Sheff Utd 5 City 1

Printable View

15-03-21, 21:45
alfie

Sheff Utd 5 City 1

Any of you old dogs remember this promotion game being on the radio. Im guessing it was not. The reason i say that is when the game was almost over i went around to the phone box as we did not have a phone to call the club for the score. When i got to the telephone box there were about 8-10 people waiting to use it.With that a guy came out and asked if any of us if we were phoning to find out the score. Everyone said yes and he told us th bad news.I think i cried myself to sleep that night.
15-03-21, 21:58
Cleve van Leef

Re: Sheff Utd 5 City 1

Remember it well. In the Masons Arms Whitchurch that night and we were all hovering around the phone trying to get some info. Bloody awful result.
15-03-21, 22:02
alfie

Re: Sheff Utd 5 City 1

If my memory serves me right wasnt Gil Reece playing for Sheff Utd then?
15-03-21, 22:19
rich munn

Re: Sheff Utd 5 City 1

Quote:

Originally Posted by alfie

If my memory serves me right wasnt Gil Reece playing for Sheff Utd then?

I was in school and there was a great absenteeism on Wednesday (it was sports day!) as so many went up to Sheffield by coach.

At 4-1 it was time to leave and go to the pub but we kids weren't allowed to by the leader of the Grange End mob, whose name now escapes me. Bearded fellow, didn't argue with him.

Got home about 4 a.m. and faced a school inquest next morning.

Gil Reece was brilliant that night, but when we signed him soon afterwards he was ....not so good. I have a feeling our goal was an og as well.

No wonder we are rather pessimistic supporters.

:ayatollah:
15-03-21, 23:08
Steve the Tea

Re: Sheff Utd 5 City 1

Quote:

Originally Posted by alfie

Any of you old dogs remember this promotion game being on the radio. Im guessing it was not. The reason i say that is when the game was almost over i went around to the phone box as we did not have a phone to call the club for the score. When i got to the telephone box there were about 8-10 people waiting to use it.With that a guy came out and asked if any of us if we were phoning to find out the score. Everyone said yes and he told us th bad news.I think i cried myself to sleep that night.

I was there. I travelled up to Sheffield on a special from Cardiff General. Sheffield had 6 shots and scored 5. It was unbelievable.

StT.
<><
16-03-21, 00:03
Former Labour leader

Re: Sheff Utd 5 City 1

Yes I was getting the scores via a phone box in Llandaff north.
Bad night.
16-03-21, 05:20
the other bob wilson

Re: Sheff Utd 5 City 1

Quote:

Originally Posted by alfie

If my memory serves me right wasnt Gil Reece playing for Sheff Utd then?

He scored one of their goals and, apparently, ran us ragged.

I tried to forget about the game by going to play five a side football in the old Dutch barn in Cantonian lower school - it didn't work!
16-03-21, 09:59
bobh

Re: Sheff Utd 5 City 1

Thanks for reminding me of this game :cry: :furious:
16-03-21, 10:57
splott parker

Re: Sheff Utd 5 City 1

Didn’t Steve Derrett score our goal?
16-03-21, 11:01
ksbenchpwllheli

Re: Sheff Utd 5 City 1

I was on that train as well,Steve the Tea. Sheffield seemed to score every time they attacked and passed us off the pitch. Game was played at a cricket ground!
16-03-21, 11:06
Moodybluebird

Re: Sheff Utd 5 City 1

When the score came up on the TV I was shellshocked and incredibly deflated. I really felt that we could do it but this result set the tone for many years to come.

I've heard from a few sources that we didn't play that badly, one of which is Steve Derrett, who scored for the City on the night.

Ironically we drew them away in the FA Cup the following season and beat them 3-1. That result instead of the 5-1 dribbling the year before would have seen us promoted.
16-03-21, 11:07
Moodybluebird

Re: Sheff Utd 5 City 1

Drubbing ! Bloody predictive text.
16-03-21, 11:11
the other bob wilson

Re: Sheff Utd 5 City 1

Quote:

Originally Posted by splott parker

Didn’t Steve Derrett score our goal?

He had a shot that was deflected in by Trevor Hockey - the Western Mail match report records the deflection, but gives the goal to Derrett, but, based on the research I did for the book, I think it tends to be shown as a Hockey own goal these days.
16-03-21, 11:34
Moodybluebird

Re: Sheff Utd 5 City 1

Quote:

Originally Posted by Steve the Tea

I was there. I travelled up to Sheffield on a special from Cardiff General. Sheffield had 6 shots and scored 5. It was unbelievable.

StT.
<><

Not too dissimilar then to the league game at home against the same opposition in 1977. Every time the ball went loose in the area they had a player available to slot it in and we got beaten 6-1. Typical City, we won the reverse fixture at their place 1-0.
16-03-21, 11:37
the other bob wilson

Re: Sheff Utd 5 City 1

Quote:

Originally Posted by Moodybluebird

Not too dissimilar then to the league game at home against the same opposition in 1977. Every time the ball went loose in the area they had a player available to slot it in and we got beaten 6-1. Typical City, we won the reverse fixture at their place 1-0.

We lost 6-3 at Bolton in our next game after the 1-6 against Sheffield United as well.
16-03-21, 11:43
cardiff55

Re: Sheff Utd 5 City 1

My second really big disappointment as City fan, just a few months after we sold Toshack. Steve Derrett scored our goal and there were nearly 43,000 fans there. Not sure if a train was run, but I was on a train the following season when we went back up there and won 3-1 in the FA Cup.
16-03-21, 12:31
Moodybluebird

Re: Sheff Utd 5 City 1

Quote:

Originally Posted by the other bob wilson

We lost 6-3 at Bolton in our next game after the 1-6 against Sheffield United as well.

And true to form we beat them in the reverse fixture.

Checking the results that season, we were incredibly inconsistent. Took some hidings and gave a few too. See we played Spurs at home in the league and had a crowd of under 9,000.
16-03-21, 13:07
Sloop_Jon_Bee

Re: Sheff Utd 5 City 1

Quote:

Originally Posted by Moodybluebird

And true to form we beat them in the reverse fixture.

Checking the results that season, we were incredibly inconsistent. Took some hidings and gave a few too. See we played Spurs at home in the league and had a crowd of under 9,000.

Yes we beat them 1-0. I am sure Bolton would have secured promotion with a win, but we spoilt the party as well as saving us from us going into relegation zone. Same season as the contentious loss at last game at home against Orient that sent Blackpool down.
Spedger
16-03-21, 13:33
Moodybluebird

Re: Sheff Utd 5 City 1

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sloop_Jon_Bee

Yes we beat them 1-0. I am sure Bolton would have secured promotion with a win, but we spoilt the party as well as saving us from us going into relegation zone. Same season as the contentious loss at last game at home against Orient that sent Blackpool down.
Spedger

I mentioned THAT game against Orient a few weeks ago on a Peter Kitchen thread. The dodgiest game I've seen in my 56 years of following the City.
16-03-21, 13:42
Bobby Dandruff

Re: Sheff Utd 5 City 1

Quote:

Originally Posted by alfie

Any of you old dogs remember this promotion game being on the radio. Im guessing it was not. The reason i say that is when the game was almost over i went around to the phone box as we did not have a phone to call the club for the score. When i got to the telephone box there were about 8-10 people waiting to use it.With that a guy came out and asked if any of us if we were phoning to find out the score. Everyone said yes and he told us th bad news.I think i cried myself to sleep that night.

I was only 7 years old at the time but I can vaguely recall being confused at how a team that was obviously decent (we were doing well) could lose so heavily. I really should move on!

And can you imagine phoning up to get the score! :yikes:

(I can vividly remember my Dad leaving the Cardiff City scores on a piece of paper outside my bedroom door so that I got them as soon as I woke up in the morning. I used to do the same for my boys. Cruel, I know! :biggrin:)
16-03-21, 13:44
Steve the Tea

Re: Sheff Utd 5 City 1

Quote:

Originally Posted by Moodybluebird

Not too dissimilar then to the league game at home against the same opposition in 1977. Every time the ball went loose in the area they had a player available to slot it in and we got beaten 6-1. Typical City, we won the reverse fixture at their place 1-0.

The following January (1972) we beat them 3-1 up there in the FA Cup R3. Saw that one, too. Why couldn't the scores have been reversed?

StT.
<><
16-03-21, 13:45
Bobby Dandruff

Re: Sheff Utd 5 City 1

Quote:

Originally Posted by Moodybluebird

When the score came up on the TV I was shellshocked and incredibly deflated. I really felt that we could do it but this result set the tone for many years to come.

I've heard from a few sources that we didn't play that badly, one of which is Steve Derrett, who scored for the City on the night.

Ironically we drew them away in the FA Cup the following season and beat them 3-1. That result instead of the 5-1 dribbling the year before would have seen us promoted.

It definitely was :cry:
16-03-21, 14:26
Dave Blue

Re: Sheff Utd 5 City 1

Quote:

Originally Posted by Moodybluebird

I mentioned THAT game against Orient a few weeks ago on a Peter Kitchen thread. The dodgiest game I've seen in my 56 years of following the City.

We were so bad I didn’t want us to score and send Orient down.
16-03-21, 16:21
BLUETIT

Re: Sheff Utd 5 City 1

Quote:

Originally Posted by ksbenchpwllheli

I was on that train as well,Steve the Tea. Sheffield seemed to score every time they attacked and passed us off the pitch. Game was played at a cricket ground!

The game was played at Bramall Lane, which you are correct, was a cricket ground at the time.

But it's the same ground Sheffield United, play at now.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bramall_Lane
16-03-21, 17:02
Moodybluebird

Re: Sheff Utd 5 City 1

Quote:

Originally Posted by Steve the Tea

The following January (1972) we beat them 3-1 up there in the FA Cup R3. Saw that one, too. Why couldn't the scores have been reversed?

StT.
<><

I've always wondered what a 3-sided ground felt like for atmosphere. Were there fans in the cricket stands too because they would have been a long way from the action ? Also did they have loads of ballboys to retrieve balls kicked onto the cricketing area ?
16-03-21, 17:09
BLUETIT

Re: Sheff Utd 5 City 1

Quote:

Originally Posted by Moodybluebird

I've always wondered what a 3-sided ground felt like for atmosphere. Were there fans in the cricket stands too because they would have been a long way from the action ? Also did they have loads of ballboys to retrieve balls kicked onto the cricketing area ?

Goalkeepers had bats :hehe:
16-03-21, 17:24
Majorblue

Re: Sheff Utd 5 City 1

I cannot remember there being a radio commentary but I do seem to remember there being a special score line telephone number you could ring .
Is my memory playing tricks or can anyone else remember the GPO (as was) providing that one off service for the game?
16-03-21, 17:28
life on mars

Re: Sheff Utd 5 City 1

Quote:

Originally Posted by Steve the Tea

I was there. I travelled up to Sheffield on a special from Cardiff General. Sheffield had 6 shots and scored 5. It was unbelievable.

StT.
<><

Gosh tough long round trip for you to witness
16-03-21, 17:48
BLUETIT

Re: Sheff Utd 5 City 1

Quote:

Originally Posted by Majorblue

I cannot remember there being a radio commentary but I do seem to remember there being a special score line telephone number you could ring .
Is my memory playing tricks or can anyone else remember the GPO (as was) providing that one off service for the game?

We used to phone the echo. Gotta be fair, they always answered, whatever the time
16-03-21, 19:01
splott parker

Re: Sheff Utd 5 City 1

The County Ground, Northampton was three sided, shared with the cricket as well.
16-03-21, 23:57
RonnieBird

Re: Sheff Utd 5 City 1

Quote:

Originally Posted by alfie

Any of you old dogs remember this promotion game being on the radio. Im guessing it was not. The reason i say that is when the game was almost over i went around to the phone box as we did not have a phone to call the club for the score. When i got to the telephone box there were about 8-10 people waiting to use it.With that a guy came out and asked if any of us if we were phoning to find out the score. Everyone said yes and he told us th bad news.I think i cried myself to sleep that night.

Yes there was a phone service with a recorded score for away games and I remember going down to a phone box and being very disappointed and surprised.
16-03-21, 23:58
RonnieBird

Re: Sheff Utd 5 City 1

Quote:

Originally Posted by Majorblue

I cannot remember there being a radio commentary but I do seem to remember there being a special score line telephone number you could ring .
Is my memory playing tricks or can anyone else remember the GPO (as was) providing that one off service for the game?

Quite right, but I don’t think it was a one off.
17-03-21, 01:01
Steve the Tea

Re: Sheff Utd 5 City 1

Quote:

Originally Posted by life on mars

Gosh tough long round trip for you to witness

The journey back to Cardiff was as long as it was silent. Then a long walk walk followed once in Cardiff.

StT.
<><

All times are GMT. The time now is 05:05.