FT: FULHAM 1 - 2 CARDIFF CITY. (Fulham win 3 - 2 on agg)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by splott parker

Utter bollocks, how can you attempt snide criticism after tonight’s game?

---

If you think that effort alone is going to get us anywhere then just look at the teams in the final.

They tried every bit as hard as we did, but also tried to play pass and move football, and that is the difference here.

I commend the effort but that is sadly not enough to get promoted. As has been brutally highlighted.

There is absolutely no shame in admitting that for whatever reason ‘effort’ in this case wasn’t enough. We didn’t have the footballing nous to win the tie and they did.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Bobby Dandruff

He has. I wonder if we’ll look to sell Etheridge in the window as a result?

---

I doubt that there will be many teams willing to pay a transfer fee for him with less than 12 months left of his contract. The time to cash in was last summer when his stock was high.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Bluebirdman Of Alcathays

Although I wouldn't have put it like Mr Dandruff has, I think he has a point. We have something about us but not enough (yet). First half I was bored which is partly why the second half was such a revelation (and great to see).

A few people saying they prefer the championship - in a way that means we'd fall short every year which is not something I'd like to see cos I think we're bigger and potentially better than that and if we do go up again I would want us to avoid relegation and play some decent football while we're at it, which means progressing a fair bit further from where we are. So, really encouraging in parts tonight but also work to be done.

---

Thinly veiled praise is the worst of all compliments you 2 faced barsteward 😖

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by LeningradCowboy

I doubt that there will be many teams willing to pay a transfer fee for him with less than 12 months left of his contract. The time to cash in was last summer when his stock was high.

---

We'd get something for him, he's a good goalkeeper

The ones I'd be worried about being able to move on are Pack and Flint

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Bobby Dandruff

If you think that effort alone is going to get us anywhere then just look at the teams in the final.

They tried every bit as hard as we did, but also tried to play pass and move football, and that is the difference here.

I commend the effort but that is sadly not enough to get promoted. As has been brutally highlighted.

There is absolutely no shame in admitting that for whatever reason ‘effort’ in this case wasn’t enough. We didn’t have the footballing nous to win the tie and they did.

---

We game them all they could handle.

Fulham looked fecked at the end.

Whereas Brentford looked like theyd had a training match after the game v your boys last night.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Hilts

We game them all they could handle.

Fulham looked fecked at the end.

Whereas Brentford looked like theyd had a training match after the game v your boys last night.

---

Rosenior summed it up pretty well, there was only one winner had it gone to extra time and they weren't in white shirts

Fulham were rattled and knew they got away with it, you could tell by their reaction at the end

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Bobby Dandruff

If you think that effort alone is going to get us anywhere then just look at the teams in the final.

They tried every bit as hard as we did, but also tried to play pass and move football, and that is the difference here.

I commend the effort but that is sadly not enough to get promoted. As has been brutally highlighted.

There is absolutely no shame in admitting that for whatever reason ‘effort’ in this case wasn’t enough. We didn’t have the footballing nous to win the tie and they did.

---

Boring wanker. Where are you when we actually win games? I remember you throwing a hissy fit after we lost to Fulham in the league then you vanished after we won the next few games

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by City123

Rosenior summed it up pretty well, there was only one winner had it gone to extra time and they weren't in white shirts

Fulham were rattled and knew they got away with it, you could tell by their reaction at the end

---

I've enjoyed Rosenior's and McAnuff's questions and verdicts, pre and post match.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Madassa

Thinly veiled praise is the worst of all compliments you 2 faced barsteward ��

---

Wind your neck in, dipshit. How the **** is that two-faced?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by LeningradCowboy

I doubt that there will be many teams willing to pay a transfer fee for him with less than 12 months left of his contract. The time to cash in was last summer when his stock was high.

---

You are right of course.

But at that time Smithies hadn’t really established himself as such a good keeper here had he? I don’t think anyway.

So the stars weren’t perfectly aligned. Still, a nice ‘problem’ to have I suppose. 👍

You seem to track my movements on here quite closely ;-)

We are just talking about football.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by City123

We'd get something for him, he's a good goalkeeper

The ones I'd be worried about being able to move on are Pack and Flint

---

His distribution is poor. I doubt that he would be first choice for any Championship team realistically aiming for promotion next season. Perhaps Warnock will want him at Middlesbrough.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Bluebirdman Of Alcathays

Although I wouldn't have put it like Mr Dandruff has, I think he has a point. We have something about us but not enough (yet). First half I was bored which is partly why the second half was such a revelation (and great to see).

A few people saying they prefer the championship - in a way that means we'd fall short every year which is not something I'd like to see cos I think we're bigger and potentially better than that and if we do go up again I would want us to avoid relegation and play some decent football while we're at it, which means progressing a fair bit further from where we are. So, really encouraging in parts tonight but also work to be done.

---

I agree with nearly all of that. 👍

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by LeningradCowboy

His distribution is poor. I doubt that he would be first choice for any Championship team realistically aiming for promotion next season. Perhaps Warnock will want him at Middlesbrough.

---

And he can take Flint with him!

(And Pack and Whyte)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Bobby Dandruff

You are right of course.

But at that time Smithies hadn’t really established himself as such a good keeper here had he? I don’t think anyway.

So the stars weren’t perfectly aligned. Still, a nice ‘problem’ to have I suppose. 👍

---

We paid £4m for Smithies and made him the highest paid (non-loan) player at the club. It was a bit of an odd thing to do if we didn't think that he is a good keeper.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by 2b2bdoo

Great effort second half, sadly it just shows how wrong the starting 11 was, in the end that cost us.

---

Dont you think that Harris knew that he couldn't get a full game out of Tomlin, so he planned to bring him and NML on at half time, i think he got the tactic spot on, it very nearly worked.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by cityhammer

Dont you think that Harris knew that he couldn't get a full game out of Tomlin, so he planned to bring him and NML on at half time, i think he got the tactic spot on, it very nearly worked.

---

Absolutely. Had Tomlin stayed on I reckon we'd have got another goal. Then he'd have been fit enough for extra time.

How come nobody can have an opinion on here without being subjected to abuse from an opposing point of view. It's a messageboard ffs

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Eric the Half a Bee

Absolutely. Had Tomlin stayed on I reckon we'd have got another goal. Then he'd have been fit enough for extra time.

---

Bennett's piss poor pass :angry:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Maxim

To be honest i perfer the championship.

---

I agree, if only
the coverage was as good as the prem around the world.
Anyway pride restored, well done city!!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Joe Gillis

How come nobody can have an opinion on here without being subjected to abuse from an opposing point of view. It's a messageboard ffs

---

**** off arsehole

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Eric the Half a Bee

Absolutely. Had Tomlin stayed on I reckon we'd have got another goal. Then he'd have been fit enough for extra time.

---

We were all over them in the second half until the drinks break, but we didn't create many chances after that, even when Tomlin was still on the pitch, did we?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by LeningradCowboy

We were all over them in the second half until the drinks break, but we didn't create many chances after that, even when Tomlin was still on the pitch, did we?

---

Glatzel chance last minute.

Vaulks shot well saved.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by LeningradCowboy

We were all over them in the second half until the drinks break, but we didn't create many chances after that, even when Tomlin was still on the pitch, did we?

---

Are you suggesting we should have created more chances after Tomlin went off?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by 2b2bdoo

Pack is my issue, as I've said elsewhere we have been playing well with a pressing midfield with lots of energy until Harris decided Pack was his new little pet.
Pack goes off at HT and we instantly starting winning the ball more in midfield and pressing like we had so often after lock down.

---

Pack is shot, gone! Hopefully, a League One club will come in for him.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by LeningradCowboy

We paid £4m for Smithies and made him the highest paid (non-loan) player at the club. It was a bit of an odd thing to do if we didn't think that he is a good keeper.

---

Were you at Gillingham for the FA Cup game?

Smithies was a known quantity when he arrived (ask any QPR fan). I don’t think that we paid £4m for him though.

He started slowly though (probably not his fault) and now we have 2 keepers capable of playing regularly in the 1st team which is a bit of a luxury when we clearly have issues outfield 🤷*♂️

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Bobby Dandruff

Were you at Gillingham for the FA Cup game?

Smithies was a known quantity when he arrived (ask any QPR fan). I don’t think that we paid £4m for him though.

He started slowly though (probably not his fault) and now we have 2 keepers capable of playing regularly in the 1st team which is a bit of a luxury when we clearly have issues outfield ��*♂️

---

Sky comms noted that we have "the best 1&2 keepers in the division"
That's not to say either of them are THE best keeper, but we have the best two when it comes to 1st choice and backup.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Bobby Dandruff

Were you at Gillingham for the FA Cup game?

Smithies was a known quantity when he arrived (ask any QPR fan). I don’t think that we paid £4m for him though.

He started slowly though (probably not his fault) and now we have 2 keepers capable of playing regularly in the 1st team which is a bit of a luxury when we clearly have issues outfield ��*♂️

---

But we need two keepers of that quality, it's a 46+ game season. If Smithies gets injured who would we turn to? Day had a mare at Wigan. The goalkeeping area is one where we are strong, why weaken it?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by City123

We'd get something for him, he's a good goalkeeper

The ones I'd be worried about being able to move on are Pack and Flint

---

I think your sentence is an un-intended double entendre - quite good though.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by cityhammer

Dont you think that Harris knew that he couldn't get a full game out of Tomlin, so he planned to bring him and NML on at half time, i think he got the tactic spot on, it very nearly worked.

---

If that's the case bring in Sanderson and move Bacuna to midfield ahead of pack. It's obvious we needed the energy in midfield.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by MacAdder

Was it about us? :sherlock:

---

I think written with a touch of irony..

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Des Parrot

But we need two keepers of that quality, it's a 46+ game season. If Smithies gets injured who would we turn to? Day had a mare at Wigan. The goalkeeping area is one where we are strong, why weaken it?

---

Maybe to strengthen elsewhere?

It is just a thought, but with resources being tight it is the manager's job to allocate the available resources to maximum effect - is having 2 first team keepers sensible when other parts of the team need addressing?

(don't get me wrong - it would be GREAT to have two first team players available for every position, as we do for the gk postion, as Chelsea did when Mourinho built his first squad! Can you imagine that?! :thumbup: )

It’s looks what swings it. According to Mick McCarthy, Watkins’ good looks dazzled the Jack defenders. He was too pretty for them. So, when I saw Patterson come on, I knew the game was lost.