Penalty shout

Printable View

10-09-17, 19:02
Michael Morris

Penalty shout

90 + 4

https://youtu.be/CjgpJuYJRyU
10-09-17, 19:02
Nick

Penalty!!

How on earth can this not be a penalty?

https://m.youtube.com/watch?feature=...&v=CjgpJuYJRyU
10-09-17, 19:05
Sgt. Pepper

Re: Penalty!!

Stone wall.
10-09-17, 19:06
Sgt. Pepper

Re: Penalty shout

He was fouled in the box.
10-09-17, 19:07
Nick

Re: Penalty!!

If that was rugby the Fulham player would have been sent off for a dangerous top-tackle.
10-09-17, 19:09
jeepster

Re: Penalty!!

yes how can the officials not see that.
10-09-17, 19:10
Organ Morgan.

Re: Penalty!!

The giveaway that it wasn't a penalty is there were no appeals, never mind spontaneous ones, by players just yards from the incident.
10-09-17, 19:11
Nick

Re: Penalty!!

Quote:

Originally Posted by Organ Morgan.

The giveaway that it wasn't a penalty is there were no appeals, never mind spontaneous ones, by players just yards from the incident.

So, how was it not a penalty in your opinion?
10-09-17, 19:13
Pearcey3

Re: Penalty!!

Surely the thread title should read as 'Pelanty'
10-09-17, 19:15
jeepster

Re: Penalty!!

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pearcey3

Surely the thread title should read as 'Pelanty'

:biggrin:
10-09-17, 19:17
Fine Lines

Re: Penalty!!

If that happens middle of the pitch it be straight red. Cos it's in the box from a corner refs deem it as acceptable. Shocking.
10-09-17, 19:27
Baloo

Re: Penalty!!

If that had been a Wolves player they would have set-up a GOV.UK petition.
10-09-17, 19:27
Penarth Blues

Re: Penalty!!

If that was given as a penalty against us I'd have been disappointed. From a Fulham viewpoint they'd see it as the defender standing his ground as Morrison tried to climb past him (look at Sean grab him around the neck). The fall backwards is a bit dramatic but I don't think there's much in it really...
10-09-17, 19:28
Organ Morgan.

Re: Penalty!!

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nick

So, how was it not a penalty in your opinion?

It was a penalty box nothin' burger, half of one and half of the other and several other cliches I can't be bothered to type.
10-09-17, 19:29
Nick

Re: Penalty!!

Quote:

Originally Posted by Organ Morgan.

It was a penalty box nothin' burger, half of one and half of the other and several other cliches I can't be bothered to type.

OK, cheers for that.
10-09-17, 19:32
Organ Morgan.

Re: Penalty shout

Deffo a penalty. Morrison should sue him for assault. :hehe:
10-09-17, 19:39
Baloo

Re: Penalty!!

Quote:

Originally Posted by Penarth Blues

If that was given as a penalty against us I'd have been disappointed. From a Fulham viewpoint they'd see it as the defender standing his ground as Morrison tried to climb past him (look at Sean grab him around the neck). The fall backwards is a bit dramatic but I don't think there's much in it really...

It looked pretty clear-cut to me he was using his body to prevent Morrison reaching the ball. He looked at Morrison and made no attempt to to compete for the cross.
10-09-17, 19:42
Kris

Re: Penalty!!

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nick

So, how was it not a penalty in your opinion?

Simply because Morrison runs into the defender first. What happens afterwards is a direct result of that.
10-09-17, 19:43
Kris

Re: Penalty!!

Quote:

Originally Posted by Fine Lines

If that happens middle of the pitch it be straight red. Cos it's in the box from a corner refs deem it as acceptable. Shocking.

No it wouldn't have been.
10-09-17, 19:43
cardiff55

Re: Penalty!!

Morrison put his arm around the Fulham player's neck and pulled him on to him. Never a 'John Hartson Pelanty'. Mind you I would rather it had been given.
10-09-17, 19:43
Nick

Re: Penalty!!

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kris

Simply because Morrison runs into the defender first. What happens afterwards is a direct result of that.

Is he not allowed to run in to the defender?
10-09-17, 19:44
Penarth Blues

Re: Penalty!!

Quote:

Originally Posted by Baloo

It looked pretty clear-cut to me he was using his body to prevent Morrison reaching the ball. He looked at Morrison and made no attempt to to compete for the cross.

I don't disagree that by the letter of the law it's a foul but we see that sort of block all the time in the box. I was just of the opinion that we'd be disappointed if that had been given against us.
10-09-17, 19:50
Kris

Re: Penalty!!

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nick

Is he not allowed to run in to the defender?

He's allowed to, he's just not allowed to say it was a foul because he ran into him. The defender stood his ground, it's got a bit messier than these things usually do.
10-09-17, 19:53
Kris

Re: Penalty!!

Defender looks at Morrison, Morrison makes a move towards the ball. Morrison's arm comes across defender's neck and defender's arm goes around Morrisons back. Morrison's send hand is around the defender's face.

Defender has to look at Morrison, he needs to know who is in the vicinity as the cross comes in. The coming together is inevitable, but it's not a penalty.
10-09-17, 20:06
Blue in the Face

Re: Penalty!!

Glad this thread is here. It was the last action of the game and the very last action should have been a penalty. The ref was very poor.

Neil needs to have a word with our players. They should have been going nuts in protest. It looked as if no foul had happened because they didn't complain. OK they might not have the incident but they should have backed up our captain and at the least should have been whinging for the sake of match winning gamesmanship.

1-2 wouldn't have been an unfair scoreline.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Baloo

If that had been a Wolves player they would have set-up a GOV.UK petition.

:hehe: :hehe:
10-09-17, 22:11
TH63

Re: Penalty!!

Could've gone either way. Looking at the slow mo, it does appear that Morrison grabbed the defender around the neck and the defender pushed him away. Six of one, half a dozen of the other.
It wouldn't surprise me if it had been given, it not surprised it wasn't either
10-09-17, 22:14
BlueArmy 86

Re: Penalty!!

Quote:

Originally Posted by Baloo

If that had been a Wolves player they would have set-up a GOV.UK petition.

:hehe:

It's a penalty and 6 wins out of 6. If he doesn't foul him then Morrison rises above and buries that.
10-09-17, 22:23
Lawnmower

Re: Penalty!!

Quote:

Originally Posted by TH63

Could've gone either way. Looking at the slow mo, it does appear that Morrison grabbed the defender around the neck and the defender pushed him away. Six of one, half a dozen of the other.
It wouldn't surprise me if it had been given, it not surprised it wasn't either

I think this is right. The defender blocks Morrison (and the one behind appears to push him too), Morrison and defender 1 grab each other.

I think at this point they are either both fouling or neither is. Then the defender pulls him down, which is a definite foul.

It could have been given, but on the other hand Fulham had a shout for one at the other end minutes earlier so the ref probably gave them the benefit of the doubt.

No complaints overall, a draw was fair
10-09-17, 22:25
NYCBlue

Re: Penalty!!

It's a penalty. What ever actions Morrison took do not mitigate what the defender did.
11-09-17, 05:52
Lawnmower

Re: Penalty shout

Quote:

Originally Posted by Organ Morgan.

The giveaway that it wasn't a penalty is there were no appeals, never mind spontaneous ones, by players just yards from the incident.

Morrison appealed, but Fulham cleared quickly and he had to run back. At the final whistle he and several others were having a right rant at the ref
11-09-17, 06:54
MacAdder

Re: Penalty shout

A more blatant penalty you will never see!
No wonder our Neil was fuming in his post match interview :angry:
11-09-17, 08:10
blue matt

Re: Penalty shout

a bit of a rough and tough at the start, all it equal on that, nothing given, and rightly so

then the defender pushes him into the ground

Penalty 100% for me
11-09-17, 08:16
A Quiet Monkfish

Re: Penalty shout

Looked like Morrison threw himself backwards - no way a penalty in my opinion

All times are GMT. The time now is 13:55.