If a Championship team signs a bunch of players from Non league, Scottish league, League One and League two, where should they expect to finish?

Asking for a friend :sherlock:

We’ll find out next season

Put another way. How many of the players we have released will play for a team that finishes above us next season?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Forgotmyoldaccount

Asking for a friend :sherlock:

---

How long is a piece of string?

I remember in 2006 us signing McPhail from a League 1 club, Roger Johnson from League 2 Wycombe, Loovens was an unknown at Feyenoord, Willo Flood an unknown at Man City, Chopra an unknown at Newcastle, McNaughton from Aberdeen. We were top 6 for most of the season.

Didn’t the players signed today come from teams in the championship and the Premier League. Either way it’s only June, will judge the team on how they play come the start of the season.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Forgotmyoldaccount

Asking for a friend :sherlock:

---

Throw in some loans and freebies plus some current Welsh internationals and I'd say top half.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by cyril evans awaydays

Put another way. How many of the players we have released will play for a team that finishes above us next season?

---

Josh Murphy, Premier League winner with Man City for one.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Forgotmyoldaccount

Asking for a friend :sherlock:

---

I'm trying to be positive because you never know. Back of my mind i'm not confident of staying up.
Have to See what the loan signings are like

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Eric the Half a Bee

How long is a piece of string?

I remember in 2006 us signing McPhail from a League 1 club, Roger Johnson from League 2 Wycombe, Loovens was an unknown at Feyenoord, Willo Flood an unknown at Man City, Chopra an unknown at Newcastle, McNaughton from Aberdeen. We were top 6 for most of the season.

---

Exactly, too much emphasis about where players are signing from. Luton signed a mixed bag of players (bit of a presumption on my part but they would've been on a tiny budget) and they did ok last season.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Eric the Half a Bee

How long is a piece of string?

I remember in 2006 us signing McPhail from a League 1 club, Roger Johnson from League 2 Wycombe, Loovens was an unknown at Feyenoord, Willo Flood an unknown at Man City, Chopra an unknown at Newcastle, McNaughton from Aberdeen. We were top 6 for most of the season.

---

Bravo.

Let's see what happens.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ccfcwelshlad

Exactly, too much emphasis about where players are signing from. Luton signed a mixed bag of players (bit of a presumption on my part but they would've been on a tiny budget) and they did ok last season.

---

Same as Huddersfield.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Eric the Half a Bee

How long is a piece of string?

I remember in 2006 us signing McPhail from a League 1 club, Roger Johnson from League 2 Wycombe, Loovens was an unknown at Feyenoord, Willo Flood an unknown at Man City, Chopra an unknown at Newcastle, McNaughton from Aberdeen. We were top 6 for most of the season.

---

Chopra wasn’t unknown by any means

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by StraightOuttaCanton

Chopra wasn’t unknown by any means

---

Thought he was a reserve player? Might remember it wrong been a while.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by dembethewarrior

Thought he was a reserve player? Might remember it wrong been a while.

---

He was, but not unknown. Had been on loan and scored consistently if I remember. Media also bigged him up. Was also an exciting signing at the time (for me anyway)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by StraightOuttaCanton

He was, but not unknown. Had been on loan and scored consistently if I remember. Media also bigged him up. Was also an exciting signing at the time (for me anyway)

---

Fair enough I don't remember as much as you, just looked up some stats on flashscores app after searching his name

Edit. Just looked played 21 games in the league over 4 seasons scoring 1 and played 2 champions league games for them in 02/03 he came on 84th minute against leverkusen and the same against Barcelona 84th minute same sub Lua Lua.

So the 2 sub appearances on live score are subs..I'd wager most of his 21 in the league in 4 years were 2 I just can't be arsed to check, was easy to look up just the 2.

Just shows Newcastle for the 4 years, no loans in between but they could be wrong

Edit again..just looking he had a few loans Watford forest Barnsley.. OK OK I concede

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by dembethewarrior

Fair enough I don't remember as much as you, just looked up some stats on flashscores app after searching his name

Edit. Just looked played 21 games in the league over 4 seasons scoring 1 and played 2 champions league games for them in 02/03 he came on 84th minute against leverkusen and the same against Barcelona 84th minute same sub Lua Lua.

So the 2 sub appearances on live score are subs..I'd wager most of his 21 in the league in 4 years were 2 I just can't be arsed to check, was easy to look up just the 2.

Just shows Newcastle for the 4 years, no loans in between but they could be wrong

---

I’m pretty sure he was on loan at Barnsley before we signed him and scored frequently which is why I remember being excited

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by StraightOuttaCanton

I’m pretty sure he was on loan at Barnsley before we signed him and scored frequently which is why I remember being excited

---

Yeah I was looking on "career" not "transfers" on the app stupidly. He scored 17 in 42 games. Concede again :hehe:

Bottom 6 ?

I went to a Supporters Trust social evening last night where Rob Phillips and Jason Perry did a Q&A session and their view was that there is a degree of risk in most of the players we have signed so far. Can those signed from lower divisions step up? Some are evidently are a punt, will it work ? Can Morison find the right combination mould them into a team ready for the season ? Given the signings so far their view was that staying up would be a result and anything else a bonus. Of course, further signings might change their view

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Enoch Mort

I went to a Supporters Trust social evening last night where Rob Phillips and Jason Perry did a Q&A session and their view was that there is a degree of risk in most of the players we have signed so far. Can those signed from lower divisions step up? Some are evidently are a punt, will it work ? Can Morison find the right combination mould them into a team ready for the season ? Given the signings so far their view was that staying up would be a result and anything else a bonus. Of course, further signings might change their view

---

We have signed the low hanging fruit so far. The more difficult hardened Championship pros and premier league loanees are yet to come. Could be as many as 7/8 more to come.
Best to reserve judgement until we see those coming through.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Former Labour leader

We have signed the low hanging fruit so far. The more difficult hardened Championship pros and premier league loanees are yet to come. Could be as many as 7/8 more to come.
Best to reserve judgement until we see those coming through.

---

Those are the ones that will stir the public's interest (GB excluded). They don't even have to be highly sought after, just good solid pros like Don Cowie, players that will give the team balance and experience and can be relied upon to help knit the side together.

I dont believe the championship is actually very good quality wise.

If you look at teams like swansea luton and Huddersfield they have been able to do pretty well over the years with players who played in leagues 1 and 2. Many many more examples and players and whole teams who have made the step up. If they click then no reason a team of league 1 and 2 players etc cant get promoted in this league.