-
Electric Cars are the future…..my arse !!
My sister who is definitely in the NIMBY brigade has been banging on to me for the last few years to buy an electric car
I actually borrowed hers which she actually leases at the cost of a family mortgage may I add for the weekend just gone
From my own experience and I couldn’t have done anything differently,why anyone would bother buying one is a total mystery.
The biggest negative is pulling into the services with your range showing 30 miles and there’s only two charging points
Both are in use and there’s two cars waiting in front of you
To top it off you’re only allowed a two hour stay or get a parking eye fine - madness!!
A run to the same destination in my diesel would normally take two and a half hours
It took just over six hours and a load of STRESS plus I’m waiting for my sister to pull me on her having received a fine
The other irritation is pulling into a garage and the charging point is out of order which happened twice plus not knowing exactly how much the charge has cost you because you need to retrieve information from the app
The other annoyance were pedestrians walking into the road - I’m not blaming them because you cannot hear any engine noise
The car was beautiful and great to drive an experience I’m glad I had
But buy one?
Not a chance
Actually doing a bit of google research if you are one of those “keep your carbon footprint down and all that” to manufacture an EV. Is worse environmentally.
I’m sure she said she’s paying £1100 a month on a two year lease
I think sitting on top of a battery has done some damage to her brain lol 😂
Definitely a NO from me for Electric being the thing of the future 🤔😂
-
Re: Electric Cars are the future…..my arse !!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Sunnysideup
My sister who is definitely in the NIMBY brigade has been banging on to me for the last few years to buy an electric car
I actually borrowed hers which she actually leases at the cost of a family mortgage may I add for the weekend just gone
From my own experience and I couldn’t have done anything differently,why anyone would bother buying one is a total mystery.
The biggest negative is pulling into the services with your range showing 30 miles and there’s only two charging points
Both are in use and there’s two cars waiting in front of you
To top it off you’re only allowed a two hour stay or get a parking eye fine - madness!!
A run to the same destination in my diesel would normally take two and a half hours
It took just over six hours and a load of STRESS plus I’m waiting for my sister to pull me on her having received a fine
The other irritation is pulling into a garage and the charging point is out of order which happened twice plus not knowing exactly how much the charge has cost you because you need to retrieve information from the app
The other annoyance were pedestrians walking into the road - I’m not blaming them because you cannot hear any engine noise
The car was beautiful and great to drive an experience I’m glad I had
But buy one?
Not a chance
Actually doing a bit of google research if you are one of those “keep your carbon footprint down and all that” to manufacture an EV. Is worse environmentally.
I’m sure she said she’s paying £1100 a month on a two year lease
I think sitting on top of a battery has done some damage to her brain lol 😂
Definitely a NO from me for Electric being the thing of the future 🤔😂
I've always wondered why electric cars don't do battery swaps instead of charging.
Nio produces electric cars and battery swap infrastructure in China which seems pretty good -
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=oTXptUuKGrc
-
Re: Electric Cars are the future…..my arse !!
One thing for sure, if and when electric cars become 'mainstream', they won't be any cheaper to run than diesel/unleaded. The loss of revenue from fuel tax will ensure whopping taxes on new electric vehicles..
-
Re: Electric Cars are the future…..my arse !!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
A Quiet Monkfish
One thing for sure, if and when electric cars become 'mainstream', they won't be any cheaper to run than diesel/unleaded. The loss of revenue from fuel tax will ensure whopping taxes on new electric vehicles..
How are you going to recharge all of these electric cars with with windmills and solar panels? I think the simple answer is most people won't have cars.
-
Re: Electric Cars are the future…..my arse !!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
A Quiet Monkfish
One thing for sure, if and when electric cars become 'mainstream', they won't be any cheaper to run than diesel/unleaded. The loss of revenue from fuel tax will ensure whopping taxes on new electric vehicles..
no, it's a bit more complicated than that.
petrol products are usually heavily taxed partially for their environmental impact, but mostly because for most countries that are net importers of oil, every time you fill up your tank it is money that is leaving the country probably to go into the middle east.
if it's an electric car, running off energy generated in the UK, the money stays washing around the UK economy, and therefore it'll make its way to the tax man in one way or another anyway before long.
-
Re: Electric Cars are the future…..my arse !!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Sunnysideup
My sister who is definitely in the NIMBY brigade has been banging on to me for the last few years to buy an electric car
I actually borrowed hers which she actually leases at the cost of a family mortgage may I add for the weekend just gone
From my own experience and I couldn’t have done anything differently,why anyone would bother buying one is a total mystery.
The biggest negative is pulling into the services with your range showing 30 miles and there’s only two charging points
Both are in use and there’s two cars waiting in front of you
To top it off you’re only allowed a two hour stay or get a parking eye fine - madness!!
A run to the same destination in my diesel would normally take two and a half hours
It took just over six hours and a load of STRESS plus I’m waiting for my sister to pull me on her having received a fine
The other irritation is pulling into a garage and the charging point is out of order which happened twice plus not knowing exactly how much the charge has cost you because you need to retrieve information from the app
The other annoyance were pedestrians walking into the road - I’m not blaming them because you cannot hear any engine noise
The car was beautiful and great to drive an experience I’m glad I had
But buy one?
Not a chance
Actually doing a bit of google research if you are one of those “keep your carbon footprint down and all that” to manufacture an EV. Is worse environmentally.
I’m sure she said she’s paying £1100 a month on a two year lease
I think sitting on top of a battery has done some damage to her brain lol
Definitely a NO from me for Electric being the thing of the future
so basically you didn't make sure you had enough charge before you set off?
-
Re: Electric Cars are the future…..my arse !!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Rjk
no, it's a bit more complicated than that.
petrol products are usually heavily taxed partially for their environmental impact, but mostly because for most countries that are net importers of oil, every time you fill up your tank it is money that is leaving the country probably to go into the middle east.
if it's an electric car, running off energy generated in the UK, the money stays washing around the UK economy, and therefore it'll make its way to the tax man in one way or another anyway before long.
Interesting you make a good point!
-
Re: Electric Cars are the future…..my arse !!
They do seem a pain at the moment. We've got fleet lease company cars in work and a few have gone full electric as its quite a saving on personal company car tax, not sure what the cost to actually lease them mind is as the company covers it.
Mines a hybrid which is great as the petrol is used mostly for motorways but around town and local use the cars hybrid system kicks in and uses hardly any fuel. Plus i don't have to mess around with charging stations and all that jazz.
I personally feel we're a good 2 decades away for everything to be fully electric as the infrastructure we have just dosn't support it. It will get there eventually but currently the cost of the vehicles and charging issues I would have to agree, balls to that.....for now.
-
Re: Electric Cars are the future…..my arse !!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Monster munch
They do seem a pain at the moment. We've got fleet lease company cars in work and a few have gone full electric as its quite a saving on personal company car tax, not sure what the cost to actually lease them mind is as the company covers it.
Mines a hybrid which is great as the petrol is used mostly for motorways but around town and local use the cars hybrid system kicks in and uses hardly any fuel. Plus i don't have to mess around with charging stations and all that jazz.
I personally feel we're a good 2 decades away for everything to be fully electric as the infrastructure we have just dosn't support it. It will get there eventually but currently the cost of the vehicles and charging issues I would have to agree, balls to that.....for now.
With this cost of living crisis, surely it will be delayed, can most countries afford to make the changes required by 2030?
RJK's point above is a good one mind, the quicker we can stop being held to ranson by the OPEC countries the better!
-
Re: Electric Cars are the future…..my arse !!
FAO RJK
Soz don’t know how to highlight captions
No my sister made sure the car was full of charge when I collected it
She said range is approximately 300 miles but that’s changeable depending on how fast you drive and air conditioning etc
Thing was not being used to driving an EV I didn’t want to go too far without topping back up
When range got to 40-60 miles I was conscious of looking for a garage
Half an hour plugged in would give up to 80% charge but this was only at certain manufacturers points
Others would take longer
Was all a bit confusing tbh
Also I didn’t have the charger at home that she does which actually takes 13 hours to charge to 100 %
All a bit much
EV’s are definitely OFF my shopping list
To much hassle
-
Re: Electric Cars are the future…..my arse !!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Sunnysideup
FAO RJK
Soz don’t know how to highlight captions
No my sister made sure the car was full of charge when I collected it
She said range is approximately 300 miles but that’s changeable depending on how fast you drive and air conditioning etc
Thing was not being used to driving an EV I didn’t want to go too far without topping back up
When range got to 40-60 miles I was conscious of looking for a garage
Half an hour plugged in would give up to 80% charge but this was only at certain manufacturers points
Others would take longer
Was all a bit confusing tbh
Also I didn’t have the charger at home that she does which actually takes 13 hours to charge to 100 %
All a bit much
EV’s are definitely OFF my shopping list
To much hassle
Mine too, considered a Tesla on salary sacrifice, not worth it , glad I’ve bought a nice petrol speedster … 0-60 4.8 secs :hehe:
-
Re: Electric Cars are the future…..my arse !!
Electric cars are in their infancy. In 2011 there were 50k sold worldwide, in 2021 that number rose to nearly 7 million.
As they are, EVs aren’t for the average customer, they’re the premium product. The same way that in the 1930’s your average person wasn’t buying a motor vehicle but now in the UK there’s over 30million registered cars. That’s about 1 car for every 2 people.
-
Re: Electric Cars are the future…..my arse !!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Canton Kev
Electric cars are in their infancy. In 2011 there were 50k sold worldwide, in 2021 that number rose to nearly 7 million.
As they are, EVs aren’t for the average customer, they’re the premium product. The same way that in the 1930’s your average person wasn’t buying a motor vehicle but now in the UK there’s over 30million registered cars. That’s about 1 car for every 2 people.
They need to have two batteries within the vehicle, with one charging as you drive. Electric charge points are no good.
-
Re: Electric Cars are the future…..my arse !!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
TWGL1
They need to have two batteries within the vehicle, with one charging as you drive. Electric charge points are no good.
:facepalm:
-
Re: Electric Cars are the future…..my arse !!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Rjk
:facepalm:
Why isn’t that a viable option?
They will make the batteries smaller. It’s not new tech, it’s been around since the 30’s
How much green belt will be used to accommodate mass usage charge points , not viable
-
Re: Electric Cars are the future…..my arse !!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
TWGL1
Why isn’t that a viable option?
They will make the batteries smaller. It’s not new tech, it’s been around since the 30’s
How much green belt will be used to accommodate mass usage charge points , not viable
Batteries are heavy and big. As technology advances they’ll get lighter and smaller and more efficient. Either to a point where having 2 batteries will be a viable solution or the batteries will be good enough not to require a second one.
Mainstream consumer electric cars are about a decade old. Regular cars are over a century old.
-
Re: Electric Cars are the future…..my arse !!
its ok sunny the leader of the free world just wants a little more time 3035 to be precise :hehe:
<blockquote class="twitter-tweet"><p lang="en" dir="ltr">Going all electric by 3035. <a href="https://t.co/dWaDqO0TOC">pic.twitter.com/dWaDqO0TOC</a></p>— Real Mac Report (@RealMacReport) <a href="https://twitter.com/RealMacReport/status/1588626140008439810?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">November 4, 2022</a></blockquote> <script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>
-
Re: Electric Cars are the future…..my arse !!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Canton Kev
Batteries are heavy and big. As technology advances they’ll get lighter and smaller and more efficient. Either to a point where having 2 batteries will be a viable solution or the batteries will be good enough not to require a second one.
Mainstream consumer electric cars are about a decade old. Regular cars are over a century old.
Anybody know why they got rid of the electric tram system within Cardiff over 50:years ago :hehe:
Following on from the original thread , before electric cars become mainstream they have to decarbonise the National Grid first , which kind of delays things , I know that from meetings I’ve held.
https://www.nationalgrid.com/respons...sing-transport
They may need longer than 2035 :hehe:
-
Re: Electric Cars are the future…..my arse !!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
TWGL1
How much green belt will be used to accommodate mass usage charge points , not viable
What a bizarre thing to say.
-
Re: Electric Cars are the future…..my arse !!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Doucas
What a bizarre thing to say.
Have a think about how they are going to have to construct massive charging areas using the current system , it’s not viable unless they undertake huge changes in infrastructure…. Underground cables etc
Dickhead, clearly you know fcuk all Cyril
-
Re: Electric Cars are the future…..my arse !!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
TWGL1
Have a think about how they are going to have to construct massive charging areas using the current system , it’s not viable unless they undertake huge changes in infrastructure…. Underground cables etc
Dickhead, clearly you know fcuk all Cyril
Further decarbonisation costs …. And this is what they are telling you so you can guarantee it will be double the cost / time
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-63514562
-
Re: Electric Cars are the future…..my arse !!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
TWGL1
They need to have two batteries within the vehicle, with one charging as you drive. Electric charge points are no good.
so what's charging the second battery while you are driving?
-
Re: Electric Cars are the future…..my arse !!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Rjk
so what's charging the second battery while you are driving?
Hybrid Charge within the vehicle
-
Re: Electric Cars are the future…..my arse !!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
TWGL1
Hybrid Charge within the vehicle
so you're running a petrol engine to charge one battery while using the other one to drive the car?!
I'm not sure you've thought this through
-
Re: Electric Cars are the future…..my arse !!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Rjk
so you're running a petrol engine to charge one battery while using the other one to drive the car?!
I'm not sure you've thought this through
I have indeed , no petrol involved, hybrid as in two separate power generators charging at different times one for output one for input
If you don’t think this is feasible have a day off
The additional power source will be self generating off each source
It’s only a matter of time as to when the battery is half the size ( saving energy, weight tyre wear etc) with twice or three times the distance
-
Re: Electric Cars are the future…..my arse !!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
TWGL1
I have indeed , no petrol involved, hybrid as in two separate power generators charging at different times one for output one for input
If you don’t think this is feasible have a day off
The additional power source will be self generating off each source
It’s only a matter of time as to when the battery is half the size ( saving energy, weight tyre wear etc) with twice or three times the distance
:facepalm: :facepalm:
so one battery is charging the other battery while it is also driving the motors?
even if batteries were 100% efficient there would be no point in doing this. the fact is that they aren't 100% efficient so you're pointlessly wasting charge and having to pay for 2 batteries.
congratulations you just designed a more expensive electric car that has significantly worse performance.
-
Re: Electric Cars are the future…..my arse !!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
TWGL1
Anybody know why they got rid of the electric tram system within Cardiff over 50:years ago :hehe:
Following on from the original thread , before electric cars become mainstream they have to decarbonise the National Grid first , which kind of delays things , I know that from meetings I’ve held.
https://www.nationalgrid.com/respons...sing-transport
They may need longer than 2035 :hehe:
I’m pretty sure those electric trams were powered by a great big coal factory spewing out aerosolised lung damage.
-
Re: Electric Cars are the future…..my arse !!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Rjk
:facepalm: :facepalm:
so one battery is charging the other battery while it is also driving the motors?
even if batteries were 100% efficient there would be no point in doing this. the fact is that they aren't 100% efficient so you're pointlessly wasting charge and having to pay for 2 batteries.
congratulations you just designed a more expensive electric car that has significantly worse performance.
Expensive for now … like everything the costs will come down especially when they decrease in size ( which they will )
-
Re: Electric Cars are the future…..my arse !!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Canton Kev
I’m pretty sure those electric trams were powered by a great big coal factory spewing out aerosolised lung damage.
Like in China at the moment ?
-
Re: Electric Cars are the future…..my arse !!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
TWGL1
Like in China at the moment ?
China are making impressive progress in becoming carbon neutral tbh to their plans to get there are probably more feasible than ours
-
Re: Electric Cars are the future…..my arse !!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
TWGL1
Expensive for now … like everything the costs will come down especially when they decrease in size ( which they will )
yes but fundamentally the idea makes no sense
-
Re: Electric Cars are the future…..my arse !!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Rjk
yes but fundamentally the idea makes no sense
Fundamentally the whole electric rollout makes no sense by the time you take into account the carbon footprint of the battery, not forgetting you still have to charge the thing.
The only country that will benefit at the moment would be Iceland as a large percentage of their power is generated by Geo Thermal.
-
Re: Electric Cars are the future…..my arse !!
Poor old Sleepy Joe lol 3035
Bring back Trump 😆😆😆
-
Re: Electric Cars are the future…..my arse !!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
TWGL1
Fundamentally the whole electric rollout makes no sense by the time you take into account the carbon footprint of the battery, not forgetting you still have to charge the thing.
The only country that will benefit at the moment would be Iceland as a large percentage of their power is generated by Geo Thermal.
don't worry about that, let's hear more about your 2 battery car idea
-
Re: Electric Cars are the future…..my arse !!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Rjk
don't worry about that, let's hear more about your 2 battery car idea
I’ve told you what I think about it, and what’s your alternative solution, apart from sidestepping the issues I’ve raised because so far you have contributed nothing of note.
-
Re: Electric Cars are the future…..my arse !!
Unbelievably the mining of Lithium actually makes the carbon footprint of the manufacture of the EV four times more than that of a petrol or diesel car
Then there’s the added problem of battery disposal at the end of their life
The problem people are overlooking is the second hand value of an Electric Vehicle
With petrol or diesel a hundred thousand miles is common- what’s the expected battery life of an EV ?
A little online research and manufacture’s are quoting depending on the make and model around £6-10,000 for a replacement battery
For me they are a fortune to buy new and leasing is expensive
The cost of charging has increased significantly making it not as attractive a proposition
The infrastructure is in its infancy leaving the driver frustrated as hell in finding an empty charging point at any motorway service
I borrowed my sisters EV on her insistence for the experience
I couldn’t wait to give it back 😫👍
-
Re: Electric Cars are the future…..my arse !!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
TWGL1
Fundamentally the whole electric rollout makes no sense by the time you take into account the carbon footprint of the battery.
It's not supposed to make any sense, it's psychological warfare! :biggrin:
-
Re: Electric Cars are the future…..my arse !!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
North Cardiff Blue
With this cost of living crisis, surely it will be delayed, can most countries afford to make the changes required by 2030?
RJK's point above is a good one mind, the quicker we can stop being held to ranson by the OPEC countries the better!
It won't be delayed. The plan is to make you and everybody else poor, and dependent on the government.
-
Re: Electric Cars are the future…..my arse !!
I've got a hybrid it's a different driving experience has saved me money with benefits in kind .
Especially with Drakefords 20mph limit as the beast self charges at that speed via the automatic gear box..
I think folk need to think about leasing,especially with battery life and hi tech software in these cars .
-
Re: Electric Cars are the future…..my arse !!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Wales-Bales
It won't be delayed. The plan is to make you and everybody else poor, and dependent on the government.
Aye, and it's becoming more plain by the day the primary mechanism to ensure just that is to drive the price of oil through the roof by a manufactured scarcity.