Warnock hates poor discipline. Madeley get it wrong?
Printable View
Warnock hates poor discipline. Madeley get it wrong?
Only saw it live at the CCS.... any footage of it?
Nathan Blake and Rob Phillips on Radio Wales both said it was a definite red! The referee definitely gave a few decisions to Cardiff, was the first a penalty? Despite this a good win today after a terrible first 25minutes!Quote:
Originally Posted by mbatte
TBF it was raining, those Brummies are used to it, I saw the weather on Peaky Blinders it was dead like today downpour and darkness , I was waiting for a Nick Cave song at half time.Quote:
Originally Posted by Ianto13
Warnock didn't complain.
In fact, I think there is a waxwork Warnock on the touchline....
You can see it here https://www.skysports.com/football/c.../report/409519 Can't argue with it being straight red
Definite red and not a bad thing Ward is out for a few games.
Makes us roll the dice
neither red cards were justified.....
Thought it was red in the ground, the reaction of the crowd was telling and the replay confirms it. Not sure why he gave the penalty in 1st half, not obvious from the Canton or the replay?
I bet Birmingham were sick going at HT 2-1 down, they battered us for 30 mins and should have been 3 or 4 up. They didn’t turn up in the 2nd half even after the red card, and we probably deserved the win 2nd half.
Both were definite reds, Ward went in with his feet off the ground and the Brum player led with a forearm smash!
I'm absolutely certain that the Ward sending off was a travesty of justice, and I haven't even seen it yet.
Pen was for a shirt pull was blatant from where I was in the ninianQuote:
Originally Posted by Stavross1927
Nasty challenge, red card all day long
Spot on i thought this could be a battering here,but what a turn around well deserved.:thumbup:
Shite tackle and the fans chanting his name after his stupid sending off were equally as stupid.
Ward should have got two reds for that tackle
I can see why the referee gave it but I think it was as much a fall/slip as deliberate.Quote:
Originally Posted by Joe Gillis
Yes, no Ward or Glatzel for the next2-3 weeksQuote:
Originally Posted by WJ99mobile
Omar it is time now to show how good you are.:thumbup:Quote:
Originally Posted by DubaiDai
Some of our players weren't being too clever when they kept sliding into tackles after the red card.
Can't really comment on Ward's as is was the other side of the pitc to me, but the brummie leapt in, leading with his elbow. Definite red.Quote:
Originally Posted by Maurice Swan
Both reds were justified, I thought so at the time, and have now seen them on the Quest highlights. The first penalty was for shirt pulling on Nelson so it seems. No appeal so thank goodness Ward can't play now, it will give Bogle a chance, and we'll have Madine on the bench I expect.
Both reds were right, but I'm not convinced about our first penalty or the disallowed Nelson goal.
A few debatable decisions, but the ref was pretty even handed with his calls.
Both reds were right & both penalties were right. Don't know why Nelsons goal was disallowed & they should have had a penalty for hand ball
Sky keep saying was for foul on flint but it wasn't,as Nelson jumped his shirt was pulled from behind, if they had TV angle from ninian side can see it's correct decisionQuote:
Originally Posted by cardiff55
It not only was poor but bloody stupid of him to dive in with both feet off the ground like that, no excusing that lack of professionalism in my view, could so easily have cost us 3 points.
We look better without Ward anyway, hopefully this gives Bogle or Paterson a real chance to show what they can do with a run of games
As clear and obvious red as you’ll see.Quote:
Originally Posted by AlwaysAway2
A really stupid tackle (was there something going on beforehand that caused him to react that way?) and you can see from the reaction of at least 5 Birmingham players that is was a really poor challenge.
Omar and Tomlin please.Quote:
Originally Posted by jeepster
It was a red card tackle. Of course, he could have got away with a yellow if the ref was feeling generous, but he gave a red and it would never be overturned.
I was surprised by our first penalty, but the ref had spoken to the defending players before the corner was taken because of they way they were pulling at our players. W hen the ball came in, one of them was clearly tugging a shirt. The reason I was surprised it was given was because we see it week in and week out and they are never given. Once that is given, when we are pulling shirts in their penalty area and we score, he has to be consistent and give them a free kick - chalking Nelson's 2nd off.Quote:
Originally Posted by jon1959
Abso-fecking-lutely!Quote:
Originally Posted by Llandaff Blue
Couldn't believe they were chanting his name at that moment in time.