up on Bristol City is as follows:
Bristol City finished 11th last season despite conceding only 51 goals - the fourth-lowest total in the division. The Robins were lacking in offensive areas, but they have added to their options with the off-season signings of Sinclair Armstrong (QPR) and Fally Mayulu (Rapid Vienna).
This will be City's first full season under highly-rated head coach Liam Manning and they have scope for improvement. If Bristol can add a few more goals to their game it will make a big difference as they are a difficult side to play against.
-
Re: The bookies have us finishing 20th ?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
The Lone Gunman
Their write-up on Bristol City is as follows:
Bristol City finished 11th last season despite conceding only 51 goals - the fourth-lowest total in the division. The Robins were lacking in offensive areas, but they have added to their options with the off-season signings of Sinclair Armstrong (QPR) and Fally Mayulu (Rapid Vienna).
This will be City's first full season under highly-rated head coach Liam Manning and they have scope for improvement. If Bristol can add a few more goals to their game it will make a big difference as they are a difficult side to play against.
And their top scorer from last season (Tommy Conway) is heading out of the door!
-
Re: The bookies have us finishing 20th ?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
The Lone Gunman
Who and when?
Ok. You got me. The other minus gds over -10 over the past 5 years are not similar (Preston seem to be the masters) to our horrendous -17. And before you point out that Eric stated top half teams, I was pointing to characteristics of mid table teams which we clearly were last season. We had a small flirtation with the playoffs and a small flirtation with relegation.
Blackburn with their goal machine finished 19th, 3 points off the relegation spots, we finished twelfth. My blood pressure situation means I couldn’t join you in wishing for such excitement but everyone has their own tastes.
For what it’s worth I really enjoyed the Rotherham game. It was quite enjoyable up until their 3, 4, 5th goals. At least we scored 2.
-
Re: The bookies have us finishing 20th ?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
PontBlue
Perhaps the issues with loans are the fees involved and we've reached our spending limit to stay within financial regulations which I'd be amazed to find we haven't already breached
Not sure, like most clubs we've shipped out a lot more than we have brought in, and even assuming they're on decent wages our wage bill may well be the same - possibly lower. I also think it makes sense to leave some loan spaces ready for the January window..
-
Re: The bookies have us finishing 20th ?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
BlueArmy 86
Derby?
No. It's us. 1953/54, albeit goal average was the thing back then, we finished 10th having scored 51 and conceded 71. It's the second worst goal difference for any top half time in the football league of all time.
We have the worst goal difference of all top half teams in both of the top two divisions. It's an unusual and somewhat freak record to hold. I can't recall it being on the club's honours board....
Sadly the club didn't keep up with the spirit of things in the third and fourth tier, where we've never had a negative goal difference after 13 top half finishes. A GD of +2 in 1996/97 was the lowest and the only one under two figures.
We've finished in the top half of the second tier on 28 occasions, having a negative goal difference 6 times. 4 of those have been since 2005/6. In fact, in our last 4 top half finishes in this division, we've created the records for the best and worst goal differences of all our top half finishes combined at this level.
-
Re: The bookies have us finishing 20th ?
Latest odds - Sky Bet
We are now 80/1 to win the Championship and shortened to 3/1 for relegation. Unchanged at 18/1 for promotion.
-
Re: The bookies have us finishing 20th ?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
PaulWent76
Ok. You got me. The other minus gds over -10 over the past 5 years are not similar (Preston seem to be the masters) to our horrendous -17. And before you point out that Eric stated top half teams, I was pointing to characteristics of mid table teams which we clearly were last season. We had a small flirtation with the playoffs and a small flirtation with relegation.
Blackburn with their goal machine finished 19th, 3 points off the relegation spots, we finished twelfth. My blood pressure situation means I couldn’t join you in wishing for such excitement but everyone has their own tastes.
For what it’s worth I really enjoyed the Rotherham game. It was quite enjoyable up until their 3, 4, 5th goals. At least we scored 2.
I really enjoyed Sheff Wed in the cup. We played with an approach which was pleasing to see. We should have won that match, ridiculous as that sounds.
-
Re: The bookies have us finishing 20th ?
Im really optimistic. A lot of the predictions are based on last seasons goal difference / xg balance but for me the squad is hugely different to last season.
Weve brought in Willock, Chambers, El Ghazi, Robertson and Kanga; Kangas a bit of an unknown quantity but the other 4 are excellent signings.
Weve got Ashford, Conte and Giles, who all look capable of stepping up, weve got Ramsey and ODowda who both played very little last year and will both make a big difference if they stay fit plus theres Eli King and Isaak Davies returning from successful loan spells. We still look light up front (unless Kanga does the business or Robinson carries on his pre season form) but lets be honest, our main problem in the last few years hasnt been our strikers missing chances, its that weve created sweet FA.
Defence looks solid plus Horvath was excellent after we signed him. Also the divisions a lot weaker than last year. I reckon we're going to finish between 6 and 10.
-
Re: The bookies have us finishing 20th ?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Cardiff Ultra
Im really optimistic. A lot of the predictions are based on last seasons goal difference / xg balance but for me the squad is hugely different to last season.
Weve brought in Willock, Chambers, El Ghazi, Robertson and Kanga; Kangas a bit of an unknown quantity but the other 4 are excellent signings.
Weve got Ashford, Conte and Giles, who all look capable of stepping up, weve got Ramsey and ODowda who both played very little last year and will both make a big difference if they stay fit plus theres Eli King and Isaak Davies returning from successful loan spells. We still look light up front (unless Kanga does the business or Robinson carries on his pre season form) but lets be honest, our main problem in the last few years hasnt been our strikers missing chances, its that weve created sweet FA.
Defence looks solid plus Horvath was excellent after we signed him. Also the divisions a lot weaker than last year. I reckon we're going to finish between 6 and 10.
I also feel confident we are going to improve in very important areas , from what I have seen so far the signings look very positive. one or two of the youngsters look like they may have something to offer . I really like the look of Conte.
So I have been looking for at the odds for a top half finish or even top six.
For a team that the bookies reckon will finish 20th there is very little value . 7/4 ish for top half and 5/1 for top 6 , better odds if you go to the spread markets . Nothing for me at the moment.
-
Re: The bookies have us finishing 20th ?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Jimmy the Jock
I also feel confident we are going to improve in very important areas , from what I have seen so far the signings look very positive. one or two of the youngsters look like they may have something to offer . I really like the look of Conte.
So I have been looking for at the odds for a top half finish or even top six.
For a team that the bookies reckon will finish 20th there is very little value . 7/4 ish for top half and 5/1 for top 6 , better odds if you go to the spread markets . Nothing for me at the moment.
13/2 for the top six with SkyBet. 2/1 for a top half finish.
-
Re: The bookies have us finishing 20th ?
I can only see one of our players in the Top Championship goalscorer market which is Ramsey at 150/1
-
Re: The bookies have us finishing 20th ?
My mistake Robinson 66/1 Miete 80/1.
-
Re: The bookies have us finishing 20th ?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Hilts
My mistake Robinson 66/1 Miete 80/1.
You could put Meite in at 800/1 and he still wouldn’t appeal.
-
Re: The bookies have us finishing 20th ?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Hilts
Latest odds - Sky Bet
We are now 80/1 to win the Championship and shortened to 3/1 for relegation. Unchanged at 18/1 for promotion.
Worth a tenner.
-
Re: The bookies have us finishing 20th ?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Cardiff Ultra
Im really optimistic. A lot of the predictions are based on last seasons goal difference / xg balance but for me the squad is hugely different to last season.
Weve brought in Willock, Chambers, El Ghazi, Robertson and Kanga; Kangas a bit of an unknown quantity but the other 4 are excellent signings.
Weve got Ashford, Conte and Giles, who all look capable of stepping up, weve got Ramsey and ODowda who both played very little last year and will both make a big difference if they stay fit plus theres Eli King and Isaak Davies returning from successful loan spells. We still look light up front (unless Kanga does the business or Robinson carries on his pre season form) but lets be honest, our main problem in the last few years hasnt been our strikers missing chances, its that weve created sweet FA.
Defence looks solid plus Horvath was excellent after we signed him. Also the divisions a lot weaker than last year. I reckon we're going to finish between 6 and 10.
Good post I am of the same P. M. A.
-
Re: The bookies have us finishing 20th ?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Hilts
Latest odds - Sky Bet
We are now 80/1 to win the Championship and shortened to 3/1 for relegation. Unchanged at 18/1 for promotion.
I really don't get that. I admit that I don't pay that much attention to other clubs, but I can't see how we're not a mid-table team.
-
Re: The bookies have us finishing 20th ?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Cardiff Ultra
Im really optimistic. A lot of the predictions are based on last seasons goal difference / xg balance but for me the squad is hugely different to last season.
Weve brought in Willock, Chambers, El Ghazi, Robertson and Kanga; Kangas a bit of an unknown quantity but the other 4 are excellent signings.
Weve got Ashford, Conte and Giles, who all look capable of stepping up, weve got Ramsey and ODowda who both played very little last year and will both make a big difference if they stay fit plus theres Eli King and Isaak Davies returning from successful loan spells. We still look light up front (unless Kanga does the business or Robinson carries on his pre season form) but lets be honest, our main problem in the last few years hasnt been our strikers missing chances, its that weve created sweet FA.
Defence looks solid plus Horvath was excellent after we signed him. Also the divisions a lot weaker than last year. I reckon we're going to finish between 6 and 10.
Great post :thumbup:
-
Re: The bookies have us finishing 20th ?
I was struck by how much the Second Tier podcast's season prediction of an eighteenth place finish for us was put down to the fact that we were owned by Vincent Tan. I said on here that I couldn't argue too much with that viewpoint when it comes to our owner because I believe that, over the past fourteen years, his overall effect on the club has been negative, but what cannot be denied, is that we've been promoted twice to the top flight under his ownership and no other owner in my City supporting life has been able to do it once.
I've seen one prediction of a tenth placed finish for us in numerous podcasts I've watched streamed by non City fans. That was well above anything else I've seen as we've generally been rated around the 17th to 20th mark. I've also read a piece saying that we've had one of the more striking transfer windows in the Championship so far - I've not seen anything else using g such dramatic language, but there's generally a feeling that we've done pretty well in the window up to now, yet this is never reflected in the finishing position predicted for us, bar that one outlier that has us finishing tenth.
So, if it seems to be accepted that we've done okay this summer, why is it not being reflected in where we're predicted to finish - as it stands, there seems to be a feeling that we've improved our squad, but are expected to drop by somethiung like half a dozen places in a division which is held to be weaker than last season by many? I agree that this can partly be explained by our finishing position being prett freakish last season - so many of the end of season stats point to a side that should be in the bottom six rather than the top dozen.
However, does the Second Tier's verdict reflect how we're perceived by football fans outside of a corner of south Wales? I think it probably does - we've been a shambles of a club for years and this stems from the man in charge, but I think this time ther pundits from outside of south Wales have got us a bit wrong, I believe that if, say, Preston has the 23/24 that we did and then signed the exact same players we have, then the verdict would be that they were headed for a top ten finish and maybe better than that - we need more goalscoring potential in the form of the sort of striker we were told to expect during this window if we are to make a genuine top six challenge in my opinion, but I think that one person who had us finishing tenth may be closer to the truth than all of the others.