Giggs - What mark would you give him out of 10 for wales?

And would you have him at Cardiff?

7 and no

7 and maybe in the future.

More than happy with Harris.

7 Yes.

Is he the best ex-footballer currently managing internationally?

6.5 and could do worse but also could do better

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Harry Paget Flashman

7 Yes.

Is he the best ex-footballer currently managing internationally?

---

Didier Deschamps is about the only I can think of to rival him.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by lardy

Didier Deschamps is about the only I can think of to rival him.

---

Southgate?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by lardy

Didier Deschamps is about the only I can think of to rival him.

---

Schevchenko was decent too.

Did say Zidane then saw internationally.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by lardy

Didier Deschamps is about the only I can think of to rival him.

---

Mancini and Enrique?

Luis Enrique and Mancini were both top players.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Harry Paget Flashman

7 Yes.

Is he the best ex-footballer currently managing internationally?

---

wait did you mean best as a player or best as a manager

7.5 and yes.

7.5 and yes. He's bold. I like that. And he would attract young players. City and Wales. It would work.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Rjk

wait did you mean best as a player or best as a manager

---

player

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by StraightOuttaCanton

Mancini and Enrique?

---

Both great players but not sure they are rivals to giggs. Deschamps is though.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by WJ99mobile

And would you have him at Cardiff?

---

No, his legs have gone.

8. He is doing well.

7 and yes.

He's won me over, as has Neil Harris.

First few games about a 3, recently a 7.

Wouldn't be too disappointed if he came here in the future but we'd have to be a premier league club for him to consider us.

9 for me and that’s only because of the shaky start.

Qualified for the Euros first campaign of asking whilst bringing through a stack of youngsters who haven’t even broke through at club level yet and without some of his key senior players for large parts of the campaign.

2 wins out of 2 in this international window.

Can’t ask anymore of him. He’s doing a fantastic job.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by J R Hartley

9 for me and that’s only because of the shaky start.

Qualified for the Euros first campaign of asking whilst bringing through a stack of youngsters who haven’t even broke through at club level yet and without some of his key senior players for large parts of the campaign.

2 wins out of 2 in this international window.

Can’t ask anymore of him. He’s doing a fantastic job.

---

Agree 9, he’s already got the best record of any Wales Manager and is blooding young players to strengthen our youngest ever Squad. Unfortunately Premier League owners will be chasing him if he keeps it up, would love him at City after winning the Euros and qualifying for the World Cup!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by WJ99mobile

And would you have him at Cardiff?

---

8 and yes he's s credit to his sport .

I really disliked Giggs as a Wales player. I hated it when he was appointed manager. I'm sure if you looked at my post history you would see these view.

However based on that back ground I would give him now 9/10. He is doing a brilliant job. He has moved us forward from Coleman. Qualified for tournaments and made us look a good team in the nations league.

He has won me over as one of his harshest critics.

8.5. Qualified, we play decent football and he's got us winning games we'd normally lose. These last 2 are classic examples, how often would we lose them in the past? Still got some way to go but definitely doing a cracking job.