-
Rate your top six Football commentators pundits
Keene
Neville (Gary obviously)
Souness
Carragher
Shearer
Richards
If we could get the top four on super sunday every week it would be brilliant, they are the best and work well together.
-
Re: Rate your top six Football commentators pundits
Quote:
Originally Posted by
North Cardiff Blue
Keene
Neville (Gary obviously)
Souness
Carragher
Shearer
Richards
If we could get the top four on super sunday every week it would be brilliant, they are the best and work well together.
Alex Scott
Jacqui Oatly
Gabby Logan
Robyn Cowen
Lucy Ward
Andy Gray
👍
-
Re: Rate your top six Football commentators pundits
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Nobody's Rep
Alex Scott
Jacqui Oatly
Gabby Logan
Robyn Cowen
Lucy Ward
Andy Gray
Andy Gray :hehe:
-
Re: Rate your top six Football commentators pundits
They're all boring and they don't really give a ****, it's an act. I love some of the forced outrage and anger.
-
Re: Rate your top six Football commentators pundits
6??? 2 is hard enough. Have to admit enjoy Roy Keane after another Man U defeat.
Thought the Irish guy who used to do summerising on the Championship was good but cant remember his name. 😂
-
Re: Rate your top six Football commentators pundits
Googled him. Keith Andrews.
-
Re: Rate your top six Football commentators pundits
Jay Bothroyd
Clinton Morrison
Keane
Neville
Hoddle
Ashton
-
Re: Rate your top six Football commentators pundits
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Nobody's Rep
Alex Scott
Jacqui Oatly
Gabby Logan
Robyn Cowen
Lucy Ward
Andy Gray
��
:fingers: (I'm sure there used to be one!)
-
Re: Rate your top six Football commentators pundits
I always thought that Mark Aizlewood was a decent pundit.
He's moved on from that now.
-
Re: Rate your top six Football commentators pundits
Quote:
Originally Posted by
The Bloop
I always thought that Mark Aizlewood was a decent pundit.
He's moved on from that now.
Clinton Morrison is 😎
-
Re: Rate your top six Football commentators pundits
I always think Pat Nevin speaks well, and gives some good insights.
If you watch the golf coverage on Sky the commentary team are on a different level to pretty much anyone in football. In the NFL Tony Romo is outstanding, highlights things you wouldn’t necessarily notice in a way that’s easy to understand.
-
Re: Rate your top six Football commentators pundits
Quote:
Originally Posted by
The Bloop
I always thought that Mark Aizlewood was a decent pundit.
He's moved on from that now.
Yes, it's a slightly unusual career progression to go from pundit to prison.
-
Re: Rate your top six Football commentators pundits
Quote:
Originally Posted by
North Cardiff Blue
Keene
Neville (Gary obviously)
Souness
Carragher
Shearer
Richards
If we could get the top four on super sunday every week it would be brilliant, they are the best and work well together.
NOT Karen Carney 🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬
-
Re: Rate your top six Football commentators pundits
Big Ron was the best until he went full Goslow
-
Re: Rate your top six Football commentators pundits
Quote:
Originally Posted by
J R Hartley
Big Ron was the best until he went full Goslow
Big Ron was very good.
-
Re: Rate your top six Football commentators pundits
Souness , Fat Scouse Atkinson , Keane all crap and better off on sky where most of the audience are over weight idiots who support Liverpool but live in Kent .
I bet they are all cross dressers those pundits , it's a dirty business .
-
Re: Rate your top six Football commentators pundits
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Tuerto
Big Ron was very good.
He was a fat busted flush
Too flash
-
Re: Rate your top six Football commentators pundits
Clinton Morrison
Michelle Owen
Alan Smith
Jayne Ludlow
Danny Gabbidon
Micah Richards
-
Re: Rate your top six Football commentators pundits
Not everyones cup of team but I always thought Craig Bellamy
gave great insights and explanations from his own experiences.
Laura Woods and Gabby Logan present and host the shows particularly well.
-
Re: Rate your top six Football commentators pundits
Micha Richards loves a laugh.
-
Re: Rate your top six Football commentators pundits
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Nobody's Rep
Alex Scott
Jacqui Oatly
Gabby Logan
Robyn Cowen
Lucy Ward
Andy Gray
👍
You missed Vicki Sparks on 5live. Awful presenter, tries way too hard.
I find the Cardiff City TV commentators to be a bit dull.
-
Re: Rate your top six Football commentators pundits
Ken Wolstenholme
Hugh Johns
Idwal Robling
Gerald Sinstadt
Brian Moore
-
Re: Rate your top six Football commentators pundits
3 votes for Clinton Morrison??!!!
🙄😱🤦*♂️🤦*♂️🤦*♂️
-
Re: Rate your top six Football commentators pundits
Jobi Mcanuff is decent. Liam Rosenior is also very good, but doesnt do as much pundit work since he went into coaching with Derby.
-
Re: Rate your top six Football commentators pundits
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Bobby Dandruff
3 votes for Clinton Morrison??!!!
*♂️*♂️*♂️
Make that 4, hes very knowledgeable and does his research. Yeah he talks a bit mandem but if you can understand what hes saying hes actually pretty good.
-
Re: Rate your top six Football commentators pundits
Quote:
Originally Posted by
19bluebirds27
Not everyones cup of team but I always thought Craig Bellamy
gave great insights and explanations from his own experiences.
Laura Woods and Gabby Logan present and host the shows particularly well.
Agreed, Bellamy especially is brilliant :thumbup:
-
Re: Rate your top six Football commentators pundits
Bellamy was superb, sadly fell victim to the PC Brigade.
-
Re: Rate your top six Football commentators pundits
Lianne Sanderson
BLOODY AWFUL - that cockernee drawl
And its not anti black lesbian stuff - she's ruddy awful and I turn over whenever she's on
-
Re: Rate your top six Football commentators pundits
Quote:
Originally Posted by
J R Hartley
Make that 4, hes very knowledgeable and does his research. Yeah he talks a bit mandem but if you can understand what hes saying hes actually pretty good.
Wow - this topic shows up such a diverse range of opinions.
I think that he is absolutely appalling - a babbling, inarticulate idiot that offers zero insight, and with even worse diction. Just dreadful and ruins (for me) any game that he is on.
On a different note, aside from Neville, there are very few pundits that add anything for me personally, which is fine when they are in the studio as you can choose to watch before, after and at HT (I don't btw). However, not being able to chose an audio channel, like we were able to during the pandemic, is a huge oversight on the part of TV companies (that I pay a lot of money to every month) as there is no avoiding a co-commentator that you don't like. For example, having to watch a game with Karen Carney or Clinton Morrison for example on co-comms, completely spoils any game for me.
Especially when it would be so simple to offer alternative audio channels other than the mute button (which is a bit rubbish) :frown:
-
Re: Rate your top six Football commentators pundits
Quote:
Originally Posted by
J R Hartley
Jobi Mcanuff is decent. Liam Rosenior is also very good, but doesnt do as much pundit work since he went into coaching with Derby.
Liam Rosenior I lost all respect for when Greg Gunningham was the victim of an horrendous tackle I believe against Brighton. Ref gave a straight red and rightly so as hes lucky his leg wasnt snapped. Rosenior tried to argue it wasnt a red and Cunningham somehow was partly to blame.
Agree on McAnuff.
-
Re: Rate your top six Football commentators pundits
I usually agree with a lot of what Don Goodman says. And Lee Hendrie always does his research and doesn't just go along with the obvious narrative (which is surprising as he came across as a total knob when he was a player).
Gary Neville is good when he's not talking about United and I always like Slaven Bilic when he does World Cups or the Euros.
-
Re: Rate your top six Football commentators pundits
Clinton Morrison is hilarious, half the time I reckon he's stoned
The other day on 5 live there was a disturbance in the crowd and he said hey man what's going on everybody just needs to chill !
-
Re: Rate your top six Football commentators pundits
Ken Wolstenholme
Idwal Roblin
Barry Davies
Saint & Greavsie
John Motsom
-
Re: Rate your top six Football commentators pundits
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Cleve van Leef
Ken Wolstenholme
Idwal Roblin
Barry Davies
Saint & Greavsie
John Motsom
Idwal was crap
Watching Wales Scotland 1977 at a field on the box with my old man and mates
Pre match warm up
Dave Jones warming up
Idwal says ...." gosh dave Jones at centre back looks just like John toshack ! "
Fellow Commentator " er Idwal that is John Toshack "
-
Re: Rate your top six Football commentators pundits
In no particular order:
Bellamy
Ludlow
Keane
Carragher
Neville
Hoddle
-
Re: Rate your top six Football commentators pundits
Saint & Greavsie
Ludlow & Scott
Carragher & Bob Carolgees
-
Re: Rate your top six Football commentators pundits
Quote:
Originally Posted by
FormerlyJohnnyBreadhead
I usually agree with a lot of what Don Goodman says. And Lee Hendrie always does his research and doesn't just go along with the obvious narrative (which is surprising as he came across as a total knob when he was a player).
Gary Neville is good when he's not talking about United and I always like Slaven Bilic when he does World Cups or the Euros.
I agree with all of that - except I also think Gary Neville is good when he’s laying into Man U.
Not changing my top six though, and even more so after reading the Clinton Morrison knocking posts. Some people just don’t recognise genius when it’s right in front of them .
-
Re: Rate your top six Football commentators pundits
I can't tell if you're all joking about Clinton Morrison or not, bloke's dreadful
-
Re: Rate your top six Football commentators pundits
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Colin'sReversibleHat
I can't tell if you're all joking about Clinton Morrison or not, bloke's dreadful
He was only arksing:hehe:
-
Re: Rate your top six Football commentators pundits
I quite like Clinton Morrison.
Knows his stuff and has a GSOH.
Can't believe nobody has mentioned Bianca Westwood :yikes: