Poor performance, poor football....but, we have one of the poorest goalies I have seen playing for Cardiff City
Printable View
Poor performance, poor football....but, we have one of the poorest goalies I have seen playing for Cardiff City
not his fault, shit defending!
Should have saved it should have kept hold of it.Quote:
Originally Posted by Taffy Blue in Berkshire
Should have, but I wouldn't call it a howler. It would have been nice if we could have created something at the other end.Quote:
Originally Posted by Whisperer
Grrr .. Etheridge, not getting forward enough, hardly in their face, and not even trying to score.
Grrr..
He's poor, yes. Fortunately he's been well protected until recently.Quote:
Originally Posted by ksbenchpwllheli
He didn't get one shot on target! The sooner Camp is fit and ready the better. Errr.....
shit keeper, hasnt got a clue. get rid in january
The best we could have hoped for from that game was a point and we failed to get it
Etheridge should have saved it although I think it's a bit harsh to say he's one of our worst keepers.
Frank Parsons holds that honour, never to be beaten.Quote:
Originally Posted by Blue blood
I've been saying for months Etheridge is crap. Mistake for goal though his distribution is awful. Murphy must start Monday.
Did the GK solely lose it for us tonight or through the last week?
He’s useless.
Maxwell on the other hand was a good, assured keeper who could actually kick the fecking ball straight.
fcking butter fingersQuote:
Originally Posted by Whisperer
11 men lost that game / failed to win it. Not one.
Silly comment. Four games ago, we were averaging well over 2 points a game and had the best defensive record in the league, all with Etheridge in goal. The difference now is that Morrison is out and defensively midfield is playing badly. Easy way out is to blame the keeper. Dropping him will make no difference. Constant criticism wont help him either.Quote:
Originally Posted by ksbenchpwllheli
Too easy to blame the keeper, our defence were standing still and Bogle completely failed in his attempt to clear
I got shot down a few months ago for saying he's ****ing shite but I actually think I was being kind
Warnock says in is post match interview Sloppy goal but keeper should have saved it.
The ball came straight at Etheridge; it bounced off his chest back into play. On Talksport this morning Warnock stated that Preston's goal was down to goalkeeper error or to be more precise Etheridge could have done better for their goal. I make no comment about whether Etheridge should be replaced but let's not hide the fact that he was a contributory factor in last night's defeat
I think it’s a bit unfair to have a go at Etheridge. Our season so far has been based on a great team effort. This was a poor collective performance.
I agree but you need your keeper to earn you a few points over a season and keepers like Marshall or Paddy Kenny would have got us a point out of that game.Quote:
Originally Posted by Barry Shitpeas
Surprise surprise Warnock says nothing about Peltier losing his man for goal. The guy even fell to the floor and still got up to get 5 yards in front of Peltier to score!
What about that Dimi bloke, he must be in with a shoutQuote:
Originally Posted by ksbenchpwllheli
Bywater as wellQuote:
Originally Posted by blue matt
I dont think he is the worse keeper , however I dont think he inspires confidence in his defenders ,which is causing uncertainty and panic in their decision resulting in needless corners and split saves , the number of times we kick our in blind panic because of a split ball is telling, I would play Camp or secure a chopsy keeper who can distribute ,love to have McGregor back
I think he'll change the goalkeeper for the QPR game, but will he play Murphy or Camp? I'm not sure if Camp is fit yet.
Camp played for the development team recently so presumably fit? If so, then I'd put him for QPR
Has Peter Zois been erased from our memories?
Claiming Zois is the worst keeper we've had is ridiculously unfair imo.Quote:
Originally Posted by splott parker
Joined the afternoon of the game - zero training time with the rest of the squad. Thrown straight into a match when we had a ridiculously lousy defence.
Did he make mistakes? Sure. He also made several good one on one blocks as our defence gave him zero help whatsoever.
Throwing an 18 yr old kid out there with zeor experience, zero chemistry with his "defence" doesn't make him our worst ever keeper by a country mile.
Night game so had to run for the train so missed it..
Their keeper was awful at kicking, worse than etheridge in fact..
He's been good enough for us this season, but my god I got frustrated time after time when we had players to release quick up the field and instead of a big quick throw he would insist on holding on to it allowing them to organise before kicking.
Don't think it's fair to bash him though.
He was 20👍Quote:
Originally Posted by ccfc_is_my_life
Yup, not sure why I thoguht he was 18... either way, the points still stand. He had a whopping 1 game ( non-league ) before being thrown under the bus.Quote:
Originally Posted by splott parker
For those who have hammered Neil Etheridge for his kicking - have you watched John Ruddy belting it out of play countless times at Ashton Gate?
It doesn't make Etheridge a better kicker - or keeper (although I think he has done OK so far) - but it is an interesting comparison.
Agent Dimi. The Chinese defective playing in front of him. Solid
I dont thinking as awful as people make out.Quote:
Originally Posted by jon1959
Their keeper last night was far worse for example.
Just frustrated me when we could have broke quickly and he's holding on to the ball like it's a new born baby
At least Camp would have wasted more time...he’s the champ..Quote:
Originally Posted by jon1959