+ Visit Cardiff FC for Latest News, Transfer Gossip, Fixtures and Match Results
Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 25 of 44

Thread: Keep, Maybe, Ditch.

Hybrid View

Previous Post Previous Post   Next Post Next Post
  1. #1

    Keep, Maybe, Ditch.

    Well done to all and particularly the last few weeks.
    We need to move on and get stronger and some players will inevitably have to go as well as the loanees.

    Smithies Keep. Keep, keep.
    Etheridge. Maybe. Sell at the right price.
    Bacuna. Keep
    Morrision. Keep
    Nelson Keep.
    Bennett. Keep
    Bamba Keep as a player / coach
    Flint Keep.
    Ralls Keep
    Tomlin Keep
    Vaulks Keep
    Pack Ditch
    Whyte. Don’t know.
    Hoilett. Sadly, time to ditch.
    Mendez Laing. Ditch.
    Murphy. Barring a big transition, ditch.
    Paterson. Maybe.
    Ward. Keep
    Glatzel. Keep
    Vassell. Ditch.
    Cunningham. Don’t know.

    We need a right back. Another playmaker or two and a 20 a season goal scorer......easy.

  2. #2

    Re: Keep, Maybe, Ditch.

    I think that you made a mistake at
    Flint as you put Keep but really meant Ditch.

  3. #3

    Re: Keep, Maybe, Ditch.

    Quote Originally Posted by Bobby Dandruff View Post
    I think that you made a mistake at
    Flint as you put Keep but really meant Ditch.
    To be honest. Not sure re Flint. If we could replace him with better then yes, ditch.

  4. #4

    Re: Keep, Maybe, Ditch.

    Get rid of Pack, Flint, Vassell, Whyte and Etheridge

    I wouldn't be totally opposed to getting rid of Bennett or Cunningham to free up some cash.

    Need a right back and a creative midfielder. I think that should be the priority, not another striker

  5. #5

    Re: Keep, Maybe, Ditch.

    Getting rid of Bennett and Glatzel would be my first order of business

  6. #6

    Re: Keep, Maybe, Ditch.

    Smithies - Keep
    Etheridge - Sell
    Bacuna - Keep
    Morrision - Keep
    Nelson - Keep
    Bennett - Keep
    Bamba - Keep as a player / coach
    Flint - Ditch if possible
    Ralls - Keep but jury is out
    Tomlin - Keep
    Vaulks - Keep but jury is out
    Pack - Ditch
    Whyte - Ditch
    Hoilett - Keep
    Mendez Laing - Ditch
    Murphy - Ditch
    Paterson - Ditch
    Ward - Keep as a sub
    Glatzel - Ditch. Not good enough.
    Vassell - Ditch
    Cunningham - Ditch

  7. #7

    Re: Keep, Maybe, Ditch.

    Quote Originally Posted by Eric the Half a Bee View Post
    Ralls - Keep but jury is out

    Vaulks - Keep but jury is out

    These are both INCREDIBLY harsh and I disagree in the strongest possible terms

  8. #8

    Re: Keep, Maybe, Ditch.

    Smithies Keep.
    Etheridge. Maybe.
    Bacuna. ?
    Morrision. ?
    Nelson Keep.
    Bennett. bye
    Bamba bye bye bamba
    Flint bye
    Ralls ?
    Tomlin Keep
    Vaulks Keep
    Pack bye
    Whyte. bye
    Hoilett. ?
    Mendez Laing. ?
    Murphy. bye
    Paterson. bye
    Ward. bye
    Glatzel. bye
    Vassell. bye

    ? = not sure

  9. #9

    Re: Keep, Maybe, Ditch.

    Quote Originally Posted by ToTaL ITK View Post
    Smithies Keep.
    Etheridge. Maybe.
    Bacuna. ?
    Morrision. ?
    Nelson Keep.
    Bennett. bye
    Bamba bye bye bamba
    Flint bye
    Ralls ?
    Tomlin Keep
    Vaulks Keep
    Pack bye
    Whyte. bye
    Hoilett. ?
    Mendez Laing. ?
    Murphy. bye
    Paterson. bye
    Ward. bye
    Glatzel. bye
    Vassell. bye

    ? = not sure
    Bit of a rebuilding job then. You'd keep 4 players from a squad that just finished fifth?

  10. #10

    Re: Keep, Maybe, Ditch.

    Quote Originally Posted by Eric the Half a Bee View Post
    Bit of a rebuilding job then. You'd keep 4 players from a squad that just finished fifth?
    ah come on ..possibly 9 with ?
    i'm no expert i just say what i see, but we must rebuild the side if we want prolonged success

  11. #11

    Re: Keep, Maybe, Ditch.

    Smithies Keep
    Etheridge. Sell
    Day. Keep
    Bacuna. Keep
    Morrision. Keep
    Nelson Keep
    Bennett. Keep
    Bamba Keep
    Flint Sell
    Ralls Keep
    Tomlin Keep
    Vaulks Keep
    Pack Ditch
    Whyte. Sell
    Hoilett. 50:50
    Mendez Laing. Keep
    Murphy. Perhaps a move might be best but sell if we get a good offer
    Paterson. Maybe.
    Ward. Sell
    Glatzel. Sell if we get a good offer
    Vassell. Stuck with him
    Cunningham. Sell if we get a good offer

  12. #12

    Re: Keep, Maybe, Ditch.

    How are we planning to get rid of all these players who aren't out of contract? They'll be earning good money with us and most clubs below the Premier League aren't going to be handing out bumper deals with the current uncertainty due to coronavirus. Perhaps loaning a few players out and recouping some of their wages is more realistic?

  13. #13

    Re: Keep, Maybe, Ditch.

    I’d get rid of

    Pack
    Glatzel
    Whyte
    Bennett
    Vassell
    Etheridge
    Day
    Flint

    I would say Cunningham too, but I’d like to see what he’s like at this level. As we’ve only really seen him in the Premier, where like most, he was out of his depth.

    I’d also question the value of Ralls, who’s been pretty anonymous, other than the odd set piece delivery. He’s slow, one paced, can’t pick a killer pass, and has little influence on the game.The team needs two full backs, a creative midfield player who can contribute consistently, unlike Tomlin who isn’t match fit three years down the line, and a striker.

    For those moaning about us being linked with Keifer Moore, I’d take him for £2 million. He’s a far bigger goal threat, than anything we have.

  14. #14

    Re: Keep, Maybe, Ditch.

    Quote Originally Posted by Bluebird23 View Post
    I’d get rid of

    Pack
    Glatzel
    Whyte
    Bennett
    Vassell
    Etheridge
    Day
    Flint

    I would say Cunningham too, but I’d like to see what he’s like at this level. As we’ve only really seen him in the Premier, where like most, he was out of his depth.

    I’d also question the value of Ralls, who’s been pretty anonymous, other than the odd set piece delivery. He’s slow, one paced, can’t pick a killer pass and has little influence on the game.



    The team needs two full backs, a creative midfield player whi can contribute consistently, unlike Tomlin who isn’t match fit three years down the line, and a striker.

    For those moaning about us being linked with Keizer Moore, I’d take him fir £2 million. He’s a far bigger goal threat than anything we have.
    For once I totally agree with you. 100%

  15. #15

    Re: Keep, Maybe, Ditch.

    Quote Originally Posted by LeningradCowboy View Post
    How are we planning to get rid of all these players who aren't out of contract? They'll be earning good money with us and most clubs below the Premier League aren't going to be handing out bumper deals with the current uncertainty due to coronavirus. Perhaps loaning a few players out and recouping some of their wages is more realistic?
    Agree and we should also be using the loan market to fill a couple of key places. Not Sanderson and Smith but show a bit more ambition with better players. Swansea are managing to do it very well. I am hoping Harris May have some connections in and around London (not Millwall)

  16. #16

    Re: Keep, Maybe, Ditch.

    Ralls ? Keep , times 10

  17. #17

    Re: Keep, Maybe, Ditch.

    At the right price everyone is ditchable. We are a selling club.

    Will be interesting to see this transfer market as I genuinely haven’t got a clue who will take a risk

  18. #18

    Re: Keep, Maybe, Ditch.

    Quote Originally Posted by WJ99mobile View Post
    At the right price everyone is ditchable. We are a selling club.

    Will be interesting to see this transfer market as I genuinely haven’t got a clue who will take a risk
    Hopefully Boro will spend millions here.

  19. #19

    Re: Keep, Maybe, Ditch.

    Quote Originally Posted by Eric the Half a Bee View Post
    Hopefully Boro will spend millions here.
    THIS is everyone’s hope lol 👍

  20. #20

    Re: Keep, Maybe, Ditch.

    Quote Originally Posted by Eric the Half a Bee View Post
    For once I totally agree with you. 100%
    I do too but depends on value. Bennett and Glatzel will be solid for us when called upon but If we can get a good fee for either, crack on. Both don’t fully fit into our style but I’m not 100% sure where NH is likely to take us style wise

    Value over ability.

  21. #21

    Re: Keep, Maybe, Ditch.

    Quote Originally Posted by WJ99mobile View Post
    Bennett and Glatzel will be solid for us when called upon.
    Bennett and Glatzel aren’t solid for us, and that’s why they should be offloaded.

    I don’t recall every seeing one defender as culpable for so many goals, as Bennett.

    He switches off, loses his man, often tackles with the ‘wrong’ foot.

    That kamikaze tackle he tried to make when Morrison was already closing the man down, that led to the Derby goal.

    He’s a liability. Some people are fooled in to thinking he’s a good because he has good hair and a tattoo sleeve, but he isn’t.

    Glatzel is beyond hopeless, a German Madine.

    Weak, slow, ineffectual, he did nothing when he came on, had one chance to be a hero, and fluffed his lines again.

    He is not a natural goal scorer, and when he moves on it’ll be for an undisclosed fee, as there is zero chance of us getting £5 million back for him.

    Fair play to Warnock, nearly £12 million wasted on two absolute duds in Madine and Glatzel.

  22. #22

    Re: Keep, Maybe, Ditch.

    Quote Originally Posted by Bluebird23 View Post
    Bennett and Glatzel aren’t solid for us, and that’s why they should be offloaded.

    I don’t recall every seeing one defender as culpable for so many goals, as Bennett.

    He switches off, loses his man, often tackles with the ‘wrong’ foot.

    That kamikaze tackle he tried to make when Morrison was already closing the man down, that led to the Derby goal.

    He’s a liability. Some people are fooled in to thinking he’s a good because he has good hair and a tattoo sleeve, but he isn’t.

    Glatzel is beyond hopeless, a German Madine.

    Weak, slow, ineffectual, he did nothing when he came on, had one chance to be a hero, and fluffed his lines again.

    He is not a natural goal scorer, and when he moves on it’ll be for an undisclosed fee, as there is zero chance of us getting £5 million back for him.

    Fair play to Warnock, nearly £12 million wasted on two absolute duds in Madine and Glatzel.
    Don't say that to Dembewarrior

  23. #23

    Re: Keep, Maybe, Ditch.

    Quote Originally Posted by Bluebird23 View Post
    Bennett and Glatzel aren’t solid for us, and that’s why they should be offloaded.

    I don’t recall every seeing one defender as culpable for so many goals, as Bennett.

    He switches off, loses his man, often tackles with the ‘wrong’ foot.

    That kamikaze tackle he tried to make when Morrison was already closing the man down, that led to the Derby goal.

    He’s a liability. Some people are fooled in to thinking he’s a good because he has good hair and a tattoo sleeve, but he isn’t.

    Glatzel is beyond hopeless, a German Madine.

    Weak, slow, ineffectual, he did nothing when he came on, had one chance to be a hero, and fluffed his lines again.

    He is not a natural goal scorer, and when he moves on it’ll be for an undisclosed fee, as there is zero chance of us getting £5 million back for him.

    Fair play to Warnock, nearly £12 million wasted on two absolute duds in Madine and Glatzel.
    As you say, Bennett certainly 'looks' the part of a footballer, but that's where it ends. He gets turned inside out too often, backs off constantly and as you also pointed out.. tackles with the 'wrong" foot.

    Glatzel is as weak as a kitten, playing in arguably the most physical league in the world.

    Time for both to go.

  24. #24

    Re: Keep, Maybe, Ditch.

    Quote Originally Posted by Rock_Flock_of_Five View Post
    As you say, Bennett certainly 'looks' the part of a footballer, but that's where it ends. He gets turned inside out too often, backs off constantly and as you also pointed out.. tackles with the 'wrong" foot.

    Glatzel is as weak as a kitten, playing in arguably the most physical league in the world.

    Time for both to go.
    Argue away please. I see overpaid fancy dans diving every other tackle. F'ing MLS is more physical than this league.

  25. #25

    Re: Keep, Maybe, Ditch.

    Smithies - Keep
    Etheridge - Ditch
    Bacuna - Keep
    Morrision - Keep
    Nelson - Keep
    Bennett - Keep
    Bamba - Keep
    Flint - Ditch
    Ralls - Keep
    Tomlin - Keep
    Vaulks - Keep
    Pack - Ditch
    Whyte - Ditch
    Hoilett - Keep
    Mendez Laing - Keep
    Murphy - Ditch
    Paterson - Ditch
    Ward - Keep
    Glatzel - Keep
    Vassell - Ditch
    Cunningham - Keep

    Then I'd bring in a RB, CM, Winger, ST. Sorted.

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •